Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Rant-Rave-Questions › Emotional affair: Is it cheating?

  • Emotional affair: Is it cheating?

    Posted by cait on August 12, 2020 at 6:52 pm

    Hello all, this is my first time here. I hope I can find some support here, because I don’t know where to turn.

    Three years ago, my husband fell out of love with me. We used to have such a loving, affectionate marriage and I thought he was my soulmate. Then, one day he told me he wasn’t sure if he loved me anymore and didn’t know if he wanted to be married to me anymore.

    I had suspicions because he was obsessed with his phone and brought it everywhere, never letting me see it. He talked constantly about his looks and a coworker, Natalie. When I asked him if he was having an affair, he denied it.

    Eventually he came back to me but our love has not been the same. I feel scared to love him because of how devastated I was before. We have had 2 children since then and each birth has weakened our marriage further. The other night we talked about the disconnect and I grilled him until he admitted he had an emotional affair with that coworker, Natalie.

    She lives in another state and they never physically met but they traded sexual videos, pictures, and stories. They also talked all day, every day. I know for sure he was not coming to me during that time (around 6 months) for any love or affection. He admitted that she was angry the few times we did have sex and expected him to leave me for her.

    He ended things when I became pregnant with our first child and Natalie has gone on to marry another man. My husband thinks what he did was not REALLY cheating because he never physically saw her, but it devastated me. It’s made me question everything. What the hell is love, if it can just end on a dime?

    I know it might seem like “ancient history” given that 3 years have elapsed, but I only just found out about Natalie last week. That period of time where he stopped showing me any love at all has haunted me. My husband wrung a promise from me not to tell anyone because his father was cheated on by his first wife and the family would react very badly. So now, I am left to deal with this on my own, with a one-year-old and three-year old to care for. (Little ones do not give you much down time to process!)

    I feel depressed because Natalie and my husband were the ones who did wrong, but I am the one holding the bag. They get away with it, really.

    I guess my questions for this community are these:

    1. Was it really cheating?

    2. Do you have any suggestions for feeling better? I feel like a wounded bird. 🙁

    3. Is it a bad idea to write a letter to Natalie? I want to release some of my hurt, but my husband is afraid it will open up a can of worms and someone from his family will find out.

    Any other suggestions are welcome!

    Thank you!

    replied 5 years, 11 months ago 6 Members · 8 Replies
  • 8 Replies
  • lvoss

    Member
    August 13, 2020 at 9:43 am

    Hi there, I am so sorry to hear you are going through this. While my husbands infidelity was physical, I cant imagine what you are going through. To answer your questions, #1 yes, I feel that what he did is a form of cheating (others may disagree) He also needs to hold himself accountable for the pain he has caused you and IF he doesn’t want you telling others then he needs to make himself available to talk and work with you through this. #2 I know Therapy is such a clique suggestion but I never understood the power of it until I started speaking to a therapist myself. She does not judge me for choosing to stay with my husband and gives me practical incite into healing and feeling better. My husband and I chose to start seeing a marriage counselor on top of him seeing his own therapist as well. His willingness to start making these steps has helped me heal a little bit bc I can see he is willing to do the work it takes to get us back on track. Maybe if your husband is willing to do things you need to feel better this will shed some light at the end of the tunnel. #3 if you think writing Natalie a letter will make you feel better then I say do it. However, that might be a double edge sword in the end. If you want to move forward with your husband maybe not involving “her” will help the past stay the past and the future will look brighter. I only say this bc the phrase “be careful what you wish for” comes to mind. I reached out to the slob my husband slept with and it made things worse not better, but I chose to go digging and it put my head space more in the past These are just my thoughts and I hope anything I have said has helped you even 5%!

  • sheribri

    Member
    August 14, 2020 at 7:27 am

    Hi. I also was dealing with an emotional affair that my husband had with a girl much younger than myself. It was all through texts and phone calls and yes this is 100% cheating. When your partner steps outside of the marriage and confides in someone else it is an emotional affair. My husbands affair stemmed from his unhappiness in his life, not just the marriage but on a whole feels like he is unhappy, probably a mid life crisis. We had a good marriage and the pain from his betrayal has run deep. I am seeing a therapist and so is he. In my opinion the only way to heal from something like this is through transparency and earning back the trust.

  • native

    Member
    August 19, 2020 at 7:32 pm

    Hi same here it’s my first time . My husband started playing online game Myth Wars a couple months ago. I noticed there was a group chat for the alliance he was in , well one day at the mall noticed a app called line i never saw before. He said it was for the game it’s how they talked . Well i downloaded the app their is a group chat there but after some digging , he downloaded an app called line can also be used as a dating app, and i found women hidden in his hidden areas , said have no idea how they got there blah blah blah , well i hacked is game account found him telling the leader “ love my slammy “ with kiss face emoji and then telling another women can’t wait to catch up with you this weekend ! In our marriage this is a nono we don’t tell people of the opposite sex we love them that we don’t know and we don’t have secret chats with girls on the weekends! Needless to say i confronted him about it and i’m crazy and bitch i hacked his crap i don’t trust him i’m insecure 😟 well the past 7yrs they have been porn sites and other women online i know how this goes . I always ask are you doing anything? of course i know i’m not gonna get the truth but i ask then i dig and i get my answer. I feel for your pain and i’m sorry and emotional connect with another women is cheating your taking time away from your loved in your spend time with the opposite sex that your hiding or not bring completely honest about it🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️

  • cait

    Member
    August 25, 2020 at 6:27 am

    Thanks for your reply, Ivoss. What you wrote was really helpful and gave me some perspective; I read it a few times! I think you are probably right about writing to Natalie. It might be better to focus on the future rather than the past. I also called a counselor to set up an appointment. I think it will be a bit weird doing it via video conference, but I have to try something.

  • lvoss

    Member
    September 3, 2020 at 11:15 am

    SLOWLY the therapy will help. I still have crap days and I wonder when it will end. Then there are days that I see the man I feel in love with and I fall back in love all over again. Life and love are an interesting journey to say the least. Has your husband been more supportive recently?

  • cait

    Member
    September 7, 2020 at 5:04 pm

    He is being more mild-mannered. I wouldn’t say he is making a huge effort to “win me back” but I can see that he is not being quite as contrary to live with as he was before he was found out. The other night I broached the topic of divorce hypothetically because I can’t go on feeling this badly. It seemed to “scare him straight” for the night and he agreed to going on dates and couples therapy. That attitude of putting in the work (in our marriage) lasted about 48 hours and now he is back to complacency. He doesn’t want to go on dates of any kind in Covid and doesn’t see the point of therapy. Life is pretty much fine for him, even if I feel awful all the time.

    What kinds of things does therapy do that are so helpful? I keep hoping it will be some miracle but I also don’t know how a counselor can tell me something I don’t already know.

  • stevecase85

    Member
    September 8, 2020 at 6:20 pm

    Yes. It is/was 100 percent cheating. I would not rule out that nothing physical ever happened. I learned that my wife was quite the liar, and was actually pretty good at it. She had three affairs, all with married men. It wasn’t until I uncovered emails and text messages that I got the full truth. The bottom line is your spouse chose someone else over you. They broke their vow and made you look like a fool. I’m sorry this happened to you.

  • jolynn

    Member
    November 29, 2020 at 2:16 pm

    Emotional cheating is just as bad as physical cheating. If your “relationship” is hidden/secretive , then it’s definitely wrong.

    My husband has been addicted to his phone for a length of time. Drives me crazy. Regardless of the many arguments , pleading or talks I had with him. He never changed. I would ( half jokingly) say , ” talking to your gf?” Never wanted to be right about that …

    Two days before Thanksgiving, I receive messages from a woman I don’t know . Yet , she knows my husband…. missing him , hoping he misses her still etc

    Long story short… this was 1.5 – 2 yrs ago. I’m just finding this out now . He was chatting with multiple woman. This person sent me screenshots of their messages , call logs and to read how my husband spoke to these woman , makes me ill . Flirty . Long conversations about our children … phone calls all hours of the night and day ( guess I was sleeping ? At work?) He even “missed her’ . What were you missing??? While I’m working , taking care of our family , washing your clothes , making dinners … you’re missing HER ? I can’t turn my brain off. I replay these messages over and over in my head. Sick knowing I was right there ave this was happening right under my nose. We don’t fight ( his phone usage is it actually) and get along great otherwise. So I’m totally dumbfounded that , what I thought was a perfectly fine marriage all around … and he still did this.

    His reasoning was that he was in a dark place. Wasn’t working at the time ( just odd & end type work to help out with bills) and he felt that he wasn’t good enough for me. Is this a bunch of bs he’s feeding me? I dunno. I asked a zillion questions , we talked … and the crazy thing , we’re in such a great place in our marriage atm , and now I feel like this. I can’t sleep well . I just want to cry all the time. I’m constantly suspicious . Maybe time will heal ? I did make an appointment with a therapist before all this came to light …bc I was having a difficult time w his phone usage ( amongst other things in life) . Now I can add this to the list ! Finding this forum is helpful , knowing what I’m feeling , how I’m reacting isn’t me just ” being crazy” .

Log in to reply.