I am very soory for the situation you are in, and will offer my humble opinion and advice, some of it may sound harsh, but you need to hear it from a neutral party, and yes, I have been where you are, twice.
A cheater first becomes a good lier, you need to keep this in mind. Him saying it only happened once, wasn’t going on for long, etc, is a classic way cheaters down-play their actions.
You say he has had “phone relationships” before, that never went this far………How can you be certain??? This is a man that cheated on you, how can you trust that anything he says is true?
The comment that a friend made to me during my personal expericence was this – You have been listening to your heart, you need listen to your gut………
Now as far as the future, I am mostly in the line-of-thinking that once a cheater, always a cheater, but people can change if the conditions are right,and they do really want to change their life. He will need to come clean about all his actions, the ones you know about, and the ones you don’t.
Your lack of trust is normal, and I am sad to say, it will take quite some time to get it back, and even if you do, this event will never really exit your mind, you just have to learn how to live with it.
I reccomend you seperate for a while, the time apart will help you heal somewhat, and clear your head. For him, it will give him time to ponder what damage and pain his actions have caused.
In the mean time, I highky reccomend you get tested for STDs, you may have been exposed to something.
Whatever you decide, I wish you all the best, and I am going to say a prayer for you all.