Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Members Stories › “I don’t remember/know”

  • “I don’t remember/know”

    Posted by freshstart on October 22, 2021 at 6:08 am

    Hi – I am new here. I found out less than a month ago that my H had an affair with someone on and off for 5 years. Like many of you I am really just trying to wrap my head around it and ultimately decide what I want to do.

    When we first started talking about this, it was initially hard for him to remember what year it started, but I was able to get how it started, and snippets of information like where they would go.

    What I have not been able to get is when/how/why did this end the last time. He tells me he doesn’t remember because it wasn’t important to him, knows it was this year, and he is indicating it has been “quite awhile” but really what does that mean?

    Also, knowing that it was on again, off again for so long, I’ve wanted to understand what motivated him to initiate when he did. What was the longest period of time they were constantly in touch (he has indicated he didn’t talk to them at one point for 6months), and when was he doing this (as in where was i??). I had assumed it was on his days off from work, but he indicated it was not the case. When I ask he tells me he cannot remember. Or I don’t know. Since I can’t get place when this would occur it really leaves me feeling like for all I know he could still be doing it right now.

    Has anyone else had this happen? Do they ever “remember”…??

    I am not sure how to deal with this. I don’t doubt that there are going to be things he won’t remember clearly, especially since it went on for so long, and I don’t doubt that there could be a part that is blocking some stuff out if he feels bad about it, but obviously it isn’t giving me any comfort.

    There are things he has done to indicate he wants to be together – When I found out while he initially said some weird shit (the spouse of the AP texted me to tell me, and my H told me that if he were me I would block the number), when we talked he immediately admitted his mistake, he indicated he wanted to make us work, that the person didn’t mean anything to them/it was just physical. He gave me this persons contact information (I was able to confirm it was the correct person), removed and blocked them on his phone, and changed his FB settings to not allow people who are not friends to message him (apparently this person was never his FB friend but would reach out on there). He bailed out of a league he usually is adamant about being in as he likes to go out, he has stopped going out anywhere except work, when I have asked questions (aside from these I don’t know things I have referenced) he appears to do his best to answer, and also he found a counselor/therapist within a couple days and has started talking to them. He also lets me know when he is leaving work and the like and if anything is expecting me to call/FaceTime/or whatever more than I do. These actions leave me feeling maybe there is some shred of hope, but the overlay of I don’t know or I don’t remember is putting a haze over that.

    replied 5 years ago 4 Members · 4 Replies
  • 4 Replies
  • tara81

    Member
    October 22, 2021 at 9:38 am

    I could have written this about my experience. my husband’s affairs lasted anywhere between 4-6 years on/off according to him. He says it wasn’t that long but I am counting until the day I found out. He said it had been over for a while. Like your husband he says he doesn’t really remember when it started or when it ended. He answered my questions but never anything definitive around the dates. He swears up and down that it was just a mistake(yeah right) and she didn’t mean anything. He must of have been in limerence. He cut her off completely the moment I found out. I know she tried to contact him but he didn’t respond. My case was a bit different because she was really in love with him and was out to get him so I had to take her to court for harassment. I also question him why it was on/off. I know like me you are probably thinking that it was a great love story and it was so irresistible to them. but he said that he kept doing it because 1. I didn’t notice 2. she kept making herself available. I believe that at the end of the day he did it because he wanted to and found someone available. I know that he excused his behavior to himself by finding faults in our marriage.

    My husband is remorseful. He worked on himself. He is transparent, he tells me when he gets home from work. I have complete accessed to his phone.

    There is hope. It has been 14 months since dday and the pain has lessen. I’m happy for the most part, don’t get me wrong this has been a hard road for me, but I’m happy I gave him a second chance. He shows up for me everyday. I was upfront about what I needed and what changes I expected in our marriage.

    I do wish that I knew the exact dates but I had to choose to let it go because it wasn’t helping me or helping our marriage. All I know is that he broke my heart and now has to earn the trust that I so blindly gave him.

    We can either allow someone else’s mistake to define us and make us miserable or we can use it it as a lesson and an opportunity to grow.

    Good Luck, this journey sucks.

  • freshstart

    Member
    October 22, 2021 at 12:41 pm

    I really appreciate this response. It helps to know on some level I am not the only one with this confusing experience.

    It does not help really to know that he doesn’t find this person attractive, and when I asked what she meant to him he said she was basically a hole. I think most people assume that the other person would be more attractive or hot, but instead it’s like he found someone who cheats on their bf and then husband to fill some other void of their own. It must have been the perfect storm, and for what, I moment of “feeling better”… my husband told me he sometimes would get physically ill later thinking about what he did, yet that was not enough to stop. The whole thing makes no sense to me.

    I hope to feel half as well as you do in 14 months, to add to this we have 3 kids and just bought a new house. When I go to that house I get sad about the life that never will be. He thinks it is a house that can be a clean slate.

    I wish I could wake up from this nightmare.

  • stargazeraf

    Member
    October 22, 2021 at 2:40 pm

    It’s been almost a year since I found out my husband was having sex with whores in hotels in the afternoon when he was supposed to be working. He frequently answered a lot of my questions with i don’t know/remember, and from what I can tell, sometimes that’s true and sometimes it is total horse$#!+. I had to let go of asking about some of the details, and really, i guess i don’t NEED to know. There’s a part of me that thinks lies should be replaced with truth, but i guess cheaters don’t always see it that way. I do think their ability to compartmentalize is so complete that they truly do forget some stuff. For my husband, compartmentalizing was a survival skill learned in childhood, and he often does it automatically, which is crazy to me but i know more about it now, so i can see the role it has played in his life. After a year of working on our relationship, he is finally grasping why he did it. He felt that I was “distant and sullen” last year because I found out he was having emotional affairs online and I was infuriated and hurt, and he thought it was no big deal and I should just move on. What his cheating really boils down to is he has an avoidant attachment style, and has had major struggles since childhood dealing with emotions or conflict, so when our conflict was emotional, he couldn’t handle it…. he decided to physically meet his needs in a no-strings attached setup. Why did he choose that? I still don’t have that answer, but it’s one of the answers I am still requiring before recommitting myself to him. I also thought he was distant and was totally ignoring my feelings, but I didn’t cheat. The last year has been a hellacious road paved with pain on both sides – his pain originating from his childhood, my pain originating from his betrayal. We have an awesome couples counselor who has been helping us learn a lot about ourselves and how we combine as a couple. Still not out of the woods but we seem to be heading in a direction that might pay off. I have found that if I really want an answer to a question, I write it down and ask him for a written or verbal response within the next couple days. That way, he can think about it. He has yet to answer one of those questions with i don’t know/remember.

  • cait

    Member
    October 23, 2021 at 10:32 am

    I can tell you that my husband also can’t “remember” a lot of details. It is hard for me to tell if he is being honest or just trying to cover his ass, at this point.

    I am VERY certain he was lying about not being able to remember in the early stages. He told me that he didn’t communicate sexually with his co-worker AP. When I wrote her a letter, intimating in it that I thought my husband was lying about the non-sexual aspect, he suddenly “remembered” that it was VERY sexual before I sent it to her. She masturbated on camera for him and send him tons of pictures and videos of her having sex with other men. He sent her sexual fantasy stories featuring the two of them. They sexted constantly. How could he forget that?

    He still doesn’t remember who contacted who first, who made it sexual first, or the content of most of their conversations. I don’t know if I can believe him at this point, but I guess I think I have enough information. She lives in a different state, so I believe him when he says that he never physically had sex with her.

    From what I’ve seen on here, this affair fog is definitely common. Is it real? Is it self-preservation? Is it both? Who knows?

Log in to reply.