Hi sweetpea
That is the biggest question you and I will have and will properly never get a definitive answer to. For people that cheat the truth about their own action is very unpalatable for them to face. I think that generally they can be put into two categories. Cheaters that are totally self centred and selfish that genuinely put their wants ahead everyone else’s feeling without caring what damage they might do and will keep doing it. The second type is every other person that cheats. This includes stupid, immature, immoral, weak, carless, greedy; the list could go on. The main difference with the second type of person is that when they get caught they wish they had never cheated on the person they loved because they can see the hurt and damage that they have caused. I don’t know what I would think of myself if I had caused someone to suffer they way I have and so many others have suffered by a cheating partner.
The fact that your boyfriend is very remorseful is a good sign. But as I have said before on this forum you have to education him in what is going on with you and what he has to do to put it right. He will want to forget about it like all cheaters because this is the quickest way not to face the truth about their actions. Which is they did the nastiest, most hurtful thing to the person who loved them that they could possibly do.
Unfortunately for him you can not put it behind you and just forget it. The obsessing over the thoughts is normal. Just read some stories posted here, we all suffer dreadfully from them. So how to move on. My advise (this is just my opinion,I am still trying to rebuild myself after being totally destroyed by my wife’s affair) is without judgment or punishment explain everything you feel. Tell him you will have to return to this again and again but it is not to rub his face in it. You have to do this to heal. You need him to be your rock. You are the one that has to do all the work but he has to be there every step of the way fully supporting you and never questioning you.
I told my wife the sense of loneliness was terrible. She said “why, I am here”. She just did not understand. I know I don’t have to explain the feeling of loneliness to anyone who has been cheated on. I have to explain and teach my wife as I work my way through my healing. If you boyfriend is truly remorseful he will do right thing by you. You may have to take a blind leap of faith giving that your trust has been destroyed but hopefully given time everything can be fixed.
Good Luck
John9575