Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Members Stories › How much is too much?

  • How much is too much?

    Posted by melyy on June 15, 2021 at 3:33 am

    We all found this site for one main reason, infidelity. So I just want to know this, how much is too much when finding out what happened between your partner and his mistress? Is it best to know everything or just know the affair happened and do your best to move on from there. I don’t have all the pieces, and quite frankly I’m scared to know everything. It makes sick and my anxiety spikes so high that I feel like passing out. Is it worth it to know the whole story? Or should I just cope with what I already have and not seek more?

    What did you choose; the entire story or just knowing the affair happened was enough?

    And was the outcome worth it to know it all or to know little of it?

    replied 5 years, 5 months ago 7 Members · 11 Replies
  • 11 Replies
  • hearbroken

    Member
    June 15, 2021 at 4:24 am

    I don’t know too many details about the affair. My husband just gets angry when I ask questions. He says we are just going in a circle. Most of what I know is what I can piece together from little things I look back on now. He’s talked about why he had the affair and that he didn’t love her and she knew there was no future with him. He won’t talk about what happened, what was going through his mind . I don’t think the details of their sex life will help me, but the details of what was in his mind might. It must be so bad, he fears I will leave if he tells me. Maybe it would be for the best.

  • eliza4one

    Member
    June 15, 2021 at 4:24 am

    My belief is that each person is different in what they need to know in order to heal.

    For me, my mind wanders and gets out of control about things if I don’t know the full story. My imagination goes wild.

    So, I have to ask. Thankfully, my husband gets that about me and will answer my questions. Granted, it can take some time to get it out of him…”It probably happened” is synonymous with “It did happen”, so I have to dig deeper/push harder, and I do. I don’t care if he’s uncomfortable. He did it. He can own up to it.

    Cait described it as desensitizing what happened. I thought that explained it really well in my case.

    For us, it is working. I’m not sure it would for all couples. It could also be that our situation is different. We are separated and focused only on healing right now (me from the affair and he from his childhood/what led him to the affair). We have decided to focus on us as a couple (if we both choose that) further down the road. That might make a difference(?).

    I look forward to reading everyone’s answers.

    I would say if it makes you ill, then do as you’ve been doing!

  • tara81

    Member
    June 15, 2021 at 6:17 am

    I want to know it all but when he does tell me things I’m not sure I believe it. I’m working on letting go. Pushing for more after 9 months of Dday is not helping me at all. Random questions pop in my head all the time but I don’t think that the answers will help. Sometimes I think that I keep asking hoping that one day it will make sense but it never will. I’m focusing on moving on and I’m so mad at myself for giving that whore one more minute of my time. He has to live with the shame not me.

  • linds

    Member
    June 15, 2021 at 7:54 am

    I needed to know everything. It hurt hearing it though and now I don’t know if it was the best thing or not. I really felt like in order to move on either with him or without him I needed to know as much as possible so that I could make an educated decision. I honestly still don’t know what my decision is. Somedays I just feel like such a sucker for staying. Like I had to set aside all my morals and beliefs to accept what he did.

    I think if you feel the need to know then as hard as it is its best to ask the questions. I couldn’t handle the not knowing and the always wondering. My imagination could make up things way worse then the actual truth.

  • eliza4one

    Member
    June 15, 2021 at 9:14 am

    linds~You and I are so much alike in our thinking/needs for healing/questioning our ability to forgive.

    This is so true for me, too: I think if you feel the need to know then as hard as it is its best to ask the questions. I couldn’t handle the not knowing and the always wondering. My imagination could make up things way worse then the actual truth.

    I truly don’t know that I can forgive my husband. I know I’m going to have to for my own sake, but what that will look like…I’m not sure. Do I have to someday tell him I’ve forgiven him or can I just keep it to myself, ha!? (Somewhat of a joke, but…could be the truth, too).

    As far as the morals and beliefs aspect, and the shame…I’ve not struggled with that yet and i wonder if it is because I haven’t (or we haven’t) decided what we are going to do yet with regards to our marriage. Quite a few people in my life know about the affair, but they don’t know to the degree that my husband and I are working together on our individual healing. I wonder if they knew, would they judge me and then would I feel shame? I guess I’ll know when it happens.

    Since you are unsure about whether you can forgive him and whether you can make your marriage last, you should definitely focus on you as much as possible. About the only thing I’ve liked about living in my condo, separate from him, is that I have had the chance to be by myself, find out my true likes/dislikes, find new hobbies, become more outgoing, etc. I know you have kids still at home, so that makes it harder, but baby steps. Rediscover who you are, even as you continue raising your children.

    I so admire you. Your strength and your honesty with regards to this whole situation!

  • melyy

    Member
    June 15, 2021 at 10:26 pm

    I’m in the same boat. I pieced a lot together but he also gave me some information. But in all honesty not really sure how much of it’s true you know. I feel my partner is sheltering me from the 100% truth. He knows Ive left previous partners that have cheated on me in a heartbeat. A part of me does feel like of I know the whole story I will never be able to let go of the pain or forgive.

  • melyy

    Member
    June 15, 2021 at 10:30 pm

    Oh I am definitely my worst enemy. I will come up with every scenario possible and the truth is probably not as bad. I guess I feel if I know everything I will lose the love I have for him. Maybe that might be good to move on but for the sake of our son and how long we have dedicated our time and life to this relationship I don’t want to just let it go although I feel foolish for staying.

  • melyy

    Member
    June 15, 2021 at 10:35 pm

    Ugh I know exactly what you mean! Those random questions come at horrible times too! Like today when we were at a graduation and a time he wanted to take me out to a scenic spot because he’s trying to rekindle what we once had. It’s always horrible timing. Sometimes I ask, sometimes I bite my tongue because as you said it may not help at all. It’s just holding onto the pain and anger.

  • melyy

    Member
    June 15, 2021 at 10:37 pm

    My fear is knowing everything and it becoming so overwhelming that I never heal. It’s so hard to decide which way to go because I want to be with him but how can I develop a healthy relationship if I never heal because I “know too much”.

  • lilly0792

    Member
    June 17, 2021 at 12:21 pm

    Being 2 years out- I’m glad I did not go for the details. I knew what I needed to know – and frankly- for any woman: he will NEVER tell you the whole truth anyway. Ever.

    So- IMO- there is no reason to torture yourself with details. I know what she wrote in texts that I saw and I can never forget them. The details I know are annoying. They don’t go away. But they also don’t matter or mean anything. My husband and Florida Slut- they don’t remember the details. So- here I am. Two years later- The only person who knows or cares.

    I am VERY HAPPY that I never pushed for more. That I never found more texts. Because I wouldn’t have divorced him. I would just be stuck with more memorized details that I don’t want. Unless you think you are honestly making a decision to stay or go- and willing to go- then I wouldn’t ask for more details.

    Well- I guess I would make an exception: the sexual details could be fun to through back in the whore’s face. Letting her know you know about intimate details would make her sick.

    Not worth it for me- but that’s the only reason or purpose they could possible serve.

  • jasminerose

    Member
    June 17, 2021 at 3:11 pm

    Being the “cheater” I found it difficult to give all the details in one go. For fear of rejection, shame, protection for me. Eventually it all came out and I wish I had just done it because me keeping things back just prolonged the agony. If you feel you need to know, try to get him to tell you it all in one fell swoop and keep to facts. Short statements maybe of info. Just remember even though he is an asshole for cheating he is still going through something and will need coaxing to share more details. Xx

Log in to reply.