I am so sorry for your situation, and will offer my humble opinion and advice. Some of this may be hard for you, but you need to hear it from a neutral party, and I assure you, I mean no ill-will…
I am assuming your husband has cheated before, you say his ex broke you all up 4 years ago – So, if I am correct in my assumption: the whip and coffee cup should have been huge red flags for you…You just “let it go” because you thought he would never cheat on you? (Remember that love has a way of blinding us)
Then you saw the undeniable truth, the picture, and he wasn’t even careful enough to delete it, REALLY???? A leopard doesn’t change his spots………
I don’t know all the details about the past, but if he was involved with her 4 years ago, and it caused you all trouble, and he is still hung up on her, then sadly, your relationship may bee doomed.
Now believe me, I get it, you’re in love, and don’t want to lose him, I have been where you are, it hurts.
Remember this, he did all this without any thought to your feelings, and he lied straight to your face…… Based on his history, is this the kind of man you want to be with???
You deserve a loving partner who will stay true to you as much as the next person, we all do…..
On a side note, you need to get tested for STDs.
Now, I know it’s easy for me to write this, and it is you that must actually do it, but you need to confront him, and you need to do it soon, for your own sanity………
You will need to bury your feelings for him deep down, listen to common sense, and your gut, NOT YOUR HEART, in this case……He will undoubtedly try and use your feelings for him to get you to believe some other lie to explain the picture, but stand your ground……
He needs to come clean about his actions, period, if he cares anything at all about you.
I would say, if he does, you all could decide later if you all want to save the relationship, but I do not believe he WANTS to change, old habits and behavior are hard to change. Let’s face it, fact is, in most cases, once a cheater, always a cheater….
I am so very sorry for what you are going through, your wounds are fresh, being betrayed by the one you hold most dear is nothing short of devastating.
Please don’t bear this heavy burden alone, reach out to God in prayer, he is listening, and can help………Also, seek council with trusted family, friends, clergy, or all three………
Whatever you decide, I wish you the very best, and will say a prayer for you all.