Oh Eliza, I am sending prayers your way. It is especially disheartening when those of us who are years past D-day make “regressions” to feelings of despair again. Everything is temporary–the good moments and the bad. So this too will pass.
I often seriously considered divorce just so I wouldn’t have to think on this matter anymore. Just so I could take a break from thinking about him and what he did and whether it is worth it to stay. It is tiring. And it is our burden because the cheaters often don’t take on the decision of whether to stay or go. But my kids are young and, like you, I don’t want to destroy my family. We worked hard to get here. I want my kids to have the best launch they can in life and it is only possible if we make it work.
I am also Catholic but feel weirdly fortunate that my husband refused to marry me in the church and would only do the courthouse route. It deeply upset me at the time because I made all my other sacraments, except this one. To be honest, he sort of sprung his sudden agnosticism on me–I probably wouldn’t have given him a serious go if I knew he had no faith whatsoever. But if I ever leave, I am only breaking vows to the state (big whoop) and to him (which he did first). By his choice, I never said vows before God. So I will do what suits me/ my family without the great anchor of Catholic guilt.
My mom is super Catholic and had to divorce my father because he turned all his abuse on HER once I moved out and wasn’t shielding her anymore. It was too much for any one person to bear. She struggled with the decision for years as well. But ultimately, she decided to leave because she felt like she was “living in sin soup.” Being in a situation that brought out the worst feelings and impulses in her was making her worry for her soul. She couldn’t be her best self and couldn’t let her considerable light shine. She talked it over with her priest and some nuns and they all pretty much told her to get out of it. So there must be grounds for divorce in church canon somewhere, or there is a liberal interpretation to be had. She is at peace now, even if she is sad that the marriage didn’t work out. If only he were a better man. Making the decision is the hardest part, I think.
To be completely honest with you, I think you would be happier if you divorced him and had closure. If your kids are grown and flown, you won’t be destroying your family like you worry. You and your husband would still get along as friends and can still be around each other. It might not be the fracture that you think it will be. I also think making the decision about what to do will give you the peace you so deserve.
Take my advice with a huge grain of salt because I am still with my cheater and still on this site working through the pain. I obviously haven’t moved past it all either!
I am still so sorry that this happened to you. You deserved and deserve SO much better. You are a class act and he is a true fool.