Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Members Stories › Is it weakness to stay with a cheater?

  • Is it weakness to stay with a cheater?

    Posted by hearbroken on August 4, 2022 at 7:03 pm

    My daughter just stopped over to tell me that she broke up with her boyfriend of 9 years. They had an apartment together and a cat and had been planning to buy a house together. He has anger issues – not violent – more mood swings and passive aggressive behaviors. She has been asking him to see a therapist for years and she decided she didn’t want to live her life like this. She seems so strong. She is planning to buy a house on her own and have her friends as roommates.

    I almost feel a little envious of her strength and her ability to let go of her love and do what is best for her mental well-being.

    Am I doing the right thing, giving this marriage a second chance? I wouldn’t say my husband has done the work on himself that he needs to. He wants to forget the whole thing as an “I fucked up.” He gets angry when I’m triggered and never wants to talk about it. Yes he’s being a better husband, and he discloses what he’s doing, where he’s going and who he’s with. I still occasionally video call to confirm and he’s OK with that.

    Am I ever going to be happy with myself for staying with a liar and a cheat? I used to fantasize about leaving and being on my own. There is a reason for that. My husband has always been self centered.

    I know it doesn’t make sense financially to leave. We would be losing so much that we’ve sacrificed for and worked so hard for. I have to give myself and my husband these 4 years to figure things out.

    I just really admire her for doing what is in her best interest.

    replied 4 years, 3 months ago 8 Members · 10 Replies
  • 10 Replies
  • bob47

    Member
    August 4, 2022 at 10:17 pm

    From everything I’ve seen you post here you are definitely not weak. Your making practical thought out decisions that are best for you right now and in the near future. Down the road … nobody knows maybe the best decision for you then will be to leave. Maybe it will be best for you to stay. That will be up to you. I don’t think it is ever weakness to stay with the betraying spouse. It’s a complicated decision that is very nuanced. I’ve seen some great people here who fell in the cheater category and appear ( to me and other complete strangers) to have th humility, remorse and clear conviction to never cause that hurt again that I’m hoping I can see in my spouse. I know I’m my case staying and working on our marriage is harder. It’d be far easier to say “adios s@&t” and never have to deal with it or her again. It takes strength to give them a chance. To open that door again knowing it’s always possible to get hurt again. To see through your pain to the parts of them you used to love.

  • eliza4one

    Member
    August 5, 2022 at 5:19 am

    Each situation is different. Each individual is different. The terms ‘strength’ and ‘weakness’ are relative and mean different things at different times with different people.

    It took great strength for me to move out. Yes, it was what I needed to do, but that didn’t make it easy. Living alone is now “easy”. I love it. The 2 months of continuing to live with him, prior to my signing the closing papers on my condo took far greater strength, though, than moving out did.

    I recently had surgery and had to stay out at the house with my wayward spouse. Those 2 weeks of being with him/living with him again took great strength!!!! At my condo, I no longer “fall off the rails”, get overly emotional, get angry at the situation, etc. At the house…yep…I did. Daily. Not healthy. #regrets!

    Like Bob said, you have played it right for you. You want to talk about strength?!?! Working with the AP for so long after DDay took strength! You’ve got that, Heartbroken! Never doubt your strength. You have strength now and you will have the strength you need 4 years down the road to make the decision that is right for you.

    I always think…if the innocent spouse doesn’t have strength preaffair, they are certainly going to have it post affair!!!!!

    I admire how you have handled your situation!

    Edited to add: You’ve raised a strong daughter. Kudos to you!

  • legolady

    Member
    August 5, 2022 at 9:35 am

    I too often ask myself if I am weak to stay. I know everyone says that it takes a very strong person to stay with a cheater but a lot of the time it does not feel like I’m strong.

    You said that you don’t feel like your husband is doing the work on himself that he should. Mine isn’t either. Yes like you said he tells me where he is and what he is doing. But he does not think he needs counseling, he doesn’t think WE need counseling either. He also acts like “I fucked up” and wants to forget it.

    It all makes me feel so weak and manipulated. He just wants everything to go back to “normal”. It really is frustrating and I am right there with you in this.

  • bob47

    Member
    August 5, 2022 at 11:07 am

    It’s not a fuck up, its a terrible decision, and shows weaknesses of character and potentially other personality defects. If he’s not willing to look at what those are and commit to changing them, i see a very strong chance of a repeat offence.

  • cait

    Member
    August 5, 2022 at 1:36 pm

    I think it shows strength to leave AND it takes strength to stay. Staying is not a character flaw. He is obviously the one with the character flaw(s).

    At this point, I think I am focusing on the fact that my life is better with him in it than without. Even if he hasn’t done all the work and even if it is still not fair…I still think I am better off with him. At the end of the day, I just want hugs from my hubby. So, I am staying.

    Your daughter had a different answer to that question. The fact that she knew what was right for her and followed through actually shows what great parenting she has had from you. You should be proud of her and yourself.

  • hearbroken

    Member
    August 5, 2022 at 9:18 pm

    Thank you Bob. I know you’re right. I was proud of her for doing what was in her best interest at the same time I was sad that we were losing her young man. I love him and have considered him part of the family for so long. So much of what she was saying was resonating with me. My husband actually has a lot in common with her ex boyfriend.An then add in the lying and cheating and I was having doubts. I am doing what is right for me at this time. It is not easy.

  • hearbroken

    Member
    August 5, 2022 at 9:25 pm

    if the innocent spouse doesn’t have strength preaffair, they are certainly going to have it post affair!!!if the innocent spouse doesn’t have strength preaffair, they are certainly going to have it post affair!!!

    Betrayed spouses have to be strong to survive this regardless of the path they take.

    My daughter is an amazing woman. I’m so proud of her.

  • tara81

    Member
    August 5, 2022 at 9:33 pm

    @heartbroken you have more strength and grace than anyone I know. Because I can assure you that if I was in your situation, I would have been arrested if I had to see my husband’s mistress everyday, I know for a fact I would have dragged her by the hair and put her right out of your work place. Like everyone on here has say it takes strength that we didn’t even know we had to get over this or to at least learn to breath again after finding out about an affair. Your daughter was probably done with the relationship before she decided to leave him. She is at a stage in her life where she is not tied to him because of human kids, joint debt and joint accounts. You have an incredible daughter and you taught her how to be strong. be kind to yourself, and enjoy the ride. We may not trust the same, but we have definitely become more self aware. If he hasn’t done the work it’s on him, just keep doing the work on yourself and work on the marriage and yourself for the next 4 years, and if things don’t work out at least you know that it wasn’t because you didn’t tried.

  • confusedlover

    Member
    August 5, 2022 at 11:29 pm

    It’s awesome that you can find strength in your daughter’s actions. It will bring you closer together and I hope you can treat yourself in the same regard; it does in fact take a lot of strength and courage to stay with a cheater.

    When you leave a cheater, you can start new with someone else or at least treat yourself with the love and respect they should have shown you. However, when you choose to stay, you choose to accept them for who they are or at least what they’ve done; on top of being there with them on their journey for betterness.

    The easiest and quickest thing would be to leave because you don’t have to actively think of them anymore unless you choose to. Staying means that nothing is ever easy for you anymore but you chose it because you want change / better days with this specific person. It’s not weakness, it’s just a different way to deal with a situation. Besides, we’re not in your shoes and wouldn’t know the full story like you do anyways. Who is anyone to call you weak?

  • chantel

    Member
    August 6, 2022 at 12:35 pm

    Hi heartbroken,

    I think it takes a lot to process the pain and unfairness involved in infidelity…it is a series of unloving choices from someone who is supposed to have your back. I’m a WS and I know that partially it would be very freeing for my spouse to just leave, say “eff it”, and try to start fresh…I feel that the BS needs to deeply focus on what fortifies them and be allowed to have as much alone time as needed to work through feelings. Especially in attempts to reconcile, the BS is on a journey to sort all the facets of their hurt, even if the WS is doing maximum work to rebuild, the BS has a lot to decide on rearrange on their own. I think a big part of it is understanding what your pre-affair values were and how they were threatened by the actions of the WS…your personal schema has been severely rocked and you have to see if your fortified/adapted value set meshes with the spouse. IFS therapy is good for examining these issues. Ultimately, as Cait talks about, it comes down to how the person who hurt you factors into your personal life concept. Just know, it is totally your decision and you can leave whenever if you need to. The feeling of being trapped and obligated isn’t going to help a true reconciliation.

Log in to reply.