Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Members Stories › Did I make the right decision…🤷🏽‍♀️Please give me your opinion bad or good.

  • Did I make the right decision…🤷🏽‍♀️Please give me your opinion bad or good.

    Posted by tara81 on May 21, 2021 at 12:37 pm

    I sometimes feel like I sabotage my recovery. Things are well and today I have the urge to bring it up. It’s been 9 months, and I still question if I made the right choice. I got so much trickled truth from him. I have written many posts on here trying to gain clarity. I do want to say that I am in a much better mental space. I no longer cry and if I do my eyes only get misty. No more gut wrenching sobs. When it first happen he said it was only a 7 months affair. Later found that it was more like 4 years.

    His response: it’s not what I think or picture. It was on/off and no real time spent together just stolen moments. He was not in love with her. It was just a huge mistake. He was just curious. He was never planning to leave me. He hoped that we would repair our marriage 🤦🏽‍♀️

    My view: it was 6 years because although he said it ended 2018, I didn’t find out until 2020. When she so graciously told me. To me he was lying until than. I still can’t not understand how I didn’t know. To my defense he was never out late. I can count in 1 hand the times where I should have suspected something but even those outings were brief.

    Our background.

    Almost together 25 years. He always supported me and my decisions. We always did things together, watch movies, shows, went out. During his affair we were going through a rough patch. I think I should had left him. We let the marriage become a friendship. I was busy with work, school, our son and any free moment I got I rather spend with my sisters. I think I knew that things were not ok and I didn’t want to be home. We were each other’s only sexual partner. He is a good father and provider. Not very communicative.

    How we are doing now.

    Right from the start he showed remorse. He was so embarrassed and apologized a lot. Was willing to go to counseling. He cut her off completely. They work for the same company but have no need to be around each other. I have complete access to his phone. He even told her off and told her she was a mistake andI was the love of his life. At least that’s what the message said that she sent him a month after telling me about their affair.

    Never blamed me. I can call her every name in the book and he would not even flinch. Has never asked me to not speak about her like that. We go on dates, we have a planned family vacation co I got up, he buys me things, celebrated my bday, Mother’s Day etc. He doesn’t go out, and attends all family outings. He is working on changing the things I requested from him. Doesn’t say anything when I don’t cook and that is often. He will eat whatever I order. In our culture that is not normal, women are expected to have a hot meal prepared for their family. I have financial control of our household. He can be a bit more affectionate but he was never like that, but he is working on it. He doesn’t like to talk about the affair but will answer if I probe enough. It makes him feel like shit and he withdraws from me for a few days.

    He is doing everything right. But I still feel embarrassed that I stayed. I of course love him, or else I wouldn’t have stayed. How do I get over this so that I can be relaxed in my relationship? Why do I have so many doubts? Every affair and every recovery is different but I value everyone’s opinions. I said I would never stay if he cheated, but here I am. Sometimes I think I made it too easy on him but at the same time I know that it hurt him to see me cry. Sometimes I just don’t know if I made the right choice to stay. I told him I forgave him, but I know in my heart that those words are so empty. I try to be positive because I hate wasting my life being upset and it pisses me off that I didn’t do anything wrong but I am the one paying for the broken plates.

    I am leaving him home alone overnight for the first time since DDay. I need to go away for the weekend with my sisters. Need that time away. So I have anxiety over that. I track his location and we have cameras in the house, plus I don’t think he is stupid or has been in contact with her or anyone else.

    I know this is a long post but I need to know that I am working with a salvageable marriage or was his betrayal too much to over come. His affair was more that a one night stand. Thanks for reading.

    replied 5 years, 6 months ago 7 Members · 13 Replies
  • 13 Replies
  • maps

    Member
    May 21, 2021 at 1:10 pm

    It’s so hard to give advice because every person is different, every relationship is different and every affair is different. I’m two months into discovering my husband of almost 20 years has been having an affair with someone from out of town for 10 years. Right now we are trying but I’m still not sure where we will end up. We are going to couples therapy and individual therapy. He seems to be doing all the things he should and frankly, that’s the only reason I’m still here. Like you, we became distant after a while but never so distant that we didn’t do things together and certainly not to the point where I ever would have imagined this was going on. My husband’s whore was kind enough to send me pictures and text messages so that was fun. In the text messages, he’s talking about leaving me and how much he loves her and can’t wait to be with her…blah blah blah. His response, I was just doing that to “keep her sweet.” He will not admit to being in love with her or threatening to leave me. So now I think, what is worse, knowing he loved someone else or knowing that he is the kind of man that would use another person and string another person along just to feed his ego? I honestly don’t know. The hardest part for me is trust. I experienced the trickle effect as well and that definitely makes it worse.

    Only YOU know if you have made the right decision. If you love him and he is doing what he needs to do to make you happy, then you made the right decision. If your conflict is because we are brought up to think “once a cheater always a cheater” and people think staying in a marriage after a spouse cheats means you are weak – I say BS! It’s easy to judge until you are in the same position. This is why I have not and will not share my situation with anyone I know – friends, family – no one – only my therapist. I want to make the decision, not be swayed by other people’s perceptions, biases, and stereotypes.

    I am in the middle of reading an excellent book by Gary Chapman called “The 5 Love Languages.” It is about how we all have our own way of receiving and desiring love and if our partner does not provide love in that way (speak our love language) regardless of anything else they do, we will feel depleted of love. I think there might be some things for my husband and me to learn from this book because we all need to feel loved – it’s a basic human need – and if we don’t feel it, we will search for it until we find it. If a couple can learn to understand each other’s love language and respond accordingly, I can see how it can make a huge difference. Now – I haven’t tried it out yet so I can’t vouch for it, but it makes sense.

    Anyhow – listen to your gut – that will tell you if you made the right decision. 😉

  • tara81

    Member
    May 21, 2021 at 3:30 pm

    I heard that book is really good. I also attached a photo of a book someone recommended I have not read it yet. I also got the gift of pictures. She even got a tattoo with his name. What a dumb bitch. I only told my sisters and they are supportive. This situation just simply sucks for all of us. I hope that we all learn from this and come out stronger and with a new perspective. I know my marriage needed a jumpstart but fuck it didn’t need to be so drastic. Thanks for responding.

  • maps

    Member
    May 21, 2021 at 3:46 pm

    I hear you on the jumpstart! Thanks for the book – same author so I bet it’s good Be strong.

  • eliza4one

    Member
    May 21, 2021 at 3:47 pm

    From everything you have written, I DO think you have made the right decision. I truly do. Now…will that/could that change in the future? Sure. We all know that things can change in an instant/on a dime. However, it truly sounds like he is doing everything right. And you are trying your darndest to forgive him and accept what happened and move on. You are doing wonderful! Keep on, keepin’ on! Keep growing as people and as a couple. Together. I think it is definitely worth it to keep a marriage intact if there is still love and effort. It sounds like there in on both of your parts. If is definitely harder to stay with a spouse who cheated than it is to leave one, imo.

    Wanted to add: Cut yourself some slack on the timing issue…their is no hard/fast line in the sand for when your “healing” is done. You’ll know when it’s done. Obviously, you aren’t there, yet. Your DH has to understand and accept that.

    Don’t be embarrassed you stayed. I get that…when my sisters find out this summer (when we go for our girls only get together), they are not going to like that I haven’t moved towards divorce, yet. Oh, well. My life is my life. Their life is their life. We each get to live our own lives in a manner that suits us. Not others.

  • tara81

    Member
    May 21, 2021 at 4:40 pm

    I think that the only people that understand without judgement are those that have gone through this experience. I used to be one of those people that didn’t understand how some women stayed after their husband cheated. I always said I would be out the door no questions asked. My sister was cheated on and I thought she was so dumb for staying. I supported her but I wished she had the guts to get up and leave. Boy did I have to eat a huge slice of humble pie. Your sisters will definitely ask you what’s going on and make you feel like you are not making the right decision but remember you are the one walking the path. No one will ever understand your feelings or your hesitation. My sisters support me but I know that they think is time for me to stop talking about it. And I am so glad I didn’t tell anyone else. I wished we lived closer because there would be some epic coffee dates.

  • linds

    Member
    May 21, 2021 at 6:25 pm

    So much of your story is so much like mine. I too am at the point where I’m really struggling with the embarrassment of staying and only his family and my sister know. No friends, not my parents, no one. I am so ashamed that I stayed and feel so pathetic. I feel like if I stop talking about it then I’m giving him a free pass and making it ok. If I keep talking about it I drive an even bigger wedge between us and I don’t think we’ll recover. I feel like I’m sabotaging the relationship we could have by holding onto the affair. Mine like yours is doing everything right. Doing everything he can to make things right but I just can’t be receptive a lot of the time. His affair was only 9 months, all texting and sexting until the one sexual experience. Some how I think he feels like that makes it better. I wish I had some words of wisdom for you but I feel exactly the same way. Did I make the right decision or am I just a pushover who allows myself to be taken advantage off, treated like crap. It’s such a tough tough place to be put in.

  • cait

    Member
    May 21, 2021 at 7:25 pm

    Tara, for what it’s worth, I think you are making the right call to try to save the marriage. You have invested so much time/ love/ resources/ KIDS in this marriage that it is completely understandable and commendable that you are trying to salvage it. He is also demonstrating remorse and effort, so that means a lot as well.

    That being said, he effed up big time with such a long affair. That means you will need longer to heal from it. Don’t they say it takes half the time of a relationship to heal from it? That probably applies to an affair, if not longer. I hate this waiting to feel better aspect, too, but I think we are stuck with it. If you left him, you might still feel the same resentment and anger and you also wouldn’t have the benefit of having him trying to make it up to you.

    This is not to say that your decision is final and can’t change. You are trying to make it work (go you!) but that doesn’t mean you are shackled for life. What gives you the most peace is what you should ultimately do, and I definitely think that evolves. But right now, from what you have written here and in the past, I don’t think divorce would be your peace.

    I hate this stigma of staying, but I feel the shame of it, too. Someone overcorrected from the “stand by your man” / “men will be men” nonsense because now we feel shitty for trying to make it work. I think that is just some poisonous cultural bias that we are steeped in, and not necessarily born of our own hearts. It’s hard but try to remember that is not how YOU feel. That is the way that movies, books, songs, and TV shows have trained us to feel.

    You’re managing beautifully. You will be okay no matter the outcome.

  • tara81

    Member
    May 21, 2021 at 9:11 pm

    I can so relate to the feeling of if I don’t talk about it than it means that I’m giving him a free pass. Absolutely not. But if I keep talking about it, it just turns to a fight and a couple of off days. Either way it messes up the recovery. I’m working on not bringing it up, I tell myself that every time I bring it up, I remind him of her. So that keeps me from saying anything.

  • hearbroken

    Member
    May 21, 2021 at 9:17 pm

    I too was absolutely certain that I would leave any man who cheated on me without a backward glance. I always felt that my friend who stayed with a consummate cheater (he even hit on me) was selling herself short. When you’re in that position, it’s not as black and white. I also feel the shame of telling anyone because I don’t want to be judged for staying and I don’t want family and friend relations to be strained or destroyed. Why I feel the need to protect him, I don’t know. I love him, but I hate that he has done this to us. We have to go with our heart. If we feel the relationship was good, then we give it our best shot to rebuild. Maybe it works out and maybe it won’t.

    My husband and I were not giving our marriage the attention it deserved when this started. We were working all the time with no time off together. There was so much tension in the house with our adult son who was living with us with his girlfriend. They were supposed to be saving money to move out, but it dragged on for years. They didn’t contribute anything to the household and were constantly flouting our rules. All of our conversations were about problems with work and problems with our son. This is no excuse for cheating, but I can see how the fantasy was an escape. I escaped in books and he escaped with a whore.

    So now we see if I can move past this and we can grow old together or if it will forever be a festering wound that makes staying together unbearable.

    You made the right decision to try if the relationship you had was worth giving a second chance.

  • tara81

    Member
    May 21, 2021 at 9:28 pm

    Thank you Cait. Your absolutely right. Tv and movies make it look so easy. He cheats, you leave with the kids and move on, start a business and find love again, and your children cope perfectly, they are better off at the end. The reality is that if you have kids, now you have to worry about custody, about having another person around your children, hoping their father honors their responsibilities. Dealing with paying debt together. Hoping he doesn’t stop helping because most cc are under your name, the worry if you’ll be able to keep the house on your own. Not being able to trust another person. Dating. A lot of woman end up loosing everything and in poverty because they make decisions while angry. It’s important to plan an escape plan just in case. I think I need to forgive myself for staying and for still loving him.

  • tara81

    Member
    May 21, 2021 at 9:30 pm

    Thank you everyone. Your opinions really helped me. Not sure why I feel like I needed validation. It all comes back to the shame of staying. I will forgive myself soon. Thanks gain everyone.

  • tomisa

    Member
    May 22, 2021 at 7:30 am

    I really admire you for staying and thinking of your family first. It takes such courage and fortitude and you sound like you really do love him. Truly he doesn’t deserve you. I have no kids or mortgage and I moved out yesterday because it was simpler. I think your choice is harder and you shouldn’t feel embarrassed or ashamed. Nothing is absolute either. You are still coping and if it gets too hard then staying is not a once and for all decision. He has to continue to make it worth your while to deal with the unwanted thoughts and the shadows that he introduced into the relationship. I wish you the very best and peace in your decision

  • cait

    Member
    May 22, 2021 at 9:03 am

    You should feel proud of yourself for staying and still loving him. It’s not a weakness. It takes a lot of bravery to stay with a cheater! And it shows how big your heart truly is.

Log in to reply.