Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Members Stories › Highly Suspect Husband and ‘Best Friend’

  • Highly Suspect Husband and ‘Best Friend’

    Posted by kitkat79 on October 12, 2021 at 1:19 pm

    Hi all

    I highly suspect that my husband cheated on me with my former best friend. This happened quite a few years ago. I was quite young and too traumatised at the thought so blocked it out.

    I wanted to note my circumstantial evidence and would really appreciate your honest feedback.

    My evidence-

    My nephew told me that he saw them together. My nephew emphasised that he would not lie to me about something like that. When I confronted my husband, first he said that he must have mistaken her for his sister. He then flat out said my nephew was a liar and sticks to that story to this day. I added that my nephew had seen then intimately (I wasn’t told this, just wanted to see his reaction) He has seen my nephew plenty of times since and has never confronted him about his ‘lies’

    I always felt uncomfortable when they were around each other. Just a gut feeling that they fancied each other. My husband certainly acted different in her presence. He hates most of my friends along with some of my family yet had no issues with my ‘friend’ and her boyfriend socialising with us.


    My husband and friend even tried to arrange a ‘family’ holiday. He knew that she annoyed me but was happy to make plans anyway. The holiday never went ahead.


    My daughter confessed to me that my ‘friend’ came to my house a few times when I wasn’t home. Again I confronted my husband adding that they went upstairs alone (although not true, I wanted to see his reaction) to this day he has never asked my daughter about it. Why wouldn’t you want to clear your name?


    My friend was round once. My husband said he didn’t like a song. She replied ‘yes you do, you like to pump it in the car’ she repeated this. Again, I confronted my husband. This brought on a smile that he tried to conceal. I asked if he thought it was a sexual connotation. He said is was. He didn’t come across as angry about her ‘winding me up’ as he put it.


    I once went into the kitchen, he looked like a rabbit in headlights. I heard her on the other end of the phone say ‘omg is she there’. I got angry and walked out. Never confronted my friend as again I was too scared to address the situation and feared for my mental health so desperately tried to make excuses in my head.


    During a time when my husband and I spilt temporarily. We were both in the car. She called, with me there he had to pick it up. She sounded different to how she speaks to me. My husband must have reacted in a way that allowed her to end the call quickly. Straight after she called me. I didn’t pick up. To this day I regret that but wasn’t mentally able.


    Years later he admitted during this time. He considered her. How could he ethically think about this if he is ‘friends’ with her partner?


    My husband told me that when looking for a flat to buy, she turned up as an estate agent. He said that she was acting in a way like she wanted things to go further but he declined her subtle advances. I can’t remember whether my husband told me at the time that she was his estate agent. I’m pretty sure he did but not 100% sure. He definitely did not say about her behaviour until later. She never did tell me.


    After all the hurt I’d expressed to my husband that this situation had caused. He had the cheek to say that they used to talk about their problems and she was ‘pouring’ her little heart out’.


    I do recall my husband telling me gossip about my sister that she had told him. I can’t remember how this came into the mix but it does suggest that my husband did say he spoke to her. I just didn’t realise that they spoke so often and about emotional topics. After probing my husband admitted that they spoke behind my back for about a year.


    I told my husband that she fancied his brother. He got jealous and shouted a little.


    My ‘friend’ posted her wedding invitations to me and my family through the letter box on the eve of my wedding. She didn’t even ring the bell she just posted them and ran off. She didn’t do this to anyone else, just me and my family. My brother (RIP) told her finance to ‘check his girlfriend, and that she was out of order’at my wedding.

    There is a picture of my ‘friend’ whispering to my other ‘friend’ at my hen night on social media. My ‘friend’ commented under the photo. ‘Ohh ‘Jane Doe’ I wonder what the scandal is’ I suspect my other ‘friend- Jane’ Doe’ knows more than she lets on.


    She is a friend of my family and none of them give a toss. It’s like if you didn’t catch them red handed then don’t worry about it. My Mum told me to just move on and forget about it. I have absolutely no one to talk to. One of my sister’s still talks about her fondly. I had to eventually tell her to stop doing this in my presence.


    I argued with my husband on an occasion, he looked very angry at one point when he didn’t think I was looking he looked down at the floor with a guilt, embarresed smile, he then turned back to me with his angry face.

    When having an incredibly heated argument with he shouted ‘so what, so what, no one cares’. He’s right no one does. I feel incredibly isolated.


    I’m sure I already know the answer just need you all to provide your honest opinions and reassurance. I know he will NEVER tell the truth. This leaves me with a little doubt that I am wrong and that they did not betray me.


    Please note that I was very young when we met. I was a little shy of 18. He was 25. I’d like to move on for peace of mind. We have a child so financially it would prove difficult.

    This has been ruminating in my head for a very long time and is making my life a misery.


    I just need reassurance that I am not barking up the wrong tree.

    I would very much appreciate your feedback and honesty.

    Thank you very much in advance

    replied 5 years, 1 month ago 4 Members · 4 Replies
  • 4 Replies
  • cait

    Member
    October 12, 2021 at 5:34 pm

    Kitkat, I feel pretty confident that they are having/have had an affair. It all sounds super shady to me. I’m so sorry. 🙁

    Do you two have kids? Will your friend tell you the truth? Or the other friend who you think might know more than she is letting on? I found out my husband cheated through some investigative/ interrogative work and it took 3.5 years. But I finally have the truth and we can start to heal.

  • eliza4one

    Member
    October 12, 2021 at 6:39 pm

    I don’t doubt a woman’s intuition. If your gut is telling you so, then it’s probably so.

    Any investigating you can do? Phone records? Credit card bills? Someone you could ask…

    Honestly, I don’t think I could just “live with it”. I HATE the thought that something went on and I am clueless/in the dark about it…it would eat me alive.

    How’s your marriage as a whole? Are you happy? Is it fulfilling?

    I guess if you can’t get it out of him, and you don’t have proof/can’t find proof, AND you don’t think you can live with it longterm, you can start “planning for your own future”. Not saying you will end up without him. But, it will give you a sense of power and control that you need. As well, start focusing on YOU. Aside from your husband and children. Women tend to give their all to their husbands and children, at the expense of ourselves. That puts us at a disadvantage, overall. Take baby steps for yourself. Again, that will give you power and control. Then, IF the time comes when you feel the need to leave him OR if you find out the truth OR if you find out he’s cheated again, then you will be “ahead of the ballgame” and better equipped to handle things.

    I might be way off base, but those thoughts came to mind as I read your post.

    I’m sorry. That has got to be a horrible feeling to live with day in and day out!

  • hearbroken

    Member
    October 13, 2021 at 9:09 am

    I think there are many of us on here who wish we had listened to our intuition. I’ve learned to my detriment that that bad feeling about something innocuous usually has some merit. I can think of so many instances where something felt off or I just didn’t like something and I rationalized that I was just being paranoid – he would never hurt me, he’s old enough to be her father, she’s a dimwitted ,unattractive ,self centered woman. I should have listened to my gut instead of my head.

    I’m sorry to say, but you are probably right in your worries. Do the investigating. You need to know the truth.

  • kitkat79

    Member
    October 13, 2021 at 11:50 am

    I did confront her at one point. Years later when my repressed thoughts started to resurface, I sent her a rather aggressive text telling her I knew, how could she have sex with my husband in a car and to stay away from my family. Somehow she managed to talk me round but was very sympathetic and not at all shocked about my suspicions.

    She asked if we could meet in a cafe which we did. I told her that someone had seen her and my Husband out together. Her response was that whoever told me that is no friend of hers. She also added that she didn’t want to even know who said it. Note that my Nephew is only a few years younger than me not a child.


    I asked her why she said ‘oh my God’ on the phone when I walked in. Her excuse was so lame that I can’t even remember her response.


    She then went on to say that she asked her boyfriend what her and my husband use to talk about and he said he also could not remember. This was her saying that he knew that they spoke.

    That is a cop out. It’s obvious he didn’t and at that point I was no longer in contact with him and did not want to involve him in something without concrete evidence. I have no idea what his thoughts or feelings are on the matter.


    She said that she and my Husband had a big Brother, little Sister relationship (my Husband had said the same) and insisted that I knew about their conversations. Never mentioned the secrecy that my Husband admitted to or the length of time they ‘spoke’. She gave any nothing and didn’t apologise just said in hindsight maybe they shouldn’t have spoke.


    I’d totally forgotten to ask her about the wedding invites. What’s you opinions on that?


    When I told her that it made me feel like I wasn’t good enough (which it did) she started to cry.

    After that I blocked her number, cutting her off completely.


    Problem is a she is a close family friend (we grew up together and our Mothers were very close when we were kids, not so much now) I cannot completely cut her off.


    My plan is to try and take my name off the mortgage so that I can claim benefits. My job isn’t particularly well paid. I have one child to consider. I wouldn’t say he adores his Father but they do have a bond.

    I am making serious steps to leave him as I will not be able to live with this, it’s maddening and heartbreaking. It’s gone beyond just an affair to straight up cruelty. He’s forced me to carry his burden. I did tell him that it will hit him 10 times harder if anything was to, God forbid happen to me.


    Part of the reason he won’t confess is he doesn’t want me to leave.

    I have asked Jane Doe, she says she doesn’t know anything but I’m not sure if I believe her as my ‘friend’ and her became pretty close at one point during that period.


    She also cried once when she was drunk saying she’s not a good friend but wouldn’t reveal why. She is also a childhood friend, our Mothers were best friends. Her Mother has passed on (RIP) She’s at a stage where she couldn’t tell me anything as I have confided in her many times.


    My Husband dislikes Jane Doe and says that she could confirm that nothing happened as she was close to my ‘friend’ why is it he hates her but not my ‘friend’?


    Also, it’s too late to check phone bills and bank statements

    Thank you both for your advice. It does help to speak with someone even if it’s through a forum x

Log in to reply.