Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Members Stories › Accidentally cheated

  • Accidentally cheated

    Posted by rave4 on August 22, 2023 at 1:38 pm

    When an ethically nonmonogomous relationship turns unethical…

    This might be a completely unique situation, which leaves me feeling so alone and lost. But my fiancé is very kinky and in the past year has convinced me to hookup with our best friend to fulfill his fantasy. We chose him to try it with because my fiancé knows that I never have been into casual hookups, and need to have an emotional connection with the person I’m being intimate with. So we thought our best friend would be a perfect candidate. Meanwhile I had not the slightest clue that it would even be possible to fall for our friend. I didn’t even have a sexual attraction to him or a crush on him, just admiration and love, but I wanted to be my fiance’s kinky dream girl so I was willing to try. Well, me and said friend had an absolutely incredible time. So much to the point of us really developing something so special and meaningful within the month that we were FWB’s. Once my fiancé saw how happy i was with everything he became more and more unhappy and jealous. Eventually i realized that i may be polyamorous because i genuinely love and enjoy both of them and i didn’t feel like one relationship took anything away from the other. I was so naive. My fiancé was super upset when he realized I had feelings and when he had enough he forced an abrupt end to this experiment. That hurt me and our friend immensely and ever since we have been doing everything in our power to heal and move on, but I’m losing hope that i will ever be able to truly forget him, especially because hes still our best friend and his feelings for me are reciprocated. The other huge problem is how toxic my relationship with my fiancé has become. Hes convinced himself that I’ve changed, not the woman he asked to marry him, not trustworthy, a liar, a cheater. I’ve been in therapy and I’ve been trying to figure out a way how to fix this on my own because he puts all the blame on me. Meanwhile I have him doubting me and gaslighting me everyday because of how much i hurt him and he just lets his insecurities and fears do the talking. I feel like I’ve reached a dead end. My partner won’t allow us to be happy together, but separating our lives is going to be a pain in the ass. We bought a house together and we live together. Plus he’s the love of my life and ive committed so much to this man. I made a vow to be with him forever and love him unconditionally. I realize that in this situation I’m the one that is the issue and so I don’t blame him for not being happy with me anymore. Just such a huge adjustment. He claims that I did this on purpose and that our relationship was never solid. But the only reason I did it was because I truly believed that we were solid and that nothing could come between us, especially not our best friend who we both love and adore. I still have to see the friend at least once a week which makes it even harder, because they are still best friends despite the awkward tension between them. I am confused and fragmented and soooo tired on so many different levels.

    replied 3 years, 2 months ago 2 Members · 2 Replies
  • 2 Replies
  • bob47

    Member
    August 23, 2023 at 12:15 am

    Your fiancé sounds incredibly toxic and manipulative. He pushed this thing knowing who you are and that you may become attached. Then blows it up and places all the blame on you for it going sideways. He wanted this. He pushed for it and when it didn’t go according to his megalomaniac plan he turns on everyone. What a child. He should have looked into this a bit more at the beginning and had a real conversation about the risks with you but no he was too busy getting turned on by some internet porn fantasy. You sure you wanna still marry this guy?

  • cait

    Member
    August 23, 2023 at 10:26 am

    You were set up to fail from the beginning. I can relate even though I am a betrayed partner on this site.

    My (cheater) husband has also pressured me into including another man in the bedroom because he has a “hot wife” kink. But, like you, I can’t just have sex with some random person. I am aromantic. I would have to have feelings for them that they would have to reciprocate for sex to feel “safe” to me. So yeah. That means you were doomed from the get-go because of course you will develop feelings. You already like them as a person and now you have great sex? Isn’t that what a relationship is all about?

    Your fiancée arranged all of this. He has to grow up and accept some part of the responsibility. My husband would be the same way, accountability is too hard for him. I also feel like he might just want to “dirty” me up so I am as dirty as him and no longer have the moral high ground. Some part of him must know he isn’t on my level. That is why I haven’t done the hot wife kink thing, but if he pressured me when I was younger and more desperate to please him, I can see how I might. I can see why you did. But really, I just want to have sex with one man. The man I love.

    It is a shame we make everything so complicated and messy when it could be simple and beautiful. All this shit people get from porn is just polluting their minds and making them dissatisfied with a life of contentment and love. Sad.

    I caution you against marriage to him. You are already starting off the marriage on the back foot and being blamed for something that wasn’t totally your fault. That puts him in the position of power (which may have been his intention all along, who knows) and you as the repenter who has to make it up to him. Not promising, girl! Start as you mean to go.

Log in to reply.