Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Rant-Rave-Questions › struggling with my options, need your input

  • struggling with my options, need your input

    Posted by idkwtd9 on May 24, 2023 at 10:42 am

    I’ve been with an amazing woman for nearly 5 years. We click in so many ways. We have a mature connection. I deeply love her in a familial way and I think she loves be as intensely in a familial way. Our sexual/romantic side is lacking. We are both sober from all drugs and alcohol. I’ve proposed sexual novelty, swinging, dirty talk, etc. I’ve done therapy for over a year trying to accept the relationship as it is and that sexual novelty and excitement just go away in long term relationships. She won’t even finish reading one book I asked her to on this topic. She won’t try the novel things I’ve suggested. Sex is ok but that’s it. The other aspects of our life are good to great.

    I feel stuck in a way.

    A. Accept the lack of sexual spice in my life and just be ok with not being ok that our exciting sexual life is gone, for now or forever I don’t know; and try to focus getting excitement in other aspects of life. This is what I have been trying to do until now.

    B. Break it off before I cheat because that’s what everyone says you’re supposed to do “break up with me before you cheat on me”.

    C. Cheat with someone who generally loves their partner and their regular life like I do; because they don’t want anything else except sexual novelty and adventure as well.

    I know option B is the noble way. Option A is the depressing way, if noble to a degree. Option C is the ignoble way but does not totally upend my life until/if the affair is discovered; plus I’m already prone to guilt issues so I don’t think I could handle that pressure.

    All this to say, can anyone give me some words of encouragement or advice on how to handle the situation at this juncture. Life sound more peaceful not being together because then I can’t do this really awful thing. Breaking up is still pretty awful but only slightly less so. I’d love to man up and accept option A but that sounds worse than the others.

    Just need some words of guidance or encouragement or how to think in this situation. Thank you for reading.

    replied 3 years, 5 months ago 6 Members · 6 Replies
  • 6 Replies
  • eliza4one

    Member
    May 24, 2023 at 7:19 pm

    I’m assuming you’ve talked to her about choices A. B. C. (?) If not, then you need to. She needs to KNOW how serious an issue this is for you! If she doesn’t know…then you are keeping her in the dark and she is powerless to do anything about it. Yes, it seems you’ve prodded her, told her, etc. But, have you laid it all out on the line for her? (As in here are options A. B. C. I can’t handle Option A. I’m leaning towards Option C.

    No, you don’t have to settle. No you shouldn’t settle. You have needs, too. And the fact that you are even considering choice C is a huge red flag in your relationship. YES…!!! She WILL FIND OUT. Your sexual needs to not take precedence over hurting and scarring someone for life due to said sexual needs. So, lay it on the line for her. If you can’t communicate things like this honestly and openly, then really, it isn’t much of a relationship, is it…

    Honesty is very difficult, but it is also very vital.

    A couple things confusing to me about your post. I am not sure what mature love means. I’m not sure what familial love means. I’m not sure what being sober has to do with things… Were you both once addicts(?) (You don’t have to answer these questions).

  • alita

    Member
    May 26, 2023 at 5:59 am

    I don’t think option C is even an option. Do you realize the pain and hurt she would have to go through if and when she finds out. Also the shame and guilt that you would feel for destroying someone who loved you. Also For how long do you think you can continue doing it without you falling for someone else or someone else falling for you.

    Talk to her instead. Tell her how important it is for you to have a good sex life. If she doesn’t understand and you really are unhappy with your sex life go for option b.

  • cait

    Member
    May 28, 2023 at 9:42 pm

    I agree with Eliza. You should put it to her. Let her choose A, B, or C.

    Personally, I can’t imagine getting so fussed about spicy sex or a lack thereof that I would throw away the love of a good spouse. I would rather have a good cuddle than a good orgasm…. but I wouldn’t say no to both. (Are you giving good cuddle?) We’re all getting older and I can’t imagine things remain as spicy as they do in the younger years for most couples.

    Companionship, loyalty, friendship, understanding, and honesty will always matter. Maybe for you, sex is paramount to feeling understood and accepted? If you can put it in a way that makes it clear that it is vital to your sense of self and your happiness, maybe she can understand and try.

    Start small. Definitely don’t lead with swinging. I would feel all NO if my husband broached that….in fact I was all no. I shut down totally and felt rejected an unloved. If he started somewhere smaller, I would have had more of an open mind. For example, dirty talk doesn’t have to be smut…it can even be like “checking in.” Do you like it when I do this and that? Buy her some lingerie that makes her feel confident. Does she know that you still find her desirable? Shower her with compliments and appreciation. Book a weekend away and pop some champagne in a hot tub. Run your hand along her leg at a restaurant. All these things bring an element of sensuality that you both can enjoy. Sex doesn’t have to be hardcore porn to be spicy. And honestly, for women, if it “looks good” then it doesn’t feel good. A lot of what you see in porn is an endurance test for the actress, not a good time. Whenever my husband tries to emulate what he sees on the screen, it usually hurts.

    Maybe you can start romancing her again. So many men wonder why the sex life wanes after marriage. Imo, it is mainly because the husband stops pursuing his wife because he already got the girl. She married you because of how you made her feel. Make her feel like that again and maybe the spice will come back again too.

    Last thought, you are probably going to run into this problem in most relationships. If you toss her for some new sexual adventure with the next woman, in five years I guarantee you will be arguing over who takes the garbage out and doing more Netflix and chilling than banging and swinging. Novelty is short term.

  • january2222

    Member
    May 29, 2023 at 6:33 am

    I agree with Eliza. You should be open and honest with her. It will probably bring you closer together also it opens the door for her to be more vulnerable with you.

    Good luck,

    January2222

  • chantel

    Member
    May 29, 2023 at 7:30 am

    Not option C.

    Read the stories on this site. Cheating ruins lives forever.

    Accept that you can’t shame another person into being as horny as you are and go find a more appropriate match…or be single and get your needs met. No judgements, just go get what you are looking for without causing pain to others.

    I’m a cheater who knows.

  • idkwtd9

    Member
    May 31, 2023 at 4:50 am

    I sincerely appreciate everyone’s thoughts and perspectives. That is helpful to read and consider. I am grateful to be able to pause in making a decision on this and have it feel like less of a crisis any particular day. I’ve talked to her time and again about the situation and she does not seem to make lasting changes. Its disheartening but overall our relationship is great and worth hanging onto for right now. You’re all correct. Option C is not really an option but feels like the only way at times. She deserves better than that. Thank you for helping me keep perspective.

Log in to reply.