Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Rant-Rave-Questions › Forgiveness – did he believe you?

  • Forgiveness – did he believe you?

    Posted by needtoheal on June 8, 2022 at 4:41 pm

    My husband had affairs with multiple women at the same time over an 8 year period. I have tried to save our marriage (Catholic and believe it’s a lifelong commitment). I have taken him back even though I have found out more lies about his version of the story over the last year. I did a lot of soul searching, praying, reading and finally was able to tell him that I forgive him. I did it on New Year’s Day. I thought I was marking a new beginning in our relationship. I’m trying to hard to help us build a new relationship.

    Today in therapy, we were talking about forgiveness and trust. I forgave but do not trust and those are two separate things. He told our therapist that he felt that my forgiveness was fabricated and not real since all of a sudden one day I said it. He has no idea how long it took me to get there. I would have walked out of therapy if we didn’t ride there together. I am heartbroken again one year later.

    I told him tonight that comment was very hurtful and that he didn’t need to respond to me. He always shuts down and that what we were working on in therapy today. Sorry, I just needed to vent so I can let this go and keep moving forward.

    replied 4 years, 5 months ago 4 Members · 4 Replies
  • 4 Replies
  • eliza4one

    Member
    June 8, 2022 at 9:16 pm

    Early on, I told my husband I was working on forgiveness. I actually thought it was something I could “work on” and succeed at/with. (I’m Catholic, too, btw, so forgiveness is vital to me).

    Well, I’m 2 years out and I am not there, yet. If/when I do get there, I am not planning on telling my husband. It is between God and myself.

    Someone on here mentioned that their therapist told them that, given their actions towards their spouse, they probably HAVE forgiven him…I sometimes wonder if that is where I am at.

    I treat him w/respect, love (not the same love I once had), kindness, empathy…but then triggers occur and thoughts stab my heart and I am a mess once again. So, no…I don’t think I’ve forgiven him.

    I have a couple of questions. You don’t have to answer if you don’t want to.

    *Who’s doing more/most of the work? You or him? It sounds like you are.

    *Who wants reconciliation more/most? Your or him? That matters…imo.

    *Do you *really* think you’ve forgiven him? Everything I’ve read says that forgiveness sets you free…gives you a sense of peace. Do you really feel that way? (I ask because I can’t imagine ever feeling that way).

    *Do your actions with regards to forgiveness match your statement that you forgave him?

    Because maybe he’s seeing actions that show otherwise?

    Regardless, what he said was uncalled for. He should be grateful you are trying so hard and that you told him you forgave him. It sounds like it doesn’t even mean anything to him…

    You know, even though we (you and I) are Catholic, adultery is grounds for divorce. So, while I’m with you on the “married for life” bit, I also realize that because my husband committed adultery on ME, I do not have to remain in the marriage. I firmly believe God is leading my path and he will guide me to where I’m supposed to end up. Whether married or divorced.

    Good luck. I do admire your tenacity with overcoming the “hand” you’ve been dealt. Your husband should be on his knees thanking you!

  • bob47

    Member
    June 8, 2022 at 10:08 pm

    As a spouse (myself) in a relationship VERY prone to misconstruing words I’d be very careful no about attributing too much to one statement. It’s so easy to say things in the heat of the moment (feeling cornered, criticized etc) that can lead all of us to lashing out to protect ourselves. It sounds like you forgave and meant it. (Trust is another matter and comes slower). But you did and seems like you meant it so maybe you just need a calmer moment to spotlight how big of a moment this is. It’s not the end but it’s a big step. This is a gift and one your partner should receive as such. It takes vulnerability and risk to give it. I’d suggest telling him these gifts to make sure he’s aware of what you’re risking here.

  • tara81

    Member
    June 9, 2022 at 8:49 am

    I think that sometimes betrayers think that when the betrayed spouse says “I forgive you” means that everything is back to normal and that the pain is gone. Which it is definitely not. Forgiveness is not important to me. I told my husband I forgave him but it doesn’t mean that I am ok with what he did, It doesn’t mean that I won’t have trigger, it doesn’t’ mean that I wont fall apart out of the blue. In my opinion what it means is, I am here and I am willing to work on things. It means that I will treat you with respect and kindness and I won’t use his lack of morals and his selfishness against him. It means I am open to his remorse and I am open to receiving his acts of redemption. I am open to acknowledging the changes he has made. I am open to one day trusting him. For me forgiving myself for staying with him and not noticing what was going on has been more important.

  • needtoheal

    Member
    June 9, 2022 at 2:02 pm

    Wow. Thanks to all of you. Such good insights and questions.

    He does the work at therapy but I have been doing a lot more. I have found other books, online sites (including this one) to help me understand all of this. He doesn’t do any more than the therapy homework. We took a few months off of therapy due to my work schedule. He did nothing. I kept listening to podcasts and trying to understand things.

    I do think I have forgiven him. It doesn’t stop the triggers and the pain. I knew I couldn’t live with myself if he died and I didn’t get to the point of forgiving him. I felt like I would regret that. I want a new life with him. He was once a good man, a good husband and father. I see that good in him and I am trying to help him see it too.

    I think we both want the reconciliation. He regrets what he did but is also afraid I will tell others what he did. I pray that he is staying out of love and not fear of others finding out his secret lifestyle.

    I truly appreciate all of you. It’s been a rough day and I know everyone here is going through the same crap. Thx for listening to my rant. Hoping tomorrow is better for all of us!

Log in to reply.