Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Members Stories › Not sure if I can believe him…..

  • Not sure if I can believe him…..

    Posted by tara81 on June 30, 2021 at 9:56 pm

    It’s been 10 months since dday, so I decided to ask everything I wanted to ask. From the beginning he has been telling me that he had no feelings for her. But I’ve been stuck in how can he not feel anything for her. The affair lasted on/off for 4+ years. Tonight he answered all my questions, I think honestly. It doesn’t seem like he put much thought into what he was doing. They didn’t give each other gifts, didn’t do anything together. I asked him what attracted him to her and he said opportunity, and she was available. He said she was threatening him with telling me if he didn’t continue contact with her. I am so scared to believe that it meant nothing. I told him that when I look back at pictures from the last six years all I see is lies. He said that it’s in my head because he was happy to go on vacation with me and that he enjoyed doing things with me. I was so blindsided by the affair, that I am afraid to believe him. He said that even before I found out about the affair, he had started to grow from his mistake. He said that with time I will see that he will never do this to me again and that I can trust him. I have come to the conclusion that maybe I just don’t want to let it go. That I am afraid to trust that he won’t hurt me again. I just want to be happy and not feel like a fool. Hope everyone is making progress.

    replied 5 years, 4 months ago 5 Members · 12 Replies
  • 12 Replies
  • linds

    Member
    July 1, 2021 at 4:53 am

    Your story is so much like mine except the affair only lasted a few months in my situation. My husband says very similar – it was opportunity, he never bought her anything not even a coffee, they never spent any time outside of work together until the sex on the business trip. Like yours he says he never had actual feelings for her it was just sex. I feel the same as you, how do I believe him? And how does someone just decide to betray the person they love just for sex. How do I believe he loved me while carrying on a affair and having sex. I look back at the last six years and think the same thing as you. All those holidays and vacations that I thought were good, where I thought we were happy and he had this secret. He swears he was happy and wanted to be there with me and the kids but the doubt will always be there for me. I try not to look at the pictures anymore. It just makes me sad. I actually deleted all the pictures of the two of us. I only kept the family ones. I feel like everything he said to me since the affair was a lie. Anytime he told me he loved me, or that he was happy. I guess at some point we have no other option but to believe them and move on with life.

  • hearbroken

    Member
    July 1, 2021 at 5:04 am

    I feel the same way. I don’t know if I can believe him and it is so hard to let it go. Right now he is so loving and concerned, and I keep thinking back to everything and analyzing it.

    It still makes no sense to me. If he truly loved me and wanted to be with me, how could he lie to me and be with her?

    If he no longer loved me or lost his desire for me, why didn’t he ask for a divorce? I would have been upset, but not this devastated. At least I would have had the opportunity to move on and find someone new.

    I want to be happy, but I can’t get out of my head. I remember one time when my son was driving him nuts and he kept threatening to move out and kept saying,” your next husband won’t be able to tolerate this either. ” I truly believe he fell out of love with me and planned to leave, then at some point fell back in love with me, but had himself trapped in the relationship with the whore. Fear of losing her for the restaurant, fear of exposure and losing everything.

    He won’t answer anymore questions and I’m afraid to stress him out, because his heart arythmia is getting worse. I don’t want to give him a heart attack, but how can I forgive and let go if I don’t know exactly what I’m forgiving.

    I feel that he really loves me now, but is that enough? I also feel that he doesn’t love her now. He didn’t hesitate to break it off with her, even before I knew her identity. He did try to deny that it was her until I had the proof, so I don’t know if she would have been able to manipulate him back into the relationship if I hadn’t found the card.

    He was always insanely jealous and possessive with me. When I freaked out over my brother’s crush on her, he said that it would be good if they got together (I did not agree, I don’t care how difficult my brother is, he deservesbetter than a cast off whore). It does mean though that my husband has no problem with her moving on, no jealousy or possessiveness. So he must not have ever felt for her the way he felt for me. He’s probably also telling the truth that he’s been pushing her to find a real relationship.

    I don’t know what to do? I’m tired of being sad so much of the time.

  • elbl

    Member
    July 1, 2021 at 6:15 am

    I understand exactly how you feel. The use of the word opportunity seems to be a common theme. I don’t think I will ever understand how a person can love someone, marry them, promise them everything and then turn around and cheat because of opportunity. My husband always had lots of women friends. I had guys as best friends, so I understood that. Course the difference is I didn’t want to screw my guy friends, his didn’t share that opinion. Also, he had had sex with them all in the past. His 1st marriage was open. He could screw who ever he wanted and she didn’t care. When we were dating, we had that conversation many (stress many) times and he said he was done with that lifestyle. I believed him. Fast forward 15 years. Turned out that was a lie. He claims to have only had oral sex with the others the entire time we had been together. He said it was because I didn’t like it….no I just didn’t like how he did it and he didn’t take instructions that well, as he said no one else ever complained. So D day 9-6-19, he did have sex with one of the skanks…in our bed (which was replaced at his cost). I caught him on our cameras walking around the house naked with her. This was one particular skank that I disliked from the start and it was not a secret. After I had found out about the oral girls….she reached out to me to offer a shoulder to cry on. Not trusting her for 1 minute I asked why she said the only guy she would cheat on her husband with was my husband…she said she wouldn’t do that. He was one of her best friends and she respected our marriage. Fast forward 2 months and she popped over to our house and they screwed in our bed. He called her “available space” and that’s all. I showed him our online conversation and he said they were never that good of friends. When I look back on photos and even our wedding pictures (the skank was at our wedding and in lots of photos) I feel it was all one big lie.

  • tara81

    Member
    July 1, 2021 at 6:56 am

    It’s easier for me to give others advice than to take it myself. Women are emotional creatures by nature. We put emotions and thought into everything we do. We think about how others would feel and how our actions will affect our families, at least most of us do. Men in the other hand, do not need to have feelings attached. To most men, sex is just sex no emotions attached. After sex woman have the need to be held while men just want to roll over and sleep. According to him they didn’t even cuddle after sex, they just got up and left the motel. He said the were only in the motel for 15 minutes. Not sure if it was 15 minutes but it couldn’t have been long because he was home at his regular time. My point is that it seems like for him it was devoid of emotions. I know for her it was very emotional, she fell in love with him. I would have felt sorry for her, it it wasn’t for how she treated me. According to him she was the one paying for the rooms. I checked the cc bills and nothing was on it. In another group someone used the analogy that the AP were like a playground were they would go play and have a fantasy before going home to their real life. I’m trying hard to convince myself that our time together was not a lie. She was the lie. He has said to me many times that when a man loves another woman they leave their families for them. He said that he never saw a future with her or planned to leave me. I’m just afraid to believe him and look like a fool.

  • tara81

    Member
    July 1, 2021 at 7:25 am

    “how can I forgive and let go if I don’t know exactly what I’m forgiving.” Wow that line right there. I felt the same way. I guess what we are forgiving is the betrayal, the lack of common sense, the hurt they caused us. I have made peace with the fact that I will never know the truth 100%. Even if he does tell me I will always doubt what he tells me. I am learning to let go of the need to know every single detail. like your husband, my husband also refuses to answer my questions. For the last month or so I compiled questions and thoughts, and last night I sat down with him and told him I needed to talk to him. At the beginning, he was defensive but than he started to answer my questions. Before answering he said that how can we move on if I keep bringing up the past and that he eventually will get tire of his mistake being thrown on his face all the time. I get that. I wouldn’t like that either and if it’s what I am going to continue to do than it will be better to end it. I found some closure, but I also realize that he did what he did because he wanted and it made him feel validated. He put no thought into my feelings, her feelings or what the outcome might have been. I think his head was so far up his ass that he couldn’t see beyond his own selfish needs. I think it would be best for my mental health to focus on the now and on the future. I am enjoying this new stage in our marriage, even if that dark cloud is still over my head. Today I am making a new promise to myself to keep putting myself first. To figure out what else I want to do. I’m going to take a page from his book and not overthink things and just go with the flow. I am young enough to try new things and enjoy my life. Tomorrow is not promised so I am going to enjoy today. I don’t see him or her loosing sleep over the hurt they caused me, So why should I? Like I told him, he changed our story and that it’s something that he has to live with. I made it clear that if this were to happen again I would walk away without a second glance at him. My life is full outside of my marriage, I will be fine on my own. I will never go through this hell again. Heartbroken give yourself a break, it has only been two moths. It does get better with time. Time does heal all wounds.

  • tara81

    Member
    July 1, 2021 at 7:30 am

    That was my mistake that since I had male acquaintances, I didn’t see anything wrong with him having one. I thought he was nice for giving her rides home since she doesn’t have a car. It’s a common theme with cheaters, that the AP didn’t mean anything. But guess what, it does mean something. It means betrayal, it means hurting the person you are supposed to love and take care of. It means that you are a cheater and a liar. It means a lot of different things, but they can’t seem to understand just how damaging the betrayal is. I made peace with the fact that I will never understand what happened and I thinks at this point it doesn’t matter anymore. Elbl, I’m sorry that this happened to you.

  • eliza4one

    Member
    July 1, 2021 at 8:09 am

    So many thoughts…

    My situation is (slightly) different because my husband did fall in “love” with the OW. Cait mentioned limerence, which isn’t really love, per se. More of an infatuation. My husband says he was enamored with her because she came from such a similar background (childhood trauma), she “understood” him and he, her. They fell hard for each other. That much I know. He told her he loved her. He told me (early on during discovery) that he loved her. So, whether love or not, he had deep feelings and a deep connection with her. For him, that connection and love was more important than the sex. The sex was likely the “icing on the cake”. (He downplays the sex…says it wasn’t good, he kept thinking of me/the fact that he was married, he had tremendous guilt, that he felt “trapped” (“how does a man turn down sex? I would have looked like a loser and she wouldn’t have wanted to be with me.” he tells me), etc.) THAT is the part I’m not sure I believe…the rest of his story/stories, I believe. But with the full awareness that little lies are likely embedded within those stories.

    Unlike most people, I do need to know in order to forgive. Luckily, my husband is willing to answer any and all questions I have. That has been so helpful. I really have to process things in my brain before I can get over them. I’m really over everything except the sexual aspect. I’m an anomaly in that the emotional bond hurts way less than the sex they had. I HATE the fact that they were intimate together. I can live with the fact that she met his deep emotional needs.

    I do believe someone can love 2 people at once, especially if they fulfill different needs. I don’t think they should act upon it, but I do think it’s possible. I think that’s the case with my husband. While he did “step away” emotionally and physically during the time he was chatting it up with her, I never got the sense that he no longer loved me. Was it lessened? Yes. I did feel that.

    For everyone else that has posted on this thread, it does sound like your husbands were in it for the sex. Whereas my husband was in it for the emotional bond, feeling of being loved, understood etc. Doesn’t matter which is worse. And what is considered worse is in the heart and eye of the betrayed. No matter, wrong is wrong.

    Can I believe my husband? I don’t think any of us can fully, 100% believe our husbands about anything!!! No way. Even lies of omissions are lies. Even with the million questions I’ve asked, I can guarantee you that their are things he has left out. Little “minimizing” lies peppered throughout his explanations…I’m not stupid.

    The age old question of, “Will they cheat again?”. My belief is that there are no guarantees in life and human nature is fickle. My husband didn’t seek out this woman. They met via social media. Started chatting. Formed a bond. Strengthened that bond through zwifting. Met up in her home country. Further strengthened that bond through lunch dates/dinner dates, day trips, sex, etc…. So, while it wasn’t an intentional act, it was an act that happened by chance. By circumstances. By a chance encounter. He CHOSE to act upon it. He CHOSE to not stop it when he knew it was wrong. He’s a weak man for sure!

    Who’s to say that won’t/can’t happen again? People come into our lives all of the time…and weak people “fall” in situations that a stronger person wouldn’t fall for/into in the first place.

    Psyches are all different, as well. I know the psyche of my husband. If another woman came along and “met his need for ___________” he very well could fall for it again. I am fully aware of that. It’s what keeps me from heading straight back to the marriage.

    One of our agreements is that 1) He stop “helping/trying to help” other women. 2) He stop communicating closely with other women and 3) IF he does lapse into communicating with another woman and he feels it is crossing the line, we talk about it.

    Point #3… A weak person isn’t able to do that, imo. Sure, he can tell me he’s going to do it, but there is a point of no return and I don’t know that he’s savvy enough or strong enough to stop and tell me before he gets to that point of no return. For him, #2 is vital. This woman was like a drug for him. Another woman could come along and be that drug, as well. It’s up to him to stay away from the drug to begin with. (Yes-he comes from a family of alcoholics, so addiction and the fallout from that is a part of who he is).

    So, all that to say, no…we can’t fully believe our husbands/spouses. I will never believe that I fully can. Can we be okay with that? I’m not sure…

  • tara81

    Member
    July 1, 2021 at 12:06 pm

    I think for my own mental health, i have to be ok to never fully trust him. To be honest I don’t think I can ever fully trust another person again. I really trusted him and I was so wrong about him. Although, I know that he cheated for whatever selfish reasons he had and because she was available, my new mantra is he cheated because he simply wanted to. I don’t need to look deeper, I don’t need to find more reasons. He cheated because he wanted to. I didn’t do anything wrong. He could have fought harder to fix things between us. But the truth of the matter is that he was selfish and wanted to have his cake and eat it too. I will no longer bring myself down by thinking that I should have done something different. He cheated because he wanted to. He didn’t think about how much it would destroyed me. My decision to work on things is solely on what he can contribute to the marriage now. How he plans to keep things good between us. How he treats me now. He no longer has the luxury to just have his needs met, he no longer has the luxury to be lazy when it comes to our marriage. he cheated because he wanted to. I am a thoughtful partner and that will not change, I will not allow his decision to change who I am at the core. However, I am more aware of my needs and what I want and deserve. I am no longer afraid to be on my own. I am not hesitant to ask for what I want. I have a good life outside of my marriage. He cheated because he wanted to. I keep repeating that so that I drill it into my head. It’s crazy how much clarity I have now than even a week ago. His betrayal still hurts but I have clarity on what I need and who I am and want to be. I no longer cry daily and I feel genuine happiness more often than not. I can see a future with him now, but I also can see one without him. He cheated because he wanted to. Hope my rant makes sense.

  • hearbroken

    Member
    July 1, 2021 at 12:20 pm

    Tara81 you rant makes perfect sense. Ultimately that is the reason they all cheated. Because they wanted to. No one forced them. Whatever excuse they have, there were other options available. Cheating was the easy thing to do and they got to live out a fantasy.

    I guess I just have to discover within myself if I can live with that.

  • eliza4one

    Member
    July 1, 2021 at 12:41 pm

    I like that truth: He cheated because he wanted to. Truly it all boils down to that simple fact. Thank you! If you don’t mind I’m going to borrow that!!

  • tara81

    Member
    July 1, 2021 at 1:15 pm

    I do not mind at all.

  • tara81

    Member
    July 1, 2021 at 1:19 pm

    Take your time. One day you will feel a calmness and it will be clear to you whether you made the right decision or not. I know for me at the beginning I told myself that I would stay with him for a year whether I wanted to or not because I didn’t what to give his whore the satisfaction. Now I’m glad I stayed for other reasons. For me it’s no longer about them. It’s about me and what is best for me. I’m just going to enjoy the relationship that we are working hard to repair.

Log in to reply.