Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Members Stories › Is it possible, the person i had an affair with I am really deeply in love with

  • johnnyfive

    Member
    July 6, 2021 at 11:12 am

    Sure it would be par for the course if I had been cheating on her for 15 years but that is not the case. I suspected she cheated on me at some point before I ever did, 5 years infact and frankly I didn’t care. I told her I hope you find happiness elsewhere because you are obviously not happy here.

    There are two sides to every story and I have feelings as well. There is the saying don’t judge someone unless you walk a mile in their shoes….that is what i am asking for input on.

    I get her being hurt I really do. But I am as well, totally appreciate that hers is a bit more acute at current but mine should not be brushed over just because I “did something wrong”….I have feelings as well and they are starting to come out and say – I’m not willing to compromise any more.

  • eliza4one

    Member
    July 6, 2021 at 1:01 pm

    My journey is going better than I expected at this point in time. Thanks for asking. As harsh as I was to you about my feelings on infidelity, I am also acutely aware that no human being is perfect. We all make mistakes. But, in the process, we should discover ourselves more deeply. You are doing that. So am I. We are just on different “sides of the fence” so to speak.

    I do hope you and your wife can be friends. That is what my hope was before my husband decided he wanted to reconcile. Even if we don’t work out, being friends will most definitely be in our future. We genuinely like each other. Always have. Always will. (I have learned “love” is a fickle word…hence my using the term like instead of love). 🙂

  • shale

    Member
    July 6, 2021 at 6:02 pm

    If something is not working, fix it, make an effort. If you both cannot fix it, make the decision together to move on. What if the tables were turned and your wife was the one who was cheating and you the loyal partner? It takes two to make a relationship breakdown. Ask yourself what were you doing to contribute to the breakdown. In my opinion if you cannot truly answer that, it follows you. Your wife deserve to know that you do not intend to work on the relationship. Sounds to me she is going through a lot of pain and hurt – the sense of losing something you had. Your safe space. Women know, they know when the person who is suppose to love and protect them has changed and someone else is in the picture. Women know. Do the right thing and talk with her. You do not want to start another relationship on a lie. Nothing good comes out of that in the long run.

  • cait

    Member
    July 7, 2021 at 7:52 pm

    I am sorry if she cheated on you before and made you feel unlikeable. I will admit that it seems like every man who has cheated on his wife does say similar things to what you are saying… “she never liked me” or “she doesn’t understand me.” It’s hard not to feel jaded about those lines, frankly. But if that is truly your case, then it must have been painful to deal with for 15 years. It sounds like you have moved on, though.

    I think you had an exit affair to leave the marriage. It is scary to leave a relationship (even a troubled one) without someone waiting for you on the other side. In order to answer your question of “could this affair partner be my true love?” you probably need to determine if you were running FROM your wife or running TO your AP. Is your AP looking better because of the comparisons to an unhappy marriage? Or is your AP truly that special?


  • johnnyfive

    Member
    July 8, 2021 at 6:59 am

    That is what I am truly grappling with, thank you for saying it so well. My AP and I haven’t spoken in a while. I want to call but I am not picking up the phone. I’m waiting to see how I feel. But as I go deeper with the counselor and discuss things like connection and getting to trust, my mind wanders to my AP (who i really have trouble referring to her that way). That’s how i felt about her and that’s how I feel when i talk to her or that is how she made me feel. Was I more deeply in love with her than I thought? Its funny with the noise of two women gone it really is helping me find clarity.

    And I feel ok going it alone, despite how scary that seems.

  • defeatedmarine

    Member
    July 8, 2021 at 7:38 am

    I applaud you for the journey your on and trying to see different aspects of things. I already said my best advice for your scenario but I wanted to also say you can’t compare how you reacted to suspecting she was having an affair to how she reacts after proof wanting her to react as you did. You’ve already said that before you saw yourself as a person who would never cheat, youd leave a marriage before cheating but then come to find out its not the case. I’m sure almost everyone here that has been cheated on and has stayed to try to make things work will tell you the same I am about to. I had a very similar reaction when I suspected she might be cheating, that if she is fine go with him were through and I honestly wish you the best “its no skin off my back I know my worth.” However when it came to actually knowing that it happened, even before I confronted her just when I found the proof, the whole situation changed. I can’t even put the feeling into words, a part of you dies, you question your self worth, you question if your partner ever cared about you or if they tried to intentionally hurt you, you get this feeling in your stomach which isn’t like hunger but still an empty pit that is flipping and spinning. Even when you can bring yourself to finally eat again the feeling doesn’t go away, it persists. You find yourself convincing yourself you’re fine for awhile then with no warning like a slap in the face you break and cry and cant stop. This is a lot of the reasons why you can feel the judging from time to time. It’s not that we intend to but that it reminds us of this pain. Also, some people have spouses who won’t talk about it much so human nature tends to gravitate towards a substitute if one exists.

    It sounds to me like you don’t want to work on the relationship and that’s ok. If you honestly don’t then the best way for you to try to stay friends and cooperative co parents is to talk to her and let her know in a nice way. Don’t make it about how you love this OW, but about how the spark between you and her is gone (I’d still apologize again and mention how you wish you would’ve handled it better and separated first you didn’t want to hurt her). Like I said it’s ok the want to end the relationship, but I’d suggest trying to have a little more compassion for her feelings until you make up your mind on if you are going to leave or not. Either decision you chose it will help you if you do.

  • keeley1

    Member
    July 10, 2021 at 9:10 am

    Johnnyfive – there is no excuse for having an affair. And blaming your wife is just shifting the responsibility. It’s on you, cowardly to start an affair & not talk to your wife about how you were feeling in your marriage. When I found out about my husband’s affair one thing he told me was that I made him feel like shit. The reality, which he now sees, is that the affair & the other woman is what actually made him feel like shit. He became someone he was disgusted with.

    Our therapist used the term “polar attraction” (I think); meaning the infrequency & excitement from seeing the other woman was a rush, but not a sustainable real relationship. With time and clarity, my husband sees the neediness on both of them and her control & manipulation of him – it makes him hate himself for allowing it. And for all the damage he’s caused me, us, and our family. He also sees now that he was fake with the other woman, never his true self; but being who/what she needed.

    In our situation, which has been and is a long road to recover, my husband realizes that “I am & always was his person”, he just got really lost.

    If you truly don’t live your wife then you need to leave the relationship. However, I caution you on thinking that you will have a wonderful life with the other woman. Remember, the foundation of your relationship with the other woman is built on a bed of betrayal. When the “honeymoon” period ends & normal life kicks in, will you two actually really trust each other? Will your kids every forgive you & accept the other woman into the family?

    Maybe you need time completely alone, work on yourself, and then see where your road takes you.

    Good luck & I hope you make good choices.

  • keeley1

    Member
    July 10, 2021 at 9:31 am

    Johnnyfive- one more thought …

    If you aren’t already, I encourage you to get individual counseling. Sort out the reasons you had the affair & help see pathways for your future. Be honest & transparent with your therapist.

    Good luck

  • johnnyfive

    Member
    July 12, 2021 at 7:02 am

    Thanks Keeley, feel that was a little projective of you.

    1. I am in individual counselling,

    2. Marriage was rough from the start

    3. With my AP i really felt what love could be like. Never knew love like that and its gone.

    4. Happy with all of my choices. Sorry that i hurt my wife.

Page 2 of 2

Log in to reply.