-
My story…
So here’s my long… painful… confusing story. I’ve been with my now-husband since 2014. We broke up in early 2015 because of “emotional cheating” and deceit. He performed that he turned himself around, I wanted to fall for it, he got me back and we got married October 2015. I found just earlier this year, he had downloaded a dating app just 2 months after we got married, when things were very “honeymoon” and good, in December 2015. He “emotionally” cheated with no face strangers (craigslist) and ex girlfriends until I found a bunch of evidence late 2018. Things have always been super high highs, and really low lows for us. I’m on my second marriage and I think part of my draw to him is the stark difference between him and my first husband. (Side note, I was the emotional cheater in my first marriage. I looked at what I was doing, decided the distance between my then husband was too great, and pushed for divorce.)
After discovering evidence in late 2018 of shady shit stemming back years, he was sorry, remorseful, said all the right things and we were “back”. Then, April this year I found he sent a love song to an ex-client of his who had “fallen in love with him and he couldn’t help that.” This was right after we had said we were recommitting. The night I saw that, I had leaned over to kiss his shoulder and looked down to his screen. He tried denying it, then turned it on me, “your love language changed”, “you neglect me”. He can’t really explain why he sent the love song, or more likely, doesn’t want to. And thinking back, I don’t really know why I let him back in. But I did. And I recommited hard and thought he did too. We signed a contract May 31 on a brand new home. June 14th, he takes me into our bedroom and says something happened. A client of another trainer he had become friends with tried to kiss him. He immediately stopped it. Up to this point, he had NEVER been forthcoming with information even after he had been caught. The classic “only admits to what he knows I know.” But, if he hadn’t told me this, I would not have known anything. Any evidence on his side was long gone and he and the woman had taken steps to make sure the other husband couldn’t/wouldn’t reach out to me. So… him telling me about this hit me as a demonstration of real change.
The husband of this woman wanted to have a conversation with my husband and I decided to go. I find out at that sit-down there was more to it (duh). They had had a few sexting conversations and been “emotionally” cheating since March. It stopped during the COVID quarantine while they both ‘worked on their marriages’, which is when he sent the love song to his client.
After seeing some, but not all the inappropriate conversation screenshots, I was done. I had printed and filled out divorce papers. This was just too many times. And his previous excuses didn’t apply.
But… somehow, I was sucked back in. Again, he said all the right things (ironic because in one of the last conversations between my Husband and this gym woman she said that exact thing… “you said all the right things”). I wanted our new home, our new life.
Here are the reasons I can pinpoint why I’ve stayed:
I was once an emotional cheater. It was discovered and it turned me on my head. I have had ZERO desire to do anything of that kind since. If that’s possible for me, is it possible for him?
Not romantic, but I don’t love the idea of giving him half my hard earned earnings. The logical side of me knows this doesn’t hold weight because I’m choosing money over my life. But if he could be believed, I wouldn’t have to lose either.
He offered, scheduled and attended therapy. Probably a total of 6 sessions till the therapist gave him the stamp of recovery.
He deleted his social media accounts. His phone addiction has been a problem in our marriage since the beginning so this was a big deal.
He demonstrated awareness of his behavior. He would feel neglect from me and turn to someone else. He said how wrong that was especially because so much of my frustration in our marriage has been because he just doesn’t step up, doesn’t do basic things that a good partner does in a marriage.
I’m obviously battling with severe insecurities.
Fast forward to November, 2020. I’m feeling fine about things but occasionally snoop on his phone. I find venmo payments of $.01 from her. She just asked a question about a song and he had ignored it. But… this reminded me that clear back 5 days after this came out in June, she had sent me a YouTube video on Facebook I had never watched. Well, smart or not, I watched it. It was just a recording of her talking to her soon to be ex-husband, begging him not to send me anything else. “With what she has now, they can work through this.” “Don’t send her anything more.”
There was a little talk back in June wondering if they had actually had sex but it wasn’t obvious. And maybe the idea of that was too painful so I avoided really thinking about it. But right after it came out, my husband and the woman were exchanging “I’ve ruined my life, poor me” messages and she mentioned they had sex. His responses to her were surprised. “Oh really? We did? When? Where did this happen?” Then it was discovered the husband was using the wife’s account to message my husband. It didn’t strike me at the time that his response lent suspicion to them actually getting physical.
Anyway, listening to that recording, I think… “there’s more. Did they have sex?” I foolishly messaged the husband, who had sent me the screenshots months before, “I know this is so stupid to bring up after so much time but, did your wife and my husband have sex?”
I then asked my husband “Did you have sex with her?” and he lost-his-shit. Threatened to leave, threw his rings, shouted the roof down. Said “I have done nothing. I have worked so hard to be the perfect husband these 6 months and now you bring this up? No I didn’t have sex with her but if my effort means nothing then what are we doing?” It shook me. I felt horrible. I sent a quick message back to this husband “Nevermind. Please ignore.” That didn’t work. The next morning, the husband blew up my phone with “Yes they had sex. They are still having sex. Talk to my ex and she will tell you.”
You may be asking yourself, “why at this point does it matter if they f*cked?”. It matters because I could confidently walk away. May not make all the sense, but it matters.
I show my husband all the messages. He denies it. He encourages me to talk to the woman… so I do. To make a long long part of the story short, she told me they did have sex, about 5 times, gave me details. But.. those details didn’t sync. She couldn’t answer simple questions that could prove her right, and she does have strong motivation to hurt us both. What motivation? The man she fell for, talked of leaving her husband and family for, used her and chose me. I looked my husband dead in the eye and said “Do you realize what a piece of shit, horrible, disgusting person you would have to be to continue to lie about having sex with her? You’d be keeping me in a marriage through deceit.” He remained firm, they did not have sex. I also tried “I will stay with you, please just be honest so I know you are capable of being honest.” Still, they didn’t have sex. I offered to give him all my stock, the new house, anything he wanted for the truth. He did not budge. They did not have sex.
A few days later, he recorded confronting her at the gym. He asked “So we had sex huh?” She just responded with “go away”, “f*ck you”, and “leave me alone”. She never said they did while talking to him. I would have thought she would say something like “Just grow up and be honest with your wife.” or “You know we did, she has a right to know.” Or something…
Bottom line, I don’t think they had sex. You may think me naive. But evidence from before and more details then I can get into here, I don’t think they had sex. Was there more than what I saw, what he has admitted to? Abso-f*cking-lutely.
So to add to my list of reasons above, I haven’t called it quits because it supposedly has not gotten physical with anyone. Believe me, I’ve wrapped myself in knots going in circles with “So you’re not willing to live with physically cheating, but willing to live with repeated emotional cheating?”
I’m obviously not over it. Any of it. And moving forward with him before fully processing is on me. I made the mistake of attempting to work through all my emotions “with” him. Resulted in a big blow out fight and him attempting the same manipulation tactics, my insecurities surfacing when it seems he wants to end it. So I started a book which suggested I find a community that may help me work through all of this. So here I am. Hurting, confused and exhausted.
Log in to reply.