Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Members Stories › Wife Got Pregnant To Another Man – But I Still Love Her

  • Wife Got Pregnant To Another Man – But I Still Love Her

    Posted by theworstpainever on October 9, 2021 at 2:01 pm

    My wife over the years has had several affairs and I forgave her every time, and even in the face of irrefutable proof of each affair (even 3 of the men called me to apologize and admitted it all and said they didn’t know she was married), my wife STILL denied all but one of her affairs, claiming those men were lying to me (yeah, men do that don’t we?). Well, late last year I caught her in yet another one of her affairs. And sure enough, nine months later, she gave birth to a beautiful baby girl and because certain timelines didn’t add up – we had sex just 7 months prior to the birth and baby was born full-term at almost 9 pounds for example, but she swears the baby is mine. I of course performed a DNA test – two actually to make sure, and sure enough, this little girl isn’t mine. It shatters my heart so deeply, but when I held her my heart melted and I fell in love with the innocent little girl and I waited a month to tell my wife what I knew because I wanted to try to prove to her that as humiliating as it may be, I would gladly be her father and raise her and love her with all of my heart. But, it all backfired on me. Bad. When I tried to approach her, her response was absolutely vicious and hateful instead of humble and loving. She told me the test was wrong (which is why I got a 2nd one), and she looked me in the eye and said the baby was mine and then she kicked me out of the house with fire and fury. Of course like all of us, I do indeed have my own demons, but not like that – but even though I have tried so hard over the past two months or so to peacefully and lovingly tell her I already forgive her and I want this to be quiet and to not tell our older children, she has, over the past few weeks just about destroyed my life in so many ways that I won’t get into here, but it has been bad. Vicious verbal attacks, telling my older children how “evil” I am (not sure how I’m evil, but ok), but I’m respecting her wishes and I moved out but I haven’t told a soul about what I know (except through this blog I guess). But, now, because of the horrible pain I have been put through and her emotional gaslighting and terrible psychological abuse for the past ten years, I think my patience is finally about gone. I sometimes feel that I want to be out for “blood” so-to-speak and I sometimes feel like since she won’t humbly let our family move forward as I so sincerely desired, I feel like letting loose sometimes and absolutely humiliate her. I sometimes want to tell the truth to everyone. I want to tell the father’s wife of the baby, I want court-ordered paternity tests, and I want to tell my older children that their mother cheated on me over the years (I have NEVER discussed this with my children because I never wanted them to think ill of their mother), but my older children are adults now. They are 18 and 20 years old respectively. I don’t know what to do, but should I finally let it all out and exercise my rights, and call the father’s wife to let her know what her husband did, and do the whole nine yards since divorce is just about inevitable now? All I wanted was peace and quiet and her to know that I can still forgive and love her, but she figuratively is spitting in my face and shredding me apart emotionally to this very day and there is only so much a human soul can take. Honestly, if I saw even the slightest shred of a possibility that our marriage would continue, I wouldn’t feel angry. I’d just want to stay quiet and continue our marriage and hope that she changes. But, there’s basically no earthly hope whatsoever of reconciliation barring a miracle from God. Any thoughts? I’m open to both criticism and opinions on what I want to do and what I have done in response. It’s ok. I need to hear all sides here. Thank you.

    replied 5 years ago 2 Members · 11 Replies
  • 11 Replies
  • cait

    Member
    October 9, 2021 at 4:04 pm

    This is one of the toughest scenarios I have heard thus far.

    About telling your children: I think it will hurt them worse than it will hurt her. (Something is wrong with her, mentally.) My husband is the cheater and is reading a book I got him on recovery. The book said, under no circumstances, should the children be told. It said, and I quote, “Let this be the hill you die on.”

    About telling the wife: That is the worst thing a woman can hear. Be compassionate as possible. Do they have kids? Are you giving up all hope of being the father, regardless of genetics? Once you get these people involved, there is no telling what will happen. You can’t unring a bell.

    About your wife and revenge: She treated you terribly and I am so sorry. You sound like someone who is uncommonly forgiving and willing to love. And she sounds like someone who has issues, to say the least. My instinct is that she needs some professional help. Don’t lower yourself to her standards. It’s not fair to you, I know. But at the end of the day, all we really have is our integrity.

  • theworstpainever

    Member
    October 9, 2021 at 5:03 pm

    Thank you so much for your words of honesty and respect. It is such a difficult decision and almost unbelievable situation, and you are right – you can’t unring a bell. When it’s out that’s it. It’s OUT. I have thus far decided to not tell the father’s wife because I did not want to disrupt his family – he has children too, and his wife is innocent and she doesn’t need to feel such pain. I don’t want to be the one to initiate it, even though it would be HIM that caused it. I do not want to be a catalyst. But then, as a human, I get those feelings of “revenge” at times, where I just want to finally see my wife beg for mercy just once, but then those feelings get overridden within moments where I know, that even today, if she held out her hand, I’d take it. I would still do anything for her, and although not a soul on earth (except my bishop at church and of course my wife) knows that I’m not this baby’s father, and since I have fallen in love with her precious little soul, I would have to relinquish her entirely if I went to court to provide the paternity results. It would crush my older children. It would hurt that little girl I’ve grown to love, and the only “good” thing would be that it would humiliate my wife which I know she deserves. To me, keeping quiet about it seems to be the only viable option in my heart. I will bear that painful cross. I’m sure others would call me weak or stupid for agreeing to raise and be financially responsible for another man’s child, but to that little soul, she does not deserve anything less than stability, love, confidence, and care. Its not her fault. Someday my wife will face the consequences of her actions, but until that day, I don’t want to be the one to hasten such consequences because as I said those consequences would travel so much further than just her. They would ruin lives and hurt others. I just can’t let that happen from my mouth. If I told you the other horrible and terrible things and abusive actions and words my wife has done to me over the years, you would think I was crazy for staying with her. Although there’s significantly more, here’s one other thing she did to me – She had an affair with my boss at work, humiliated me there, caused me terrible depression and I lost my job four years ago because of it. I hired a labor law attorney to prove that the company provided a hostile atmosphere and did not provide reasonable accommodations, and right when I was about to succeed in that lawsuit, my wife had an affair with my own attorney which the company found out about even before I did, and so he destroyed my credibility and I was literally called “stupid” for not “realizing” what my wife was doing so I just dropped that case and fell into a deeper depression. But I still forgave her and still told no one because I did not want to ruin her reputation with her family, my family, our children, and her work. Then she had another affair, and another, and I would stay home countless nights watching and caring for our little girl while she was out sleeping (unbeknownst to me) with other men as I found out. So why am I still with her? Am I a glutton for punishment? There is even more she has done to me that I will not discuss because they are far too emotional for me to write about, but all I can say is that I am loyal to my word and I believe in God and I don’t think there is any soul on earth, nor any situation that cannot be redeemed. So, although I may be called delusional for having such hope, I am holding on to it to the bitter end. I know my actions do not make sense to anyone. But I know my heart and certainly I have my own demons, but there was once a young lady that I married who was pure and sweet and wonderful, and she changed into this person she is today, so I feel it is possible that she may become who she once was. Everyone will disagree, I know, but I just want peace and stability for my children even if at the expense of my own sanity. Again, I’m rambling and I don’t make a lot of sense right now, but I am just the type of person that loves everyone and trusts others, and hopes for the best while preparing for the worst. Please know I am preparing – I have recorded every single one of her hundreds of vicious verbal attacks against me right in front of our children and I will use those recordings only if I have to defend myself, but I will not use them offensively just to hurt her. I have also taken other precautions to prepare for the worst, but for now, this is where I am. Holding all of this inside and keeping it all from my family and hers has not been easy because they can tell when I am emotional, so when they ask me what is wrong I just lie and say I’m tired or whatever. Nobody knows who and what she has become except me and her. Again, however, if she does (or I do) file for divorce and she tries to hurt me in the legal forum then indeed I will be forced to reveal so much about her which will then be public record. Sorry for this novel I just wrote here, but these are the thoughts of my heart at the moment. Everybody tells me to “GET OUT NOW” from this abusive relationship, but it’s just not that simple. It isn’t. There are too many people’s lives at stake other than just my own. Thank you.

  • cait

    Member
    October 9, 2021 at 7:57 pm

    I don’t think you are weak or stupid at all. I think you are really trying to have a soft heart in the face of adversity and betrayal and that requires a lot of strength and courage!

    I also think you have been in an abusive relationship for a long, long time. I think that kind of stress is very confusing and damaging. It changes us, both the abused and the abusers. I see a pattern of abuse and codependency from what you wrote, in addition to the rampant infidelity. I am so sorry you have lived with this in silence for so long. I don’t think you should do that any longer; it is not healthy.

    Her treatment of you is not okay. You don’t have to accept it. Your marriage to her is not the basis for stability in your children’s lives, including the baby girl’s. (Legally, you are the dad if you want to be!) Your sanity and sense of self is.

    You don’t have to divorce her if you are unwilling or not ready. But I don’t think remaining in the house with her is wise. Your kids shouldn’t see her treating you that way. And, frankly, I worry about her ability to be a normal mother. They are learning about relationships from the two of you. They need to learn about love and boundaries, and this doesn’t sound like what they have been seeing.

    Just because you don’t tell the kids about the infidelity doesn’t mean they need to be told that her screaming at you is okay or rational. Mental health is at the forefront these days and it would definitely benefit the family to have counseling. Your wife certainly should get some help. And so should you for your depression.

    You are coping well. You have been strong. But it is time to share your yoke. God doesn’t mean for us to suffer alone.

  • theworstpainever

    Member
    October 9, 2021 at 11:24 pm

    Wow. You really hit the nail on the head. Your third paragraph specifically rang such a bell of truth it brought me to tears. You said that the basis of stability for my children isn’t just staying married, but rather it is my sanity and sense of self. That makes so much sense. You are absolutely right. It’s like I’m gripping so tightly on the sharp end of a knife just for the purpose of not dropping it, all while I ignore the fact that it’s irreparably cutting my hand. Sometimes we have to just let go. This marriage has indeed destroyed my self-confidence, made me repeatedly question my own sanity (she’s a classic gaslighter), and spiraled me into a terrible deep depression that I am being treated for currently. A very important element to life as well though is that not only are we responsible for our own actions, but we are also responsible for our REactions to the actions of others, no matter how horrible those actions are. I mean, my wife cheats so I’m justified to do whatever I want, right? Absolutely not of course. I fully admit I often chose very bad coping mechanisms that I finally stopped, but I admit my culpability for those actions. As I mentioned, I indeed have my own demons – for example, in order for me to deal with everything I turned to prescription medication and abused it regularly. I don’t drink at all, but xanax was my best friend to a point where I just became numbingly intoxicated on several occasions so I wouldn’t feel the effects of her abuse. I am so ashamed of that destructive behavior and finally got clean and got rid of it all which I hoped and thought would also change my wife’s behavior. She always blames me for absolutely everything she ever does “wrong” although she never actually recognizes any of her behavior as “wrong.” Only if there are negative consequences that arise does she even acknowledge she may have done “something,” BUT that “something” is always my fault. For instance, she slept with my boss, I ended up losing my job, but it was my fault because she said that I reacted to her affair like “a weak loser and failure.” I am so tired of being called a loser, a failure, a freak, weak, and a thousand other names right in front of our kids. There was a point when I started to believe her, and when she encouraged me to commit suicide a few times, I admit I almost took her advice. But to this day, everything she does is still completely justified in her mind. It is an absolutely terrifying trait to face in the one you love. When I stopped turning to meds to cope, she lost her go-to justification so she found a new one – “the past” when I was taking the meds wrongly. There’s always a justification to her.

    And, regarding my new little baby girl – you are absolutely right – I am the father under the law, my name is legally on her birth certificate, although the presumption of paternity is rebuttable, so if the “real” father wanted to, he could waltz into court with a DNA test and basically try to take my little girl from me at any time for the next 18 years, which thought terrifies me. As I said, I want to stay as her father so badly. She is so innocent and pure and I know that God doesn’t send down “accidents” so her life is supposed to be in mine in my opinion. I love her with all of my heart and even though she’s only a month and a half old, she and I have already created a special little bond that I cannot give up. I thought about that so much, that when I did lovingly try to approach my wife about what the paternity test revealed, I carefully suggested that I prepare a waiver of paternity agreement with a non-disclosure clause for the father so he indeed loses his right to rebut my fatherhood, and so he would be prohibited from saying he’s the father to anyone. Of course that suggestion didn’t go over well with my wife – if she agrees to that then she agrees to cheating on me so she just ended up shredding me apart so viciously when I tried to bring up that quiet and loving solution to the problem she created. And, to be clear that was just a few weeks ago. That is how fresh all of this is. This blog here is my only outlet right now and it feels so good to finally “tell someone” even if I am only doing so anonymously. Thank you for your caring nature.

  • theworstpainever

    Member
    October 9, 2021 at 11:34 pm

    One other thought – I also had the idea of carefully approaching the father myself (over the phone or in another safe environment of course) and discussing the situation with him and gauge his reaction. At this point, I am not angry anymore at him. Last year as I mentioned, he apologized to me but at that point I didn’t know he got her pregnant and I now wonder if he knew then. Any thoughts to that possibility? And if so, how should I approach him and what should I say? I mean, part of me wants to threaten him with telling his wife if he doesn’t agree, but I’m not a black-mailer. The other part of me just wants to tell him I forgive him and lovingly ask him to sign a waiver of paternity, and the other part of me wants to try to forget him completely. Let me know what you think about that. Thank you.

  • cait

    Member
    October 10, 2021 at 9:19 am

    I have read your post several times and the raw pain and confusion were so heartbreaking. But, I am so relieved that you are finally speaking your truth after holding back for so long. You need to talk about it and label it to gain clarity. Only then can you make informed choices.

    Especially in abusive relationships, we cannot see the forest for the trees. I have been praying to God this morning for the right words to give you so you can extricate yourself from a very difficult situation. This is actually the first time I have shared one of these messages on this support group with my straying husband. He said he wishes he could be your friend and I feel the same way. You really need someone in your corner.

    There were a lot of issues that came up within your post. I am going to list them in the order that I think is the most “on fire,” so to speak:

    1. Your wife’s mental health disorder, because she clearly has one.

    From what you wrote (“She always blames me for absolutely everything she ever does “wrong” although she never actually recognizes any of her behavior as “wrong.” Only if there are negative consequences that arise does she even acknowledge she may have done “something,” BUT that “something” is always my fault. “), she sounds exactly like a narcissist and that gave me a sinking feeling in my gut because they don’t change. Their hallmarks are an inability to admit when they are wrong, even to themselves and putting themselves first at all times. If you can’t admit when you are wrong, how can you ever change? I sincerely hope your wife is not one; at this point, I am praying she is “merely” bipolar with impulse control issues.

    2. Your wife’s abuse of you and your co-dependent relationship.

    Your sense of self seems tied up in her treatment of you and this will only lead you to despair. Trying to get real, sustained love from an abusive narcissist is like banging your head against a wall. I have a narcissist as a father and the damage he inflicted on the whole family was massive. I only stopped being hurt by him once I stopped trying to seek his love and approval. I was feeding his ego every time I did that and worsening his tyrannical behavior. I couldn’t love him out of it. I was just “rescuing” him from the natural consequences of his actions and he never learned to be better. He just got worse. (My mother divorced my father a few years ago and recently got sole custody of my special needs brother and, finally, FINALLY our family is healing now that he is out of the picture.) You seemed trapped in a similar cycle with your wife.

    I am a kind, loving person and so is my mother. We tried so hard to fix him; we prayed to God to heal him. But, we had to come to accept that we were not the agents of God’s miracle for him. In fact, we were blocking change by rescuing him from his consequences. The fact that he doesn’t love us doesn’t mean we are unloveable. It just means that he can’t love. It is very sad.

    Since I have left that abusive relationship with my father, I have freed up so much mental headspace. I have a 1000 lb weight lifted from my shoulders. I am a better, happier, more present mother to my children. I am a better wife to my husband. I am a better daughter and sister to my mother and brother. I smile more; I bring light with me instead of despair.

    I feel like this will be the case for you as well. I see so much in you that is stifled by this pattern of abuse.

    3. Questions about your wife’s ability to be a mother to your children.

    This is going to require brutal honesty with yourself. You are probably not the only martyr in that house. Look closely at their interactions. How does she treat your children? What does their body language tell you? Does the family revolve around her and her moods? How do you, as a family, feel when you hear her car drive in the driveway? My father always inspired dread; my mother still felt that even when she was deliberately closing her eyes to his abuse of her children.

    Abusers rarely content themselves with one victim.

    4. Your depression and addiction.

    You are dealing with a multi-headed beast here and depression/ addiction is one of those heads. I have never had an addiction but I am depressed. You have protect yourself and your sobriety so that you can be strong for yourself and the family. It is obvious that she is your trigger. That means limiting your exposure to her abuse, joining support groups/ AA, and getting support from your friends and family. You don’t HAVE to tell everyone everything (although you can–this is NOT your shame!) but you can say that you are struggling with an abusive relationship and depression.

    As an exercise, write down 10 things you love about yourself as a person, 10 wonderful things that you bring to the world, and 10 blessings in your life. Look at these lists and see that you are loved, you are valuable, you have so much, and you have so much to give. When you feel lowly or vulnerable, take these lists out and read them. I do this myself at least once a week.

    Another coping mechanism I do is list the tools in my toolkit that make me feel happy. I have a lot of those…music, books, walking, spending time with my kids, talking to my mother, writing poetry, etc. Even on days where I am so blue, I can’t get out of bed and I can’t find happiness in anything, I look at my toolkit list and see if SOMETHING on it can help me find joy. One thing that never lets me down is a soft blanket. Then I turn on a song…then I find some soft pants and put them on…then I stretch my healthy body….then I make some coffee and smell it brewing….and the snowball effect of finding small joys supersedes the nihilism of depression.

    If you feel a major depressive episode coming on and feel suicidal, take deep breaths and count to 15. I heard on the radio years ago that most of these episodes last about 15 seconds. If you can get through 15 seconds and you still feel in danger, then count to 15 again. I have counted to 15 many times. And I’m still here.

    5. Baby’s paternity questions.

    This one I have to reflect on for a little while longer. My initial thought is that you shouldn’t do anything yet—you can’t take it back. But you CAN wait and do it a little later.

    I think you need to know more about this other man and his family. Is he a good person? Are his family members good people? Will he respect your bond with your daughter? Will he help you and be on your “team” or will he be an adversary who will drain your battery? Will your wife lure him back into her spider web?

    Of course, I worry about his wife and children, but I also don’t think they are under your purview, either. His choices, his consequences. Your choice to tell is not what will make or break their family. Just don’t let your basis for telling be coming from one of revenge or anger, if you can.

    Here is a test for myself before I make certain difficult choices or decide to say something difficult:

    A. Is it true?

    B. Is it kind?

    C. Is it helpful/necessary?

    If you have 2/3, you may proceed.

    6. Last fire, her rampant infidelity.

    Before you open your heart to her, you need to know she is safe to love. Your loving soul is precious; do not waste it on someone who won’t value it. She needs to be emotionally safe to you and faithful.

    There is so much more to be said on this if you get to this juncture in your marriage. But it requires her to be remorseful and to admit she was wrong. I don’t even know if she is capable of that. Do you?

  • theworstpainever

    Member
    November 5, 2021 at 8:16 am

    Your help has been so wonderful. Thank you. I really took some time to think about and re-read what you wrote. I came to the conclusion that indeed she is a true narcissist. There is no other explanation. I’m terrified of her. There is so much she has done to me and our family that is all “my fault” because of my admitted demons. I know we can never change another person – they need to recognize their own faults and change themselves with proper support, but she refuses to acknowledge that she even has a problem. Forgive me if I already stated this, but one time when I asked her if she had sex with other men, her answer to me was “YOU DON’T OWN ME!” I guess only an idiot like me would stay with a person who gives that answer. I have so much more to say but I am emotionally exhausted. I am writing a narrative book (names changed) that will fully explain all that I have been put through, of course including my own demons and my own faults. So far, the book is over 250 pages.

  • cait

    Member
    November 5, 2021 at 10:31 am

    You are not an idiot at all! You are trusting and loving and there is a big difference! You wanted to believe in her and love her because of something beautiful within YOU, not her.

    And I am so glad that it was helpful. You have been on my mind since we last “talked” and even my husband has been asking how things are turning out for you. I have a feeling like you are just beginning your journey of healing and breaking free of an abusive relationship. Once you start learning more about narcissistic personality disorder, it is amazing how validating it can be to recognize the truth after being gaslighted (gaslit?) for so long. It also can be sad because you have to give up hope for a better outcome to the relationship and accept who they are versus who you wished they could be.

    The #1 tip for dealing with narcism is no contact, but I don’t think that is an option for you at this stage because you share children. (How are your kids holding up, by the way?)

    Another big technique is called “gray rock.” A narcissist looks to others for their “narcissistic supply”, to feed their ego with drama or validation. Sometimes that means love-bombing you for affection…sometimes that means they want to get into the mud with you to feel self-righteous or like a victim. They want you to be wrapped around their finger, but if they can’t have that…they want to fight with you. They want you to give them your pain so that they can use it as ammunition against you.

    “Gray rock” essentially deprives them of any kind of emotional interaction that can feed their ego. You keep things as low contact as possible and be very bland and impersonal. Pretend you are a bored customer service representative, super polite, and businesslike. It will starve them of their supply and give them nothing to throw back at you.

    Obviously, that isn’t how you really feel and you have to control almost all of your impulses to do this. It is draining but so is fighting. Can you go anywhere while you work out how you want to handle the situation?

    I think it is great that you are writing your experiences down and looking at your story with a fresh viewpoint. A word of caution, though…DO NOT give that book to your wife. You might as well hand her a nuclear bomb to throw at you. Give her nothing to hold against you. It won’t open her eyes to your pain. It will just reinforce her own viewpoints. I am so sorry. 🙁

    If you are looking to learn more, there are a lot of support groups on FB dealing with recovery from narcissistic abuse.

    Dr. Ramani has a Youtube series on narcissism and recovery from abuse that I have found very helpful. Some of her videos are kind of long but here is a short one to introduce you to her, if you are interested: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J4yraZiJ9D8

    She also has videos for people who decide to stay with their narc partners as well so there is a ton of help out there for you, whatever you decide to do.

    I hope you will keep in touch about your journey!

  • theworstpainever

    Member
    November 5, 2021 at 1:37 pm

    I would like to speak somehow with you personally. It would help so much. I will figure out how to get that done. Maybe give a fake name and temp email or something.

  • theworstpainever

    Member
    November 5, 2021 at 2:47 pm

    temp email

    robertjevonsson@gmail.com

    after we establish communication in another way I will delete this email just to be safe. I’m not too savvy with privacy so I’m not good at hiding things I guess. She seems to find everything even if it’s nothing. I got ripped apart one time for something absolutely and completely benign that required no confession or even discussion that happened within the first year of our marriage. I was shocked at her behavior and didn’t even know how to defend myself because truthfully, it required no defense whatsoever to a “normal” person.

  • cait

    Member
    November 8, 2021 at 1:43 pm

    I understand. It can be hard to communicate in an authentic way through this forum, especially since it is public.

    I would be honored to help you, if I can. I do have to think about communicating privately through email with a man, though. My husband and I have agreed to not have friends of the opposite gender, and I am finding it crucial to my recovery/ trusting him again. I would be livid if he were privately emailing a woman, even if it was from a support group. Even if it was “innocent” because he has broken trust with me in the past. I think whatever I ask of him, I also need to do myself.

    It sounds like you are having a battle with your wife over communicating with women, however innocently, online as well. It is obviously hypocritical, but you’ll find that to be another hallmark of narcissism. She will throw this at you and it can be hard to gray rock when you feel “caught out”—even if it is over nothing. After I went no-contact with my father, he stalked me and my mother, trying to “catch us sneaking around behind his back.” Looking back on it now, I am amazed at how crappy and guilty he managed to make me feel over visiting my mom!

    In a strange way, I am revealing a more intimate side of myself on this site than I do to my closest girlfriends. However, the anonymity and the public nature make it feel acceptable to me.

Log in to reply.