Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Rant-Rave-Questions › Does knowing how/why help at all?

  • Does knowing how/why help at all?

    Posted by strider99k2 on July 5, 2021 at 7:42 am

    I’ve shared this before in a much longer post, but my wife cheated on me twice within the last 2 years after almost 20 years of marriage. I just don’t understand how she could do that to me. She tells me she was just being selfish, but I just can’t accept that. I can’t understand how being selfish equals cheating on me once, swearing never to do it again, promising to renew our vows when we celebrate our 20th anniversary, only to cheat on me again a few months after making that promise.

    Why would she make yet another promise she wasn’t going to keep? Why would she break my heart again when all I wanted to do is heal? Why do I still love her and still want to spend my life with her?

    These are kind of questions that keep coming up in my mind and my heart but she doesn’t want to talk about it anymore. After the first time she cheated we agreed that no matter what she would tell me the truth and be honest but because she doesn’t want to hurt me by telling the truth she’s refusing to discuss these things with me. I’ve almost come to expect her not to keep her word when it suits her.

    Is there anyone out there who has gotten any answers to questions like mine? What difference did it make?

    replied 5 years, 4 months ago 7 Members · 15 Replies
  • 15 Replies
  • dragon

    Member
    July 5, 2021 at 10:04 am

    Because my husband has answered every question I’ve asked, and has answered very honestly, is why I think we are healing. I’m actually learning to trust him again. Not sure I will get to 100% trust, but I truly feel he is putting in the work and commitment to be better. If he didn’t, I would leave. Especially because he still works with his AP.

  • eliza4one

    Member
    July 5, 2021 at 4:35 pm

    Knowing how and why has a twofold effect, imo.

    First, it helps the betrayed heal. My husband has explained again and again his mindset during the 2 year period he was emotionally involved, and then physically involved with her during a work trip. I say again and again because it takes time to process all of it. Just today, 13 months after Dday, we talked yet AGAIN about his mindset during that time. His explanations have helped me have empathy for him, which is important, I believe.

    No one is perfect. We all make mistakes. We all screw up. Some screwups are larger than others, but…knowing the mindset/psyche of the person who made the mistakes helps greatly. If I still had questions about “why”, and my husband were not willing to answer them, I KNOW myself well enough to know I wouldn’t be able to get past it/live with it. Knowing why has helped me heal. I understand not everyone needs that, though! I applaud those who don’t. I guess I’m not that strong.

    Second, each time we talk about my husband’s psyche/mindset during that timeframe, things become clearer in his brain. He is able to process things himself. Gain clarity. Understand himself better. Think about WHY he did what he did. WHAT he was thinking during that time frame. What he could do differently in the future. Even today, something clicked in his brain that he had not thought of in our earlier conversations. Had I not brought up my “wonderings”, he might not have had this new revelation. And he certainly wouldn’t have shared it with me.

    So, being open and honest can be important if the betrayer wants to truly not make the same mistake again. Again, just my opinion, but I do think it is vital. I can guarantee that the conversations my husband and I have had go far deeper than any he would ever have with a counselor. He knows he can open up and be honest with me because I listen and I know him so well.

    I do not believe an affair happens “just because” something was wrong with the marriage. Can that the case? Sure. That doesn’t change the fact that the betrayed HAD A RESPONSIBILITY to TALK to their spouse about said cracks in the marriage!! BEFORE they stepped outside their marriage. They didn’t, though. This leads me to…

    Ultimately I believe someone who steps out of their marriage has a character flaw that needs to be looked at, analyzed, dealt with, etc. I’m not saying that to put down betrayers. We all have character flaws. Human nature and all. It is our responsibility (if we so desire) to know, understand, and learn from our character flaws. To know what makes us tick. To understand why we make the decisions we do.To look at our past to see what influence it has had on our present life. Sadly, the character flaw(s) of betrayers hurt others very deeply, even if they don’t intend it to. Because of that, if they want to truly make amends, (and become better people in the end), it is their responsibility to figure themselves out. Talking with the betrayed spouse can help with that.

    Sorry this is so long. I have very strong views on this topic. Take it for what it’s worth. My opinion.

  • defeatedmarine

    Member
    July 5, 2021 at 5:08 pm

    I agree. Being honest and open is a primary need if you want to be able to heal. You know my story as I know yours. I’m still in a lot of pain and confused but recently we had another discussion about it. She told me that a part of her did it again because she was mad at me and wanted to hurt me. As awful as this sounds it actually helped me and her. She is try to change that aspect of herself and I believe more that she is no longer keeping secrets from me. There is no way you can heal, in my opinion, if she won’t be honest with you or talk to you about it.

  • eliza4one

    Member
    July 5, 2021 at 5:16 pm

    You said: There is no way you can heal, in my opinion, if she won’t be honest with you or talk to you about it.

    I so agree! Rebuilding the marriage is going to be that much more difficult, too. There’s the healing aspect AND the rebuilding of the marriage aspect to consider…

  • cait

    Member
    July 5, 2021 at 6:32 pm

    Knowing how/ why was essential for me to wrap my head around it. I still feel surprised that this happened every day. I don’t know how he could hurt me if he loved me.

  • strider99k2

    Member
    July 6, 2021 at 5:42 am

    My wife started out answering my questions after the first affair, but she started to evade conversation around the time she started the second affair. (That was my first sign she was cheating again.) When it comes down to it I don’t think my wife wants to face the pain she caused me and it’s easier for her to just call it quits and get a divorce. She seems to always be ready to talk about divorce and as much as it pains me I can’t make her do anything right, let alone stay in this marriage.

  • strider99k2

    Member
    July 6, 2021 at 6:39 am

    Thank you for such a clear explanation. I think part of the problem is that my wife doesn’t want to face the pain she caused me. Her excuse for avoiding conversation about her second affair is that it would hurt me too much. To your second point, I don’t think my wife wants to do any kind of introspection. I feel like she really needs to have a deep understanding of why she is almost 40 years old and engaging in high risk behavior. By high risk I mean this is the second time she cheated on me with someone she met on the internet after only knowing them for a few months. They could have killed her, robbed her, done any number of things to her an know one would have known. She could have gotten an STI.

    The excuses she gives me are that we got married young and she didn’t get to live much before we got married. Another one is that she felt like she sacrificed for everyone else and wanted to do something that was just for her. Both of those might be totally valid, but for me, I can’t see how that by itself leads someone to cheat on their spouse twice in two years after nealy 20 years of marriage. And that after promising to renew vows on our 20th anniversary. I mean, I could use the same excuses, but I’ve never even given her one reason to believe I’ve cheated because I never wanted to. I feel like there is something deeper that she hasn’t figured out yet. She drags her feet when it comes to getting individual counseling which I believe is a passive agressive way to say she doesn’t want to do it. She doesn’t want to get marriage counseling because she says we talked about her affair too much and it was a painful experience, another unsatisfactory excuse in my opinion. At the end of the day I can’t make her see what she is walking away from, I can’t make her love and respect me the way I deserve, and I can’t carry the burden of keeping our marriage together on my own. I can’t make her stay if she just wants to avoid the pain she’s caused. And yet I still lover her more than anything.

  • strider99k2

    Member
    July 6, 2021 at 6:53 am

    I have to say I’m really encouraged that there has been some positive progress in your situation. Also, you’re not wrong. After she cheated the first time we had an agreement that she would be honest and truthful with the understanding that the truth wasn’t always going to be what I wanted to hear. We were good for a while and then she cheated again. I can’t express enough that this is totally out of her character. If you had told me 3 years ago that she would have even considered betraying me like she’s done over the last two years I would have told you to watch what you say about my wife and that you have the wrong person. Now, I guess I shouldn’t be surprised that she would back out of our agreement because “it would hurt me too much.” I think that excuse is BS because if she had any concern about hurting me, or if she “cares about my well being” like she claimed recently then she wouldn’t have made the choices she made. It’s beyond frustrating that there is nothing I can do to make her talk to me and be honest and truthful even though it would transform our relationship. I’m at my wit’s end, but every time someone shares any little bit of progress they’ve made it gives me hope. At the same time I’m slowly realizing that my wife is purposefully sabotaging our marriage and I may never understand why. I’m conflicted and confused.

  • strider99k2

    Member
    July 6, 2021 at 6:57 am

    I’m right there with you. I think of all the times she said she loved me, how I’m a great lover, how I’m a good father and a good man. If that’s true then why is she doing this to me? I feel like she lies so much now so was she lying then too? At this rate I may never know…

  • movingforward

    Member
    July 6, 2021 at 8:02 am

    I think your wife has issues with being able to self reflect…. It’s a very very painful process My husband had thick walks put up for years and he found a therapist that was able to teach him how to honestly look at himself. Until your wife does this she will never be happy with you or anyone else. My take is she uses the affairs as a way to distract herself…she is running from herself. The affairs serve as a temporary fix but in the end she still has to face herself and who she is. She’s unhappy and searching for something or someone to make her happy. Before my husbands affair he would buy classic cars and harleys thinking 1) he deserved them and 2) they would fill the hole inside him. The affair was just more of the same.

    It sounds like you really love your wife, maybe if you could convince her to see a therapist it could make a difference like it has in my marriage. Good luck to you

  • eliza4one

    Member
    July 6, 2021 at 10:13 am

    I agree, movingforward. Self-reflection is important for all humans, but especially humans that have made grave mistakes. Love your post!

  • eliza4one

    Member
    July 6, 2021 at 10:16 am

    You said: If that’s true then why is she doing this to me?

    Remember: This has more to do with her than it does with you. SHE is the one with issues that she can’t quite grasp. Her actions are a reflection of what’s wrong with her. I know that’s hard to accept/believe. It’s what I’m struggling with right now, too. As much as I know my husband’s actions are a reflection of his inner psyche “issues”, it is very hard to not still take it personally. Ugh. The psychological mind games adultery plays on us! I hate it!

  • eliza4one

    Member
    July 6, 2021 at 10:18 am

    Strider~

    Yes, we have made positive progress, thank goodness. But I still struggle daily with feeling “not good enough”, “2nd best”, “the consolation prize”, etc. I HATE it!

    You are correct, you can’t control your wife. You can’t make her do, believe, see…what you want her to do/believe/see…it is up to her.

    You ride the wave(s) until you decide you can no longer do so. Then you jump off and figure out what to do next. You’ll know when the time is right.

  • eliza4one

    Member
    July 6, 2021 at 10:24 am

    You said: I feel like she really needs to have a deep understanding of why she is almost 40 years old and engaging in high risk behavior.

    Yes, she does. And you are right, she put herself into a very dangerous situation. I hope that doesn’t happen again.

    You said: The excuses she gives me are that we got married young and she didn’t get to live much before we got married. Another one is that she felt like she sacrificed for everyone else and wanted to do something that was just for her.

    Me to a T! Excuses…!!!

    Military wife/spouse/mother. Married at 20. Gave up my own “life” for my husband’s military career and to raise my children. At no point in time did I feel the need to have an affair. Again, I do believe it boils down to something deep within a person. A person who feels whole doesn’t feel the need to fill any emptiness because there is no emptiness to fill.

  • whichwaydoigo

    Member
    July 18, 2021 at 5:27 pm

    I’m very new to all of this. Your post was very insightful. Thank you to everyone who commented. I’ve known for a day about my husband’s affair and I’m a jumble of messy emotions, but this post hits home and is re-assuring.

Log in to reply.