Uh oh. The credit card and electronics should be able to be checked by you at any time. That was a line in the sand for me. If he couldn’t do that, I would leave the house or ask him to leave. It doesn’t mean you have to get a divorce but he needs to understand how serious these issues are. He still thinks he can cuddle his way out of this.
As for the rest of your questions, maybe you should write them down and send him an email each week with one question. Then he can take his time and not feel put on the spot when he answers. It might be that he isn’t good with talking about these emotional topics or is afraid that you will be flooded when he does. (That, by the way, is a natural reaction and doesn’t mean you are histrionic or hysterical, or undeserving of the truth. The truth just really sucks, that’s all and that is on HIM.) He might need a different medium, writing rather than speaking, to communicate.
Another advantage is you can also read his answers in private and have whatever reaction you have in peace….or confront him if you feel you need to let him have it. However, if your objective RIGHT NOW is to get the truth, I would compose myself and thank him for his honesty in order to beget more honesty. Punishing him now might be counterproductive. Your objectives might change later, like wanting him to GET IT, and that might mean showing your emotions more.
I also asked my husband to write me a letter, telling me everything he remembered about the affair. He also apologized in the letter, which was helpful. That way when I have questions or need an apology, I can go back and reread what he wrote. This was good for me because my mind was so blown, I almost couldn’t think of specific questions for a while. I just wanted the story and then I drew questions from that.
Extracting the information and playing detective is so painful, but take heart. I think it happens to 90% of couples who go through this. It takes a while for the betrayer to buy-in to full disclosure. They have a term for this–trickle-truth and it really sucks. Tell him that the faster you have full disclosure and transparency, the faster you can heal. The clock starts when you have all the information and no more betrayals are waiting in the wings to wallop you!
Good luck!