Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Rant-Rave-Questions › Everything is terrible

  • Everything is terrible

    Posted by katniss on May 25, 2021 at 4:14 pm

    I’ll try to keep this as short as possible, while giving the most important details. A quick background about me – I’m a middle-aged mom on my 2nd marriage, one kid, no diagnosed mental health issues, but if I had to guess I’m on the anxiety/depression side of things. My husband and I are very different – I am always restless and have a constant need for adventure (nothing crazy or expensive, I just enjoy the outdoors and simple pleasures), while he is a homebody. I am a passionate person who has no problem expressing my feelings, while he is constantly telling me to “tone it down”. I have felt for many years now (we’ve been together almost 17 years) that I am having to dilute myself on a daily basis to make things work. 4 years ago, we moved to a new neighborhood and I met a man (also married) who I instantly felt a connection with. He was easy to talk to, and was kind and funny and outgoing. I spent the better part of the next year talking myself out of having any feelings for him, when we finally connected via social media one evening and confessed our mutual attraction for one another. We only met in person once or twice, while most of the affair was via a secret app. I think the original intent was to just fill a void of something missing in our respective marriages (he was physically and emotionally lonely, although he never used those words or complained about his wife), and I was restless and also feeling emotionally rejected, while also realizing more and more how much I had in common with this man, and how little with my husband. A lot of trust was created and shared in this love affair. My lover broke it off once about 6 months into our affair because he felt overcome with guilt and stated he still loved his wife. We remained friends, and about a month later we picked it back up again. This went on for over a year, when his wife discovered a selfie on his phone that she realized had not been for her (they have not been physically intimate in a long time, and she is no longer insterested in sex). He broke it off with me that day (he is unemployed, we were in the middle of a pandemic, and they have an emotionally fragile child), because it was “the right thing to do”, and I didn’t hear from him in nearly 6 months. I went into a deep depression, lost about 20 lbs (I’m already a tiny person), and started therapy. About 6 months later, we ran into each other at an event, and he told me things were OK, that he had told his wife that it had been just a random photo to a random person he’d met online (his wife and I are acquainted), that he’d “taken full responsibility”. He said he was on a “tight leash” and under “constant scrutiny” (who wants to live that way?!). I was devastated all over again. But that night he reached out to me via the secret app (I never deleted it) and told me he was sorry he’d been gone for so long, that he knew he’d hurt me, and that he was still feeling empty and unfulfilled. For 3 weeks, our relationship picked back up again, and I felt human again for the first time since it ended. Then just like that, without warning, he was gone again. I see him regularly because our kids have events together, and I have tried talking to him, but he just keeps it casual. I am completely devastated. Even before we reconnected, I had already made plans to separate from my husband, who I think deserves better. I can only see a future with this man who I wholeheartedly believe is my “person”. I can’t go into every detail of the level of connection we had, but I know it’s a once-in-a-lifetime thing and goes way beyond anything I have ever experienced with anyone in my life. I can’t help but believe that he’s only staying with her out of fear (of losing his family), guilt (of being discovered), and pity (for her and for their kids), and that he continues to be sad and lonely, remaining in a loveless marriage. Most days, I feel like a robot – I only live for our child, and keep it together for them, but inside I feel either empty or incredibly depressed. I am exhausted from pretending to be OK every day. Therapy has not been very helpful, and I’m not sure I want to start taking medication to feel better. My heart breaks for my own husband as well as for his wife, but I feel like our respective relationships have run their course, that we’re each just staying out of duty to our kids and families, and that it will untimately lead to frustration and resentment. I am beyond heartbroken and have looked everywhere for a solution but can find none. I love Glennon Doyle and her subscription to “looking inside”, but ultimately I feel that this man is the love of my life and I will never get past it. I know he’s got issues he needs to figure out, as do I. I’m not so naive as to believe he’s “perfect” in any way (he drinks too much and enjoys the occasional recreational hallucinogenic with friends), but I can only see a future with him in it. Any (non-judgmental) insight is welcome.

    replied 5 years, 5 months ago 6 Members · 22 Replies
  • 22 Replies
  • eliza4one

    Member
    May 25, 2021 at 7:41 pm

    Divorce your husband and go from there.

  • lilly0792

    Member
    May 25, 2021 at 8:08 pm

    Katniss— you could use some individual therapy. Some individual self care and a NEW focus. I agree with Eliza that divorcing your husband could be step 1, but not if you think you’re going to end up with the married man. That will never happen. Ever. As painful as that is—the sooner you fully cut him out of your life – the sooner you will eventually feel better.

  • eliza4one

    Member
    May 25, 2021 at 8:40 pm

    I suggested divorce solely for her husband’s sake, not her own. What she is doing is not fair to her innocent husband who has no clue and is unwittingly being scarred for life.

    I wish my husband had divorced me rather than put me through the pain of his infidelity.

    Obviously, communication with one’s spouse would be the ideal first step, but for some reason, people who choose to have affairs lack the ability to clearly communicate with their spouses. So they cheat behind their spouse’s back. Why not just ask/file for a divorce instead?!

  • katniss

    Member
    May 25, 2021 at 9:06 pm

    First off, I came to this site because I was under the impression it would be inclusive and non-judgmental. About 99% of infidelity help groups are geared towards helping the cheated on, as if the people who cheat are undeserving of empathy and understanding. There’s plenty of other sites for that. Second, what makes you think I *haven’t* tried to communicate with my husband? I guess you missed that part, and just honed in on the “she chose to cheat”. I agonized over taking that leap, and I’m not at all proud of it. In a perfect world, when people come to the realization that they’re a poor match, they both have the wherewithal to speak up and say that maybe it’s for the best to split up. But that’s not reality. I have gone to therapy on my own because my husband refuses to. I tried to get him to come to therapy with me before I met this man. I tried to become a more muted version of myself because my expression of emotions made him uncomfortable. I am not blaming the affair on my husband – I take full responsibility for it. I found comfort in another man, and vice versa. I know it’s easier to think of the other woman as a selfish, soulless seductress, but that’s not how things are. I know my husband is a good man, but we’re no longer a good fit. I’m sure that’s what therapy would have revealed had we gone. I am sorry that you got hurt by your husband’s cheating, and since I don’t know the details, I won’t make any assumptions. You should extend the same courtesy to someone else who is hurting. It wasn’t me.

  • eliza4one

    Member
    May 25, 2021 at 9:15 pm

    Why haven’t you divorced your husband? We are here to learn from one another, as hard as it is to hear things you don’t want to hear. I am genuinely confused and curious and yes, aghast at why someone would choose to cheat over choosing to be upfront and honest and just ask for a divorce if things aren’t working out.

    I apologize for coming off as judgmental. Dealing with infidelity isn’t a walk in the park. We have our good days and our bad days. Today has been difficult.

  • katniss

    Member
    May 25, 2021 at 9:15 pm

    I’ve been in therapy now for nearly 9 months. It’s not doing any good so far. There’s something inside of me that says to hold on. I can’t imagine my life without this man. As I mentioned to Eliza, I have already decided to leave my husband. I am working on the right moment (if there can ever be such a thing). We are like roommates more than anything. And I would honestly rather be alone than in such an unfulfilling marriage. My lover is a good man, and is trying to do “the right thing”, but I don’t think that continuing to be dishonest with yourself and your spouse about your needs and your deeds is going to work out in the end. Neither one of us is a serial cheater. We just happened to meet at the right (or wrong, depending on perspective) time, and we recognized something in one another there. You don’t just stop having feelings for someone at the snap of a finger. It’s complicated, but not impossible.

  • eliza4one

    Member
    May 25, 2021 at 9:29 pm

    Ultimately, it boils down to doing the right thing.

    1) Be honest with your current husband.

    2) File for divorce.

    3) Stop seeing the married man until he is divorced. (If he truly is your person, he will divorce his wife and choose you).

  • katniss

    Member
    May 25, 2021 at 9:52 pm

    That is my plan. I’m not currently reaching out to my lover, because I *am* trying to do the right thing as much as it can be done at this point. I think that telling my husband the truth will serve nothing but to hurt him more and make him less trusting of future partners. I am slowly putting the wheels in motion for divorcing him – I thing he is beginning to see that this isn’t working for either of us. We even had a conversation about what it would look like about a month ago, but now he’s backing out of that. All I can do is be patient – with him and with my lover.

    I wish you peace. I found a lot of support in Glennon Doyle’s book Untamed, as well as her podcast. I guess I came here looking for a kindred spirit

  • eliza4one

    Member
    May 25, 2021 at 10:06 pm

    There are a few posters on here who are “on the other side of the fence” with regards to infidelity. They have earned great respect from me with their willingness to open their hearts with those of us who have been deeply hurt by our spouse’s infidelity. They have opened up to us about their guilt. Their remorse. Their making amends. Their inner reflections about why they chose to do what they did. Their growth as human beings, moving forward from inflicting great pain upon their partners/spouses.

    Those are the posters who have earned our (my) respect because it is clear that they regret what they did and are now trying to do the right thing, both for their partners, and for themselves.

    I don’t think you’ll find a kindred spirit in those of us who are struggling to piece together our hearts and our lives after learning that the ones who vowed to love and cherish us above all others failed us miserably.

    I encourage you to read through some of the heartbreaking posts on this site. Gaining perspective from the other side of the fence certainly can’t hurt.

    I truly do hope you move forward with divorcing your husband. And I pray that the other man stops what he’s doing, as well, and does right by his wife, even if that means divorce.

    It truly pains me deeply to know other women have to go through/are going through what we on here are going through. (There are a few men on here, too, who are living this horrid reality). It is a pain you will never understand until you’ve experienced it.

    You said: He said he was on a “tight leash” and under “constant scrutiny” (who wants to live that way?!).

    An indication that you don’t quite grasp it…he wouldn’t be living that way if he weren’t doing what he’s doing. That’s one of the few “consequences” of cheating. You lose the trust of your spouse…

  • monin70206

    Member
    May 26, 2021 at 1:36 am

    I really try to come off not judgemental but I it might be hard because few things you have said have striked something deep inside me.

    One thing I strongly feel and believe is that the one who is getting cheated on must have a choice about what happens next. To do that, he must know what is going on.

    Reading your posts I can understand that you are trying to “keep him safe” and don’t really want to hurt him, but the hurt will be inevitable. Sooner or later he might find out (heck, your lover could tell his wife at some point and she might tell your husband..) and it would be so much worse.

    Just the fact of getting a divorce (without cheating) will probably mess with his head, I agree, but he does have a right for a choice. You have already chosen to get a divorce and leave but something is holding you back. Is it the fact that maybe your lover won’t leave and you will stay alone and you got divorced for nothing? Are you afraid that if you tell your husband about the affair, he might choose to just leave and you won’t have “backup plan” or a choice to try and fix things with your husband?

    Maybe everything I have said comes from deep hurt and confusion I am feeling because I suspect my husband is having an affair but he won’t admit to anything.

    So my question to you is – if you husband would come and say that hey, I feel you are cheating on me.. Would you fess up?

    Also maybe you should switch therapists? If 9 months of therapy is not working it might be either you are circling around the issues that you can’t do anything about or your therapists is just not a good fit..

  • tara81

    Member
    May 26, 2021 at 6:57 am

    It’s not that you don’t deserve sympathy but you are freely entering into an affair. You are choosing to have an affair. People that get cheated on, do not have a choice in the matter. You are selfish because you are only thinking of yourself. You don’t realize the damage you are going to be causing his wife. The wife that is not aware that her husband is a piece of shit. If his relationship is so bad he would have left. He probably tells you what you want to hear. You do deserve to be happy and it seems that your husband is not doing it for you. Leave him and find love with a single man. Side chicks are delusional and as much as you want to think that it’s true love, It is not. You are his second choice not true love. Hi misses the adrenaline of doing something forbidden that is why he keeps coming back.

  • lilly0792

    Member
    May 26, 2021 at 6:59 am

    I agree about the dig at his wife – Katniss- he’s living under scrutiny the same way my husband did after he cheated on me.

    Your lover already made his choice. His wife.

    I have empathy for you – but you clearly are delusional when it comes to this man.

    He IS having sex with his wife- of course he is. He IS assuring his wife that he loves her and NOT YOU. He IS not going to leave her. He is not staying with her because he feels obligated or for the kids. He’s staying with her bc she’s the person he wants to live with. Not you.

  • linds

    Member
    May 26, 2021 at 8:56 am

    End your relationship with your husband he does deserve better but do not pursue this other man unless he ends his own marriage. What you have been doing is wrong no matter how connected you are to him and the pain you will have caused his wife once she finds out is unmeasurable. An affair is never right. It is never ok. And it always causes pain especially when there are children involved.

  • katniss

    Member
    May 26, 2021 at 9:33 am

    I’m not sure how may more ways I can say this, but I came here to hear from other people who are experiencing what I’m going through. That said, since ya’ll insist on projecting your own stories and interjecting your own judgments, I’ll tell you what I’m concluding from your posts – 1. you are seemingly unable to truly *listen* to what someone has to say, and maybe *that* is why your SO sought to be heard elsewhere – you hear what you want to hear and skimming through my post with only one intent – to share your own story and your own pain; 2. You haven’t come out and said it outright, but I’ve read it in many other posts on here as well as elsewhere – the “other woman” is a “slut, whore, narcissist”, whatever you need to tell yourself that she may be, when in fact she could be your friend, your sister, your mom, your neighbor, your daughter… think on that for a second. We’re not succubuses sent from the bowels of hell. Are there serial cheaters who get a kick out of hurting people? Heck yeah! But most of us are just a human being with feelings and dreams and lives. AGAIN, I did NOT come here for advice from those who’ve been cheated on because that’s not realistic, much as *I* do not go onto the stories of those who’ve been cheated on and brow beat them with the trite old “you should have tried harder”, “maybe you were a boring nag”, “maybe you were a crappy communicator”, etc. because THAT’S NOT HELPFUL FOR YOU, and also it’s not helpful for me. 3. Every last one of you has made this about *you* – how your husbands “chose to do this to you”. I can’t speak for your husbands, but I can speak for myself – I didn’t have an affair with the specific intent to hurt my husband. I spent YEARS on trying to communicate my needs to him, almost losing myself in the process of trying to be what and who he wanted me to be to keep the peace. Did having an affair fix it? Of course not! I never said having an affair was a good idea. But I did find love and understanding and mutuality and connection with another human being who was in the same place I was.

    I think all of you could use some introspection. As I was saying, you are seemingly incapable of “reading your audience” and clearly don’t give a rat’s ass about what I’m asking for. Maybe this is a pattern for you? Yes, cheating is wrong. Affairs are hardly the answer. No one in their right mind would claim this. But just as the opposite of love isn’t hate (it’s actually indifference), trying to fix your marriage by threatening and badgering and giving your spouse ultimatums and creating chaos in every sort of way is also not the solution. Your husbands may initially show remorse and regret and say that they want to work on the marriage depending on how they feel about both you and their lovers, but it’s often just a kneejerk reaction to a sudden shift and they’re acting more out of fear of the unknown (i.e. do they choose to continue to live in an unhappy yet predictable marriage, or do they take a leap of faith with the “other”?). I’ve never found the idea of vengeance and destroying someone’s reputation to be satisfying in any way. So while *your* kneejerk reaction may be to make your husbands feel the same pain you’re feeling (they probably already do, having suddenly broken off with someone they may love), badmouth them to anyone who will listen (including the kids and the extended friends and family), it’s not what will heal your pain. And the idea that “people who cheat bring the pain on themselves” and thus deserve it is misguided at best, and the ultimate testimony that you’re not trying to save your marraige because you love your husband so much, but rather it’s a matter of pride, of being angry at having “failed” at something, of having been “made a fool of” (which is only in your own mind, and only the case if you choose to spread this very private news to anyone who will listen in order to garner sympathy for yourself and scorn for your husband).

    So please – if you haven’t gone through what I am going through, I am not here to be your punching bag. MOST online support groups are designed to support the cheated on person – go there.

  • lilly0792

    Member
    May 26, 2021 at 10:52 am

    Katniss- I feel sorry for you because you are madly in love with someone who is not in love with you. That’s it. Period. You should move on with your life and forget about this “lover” bc he’s never going to leave his wife. Not for you, anyway.

Page 1 of 2

Log in to reply.