• He loves but?

    Posted by jacqueline on March 19, 2022 at 10:51 pm

    Is not in love with me. Is affair is over I hope. He’s been good about doing what he should. DDAY was Sept, I asked to leave with no contact in Dec lasted 7 days. He says he says he loves but trying to be in love with me. What the hell is that? Why am I am MC with this man? Yes I love and in love with him. 18 years together. He’s my best friend. Why am I working so damm hard to save me marriage when I did nothing wrong? I have been crying for over an hr since he told me this. Is this hopeless? I hurt so bad for something I did not not do. Just need a sympathetic ear thanks

    replied 4 years, 8 months ago 4 Members · 5 Replies
  • 5 Replies
  • broken1515

    Member
    March 20, 2022 at 4:08 am

    My husband says he is struggling now with his own healing. He has put us backwards. He is concerned we will never be where we were before his affair and that we will never have an emotional connection. Lately he has been drinking and then getting very angry at me when I am not doing anything. He is so hyper focused on analyzing me I also don’t think I can go on. I guess I am waiting until our next MC appointment because that seems to be the only safe spot to talk. We were making good progress or so I thought but suddenly he doesn’t think so and that he is now not making progress. I am trying to be understanding but my god he is the one who chose to have a 3 year affair and now that he had to end it to be with me it’s like he is miserable.

  • nejjjen

    Member
    March 20, 2022 at 4:32 am

    The word love is thrown around a lot with people. What is it that makes it unique and different from want, lust, desire, etc..? Sacrifice? The giving of one’s self for the benefit of the one you love? I would say all of those love words mean that. Even though my wife cheated, I still would take a bullet – at this time. Do I love her or in love? I think we say love when we really want the other happy, so we get affection, intimacy and adoration in return, but longer term relationships should build a different level of love.

    Not “in love” is the signal that it is not the love mentioned above. I love my sister and my brother. I love close personal friends. Friendly conversation, hug or hand shake hello and good bye, but not intimacy. I only share that with one. I share with my best friend and love partner. This is why I am trying and why this hurst so badly.

    I’m sure you know what signal he is giving you. He is either saying that he doesn’t feel that “best friend and partnership” that you do and/or he doesn’t feel he can give you that exclusive intimacy you shared or at least you felt before. My wife didn’t use those words but a similar conveyance of the message for a 1/2 year. I was just too naive to know she was having an affair at the time.

    I am working with my wife to get this marriage to survive. She is doing what the experts say nearly always (so far), although I have no clue how I will feel for her in months or years no matter what she does. If she said to me what your husband said, it would stop our reconciliation. Just as it is a stopper to start a marriage, it is a stopper to reconcile.

    Please do what you must to improve and protect yourself. Work on you and he needs to carry a lot of the burden to fix the relationship and trust that he broke. I’m not an expert at this. It is my 3rd week and 1st time.

  • broken1515

    Member
    March 20, 2022 at 4:40 am

    Well said nejjjen!! We as the victim need our partner to step up and take our pain as a consequence of their actions. If they can’t then it will never work. The things your husband is saying is selfish. The only way to move forward and for them to truly understand at all the damage is with MC. It takes an outside person to explain in a way that protects both your feelings!

  • cristina

    Member
    March 20, 2022 at 1:15 pm

    You need to cry as much as possible, then cry again. Then wake up from your nightmare. You deserve more than this, it is not fair to be left in the dark about your future. You should not have to work so hard to make someone fall in love with you or notice you. When he decided to stray, he gave absolutely no thought to your feelings or what all the years you spent together really meant to you. He also didn’t care about catching an std or possibly getting someone pregnant 🤷🏻‍♀️ Please think about that and realize you are not worth being discarded. You have love and trust and honesty to share with someone, the world is full of people just like you. Cry a little more, and then stand up for yourself please.

  • cait

    Member
    March 21, 2022 at 10:54 am

    My husband has recently said the same thing to me….”I love you but I don’t always feel IN LOVE with you….” It was something I always kind of knew but it was heart-wrenching to hear it confirmed.

    And that is nothing to what he did during his affair. During his affair (which he was denying at the time) he gave no sign of love to me for 6 months. He didn’t even look me in the eyes most days. He didn’t say “I love you” back to me. He barely tolerated my hugs or touch. The only time he was kind to me was when he wanted sex…and after the sex BAM. Any scrap of affection was gone. When I asked him if he loved me and if he wanted to be with me, he said he didn’t know–which was his cowardly way of saying “no.”

    Now he says he loves me but doesn’t always feel “in love” with me because of these rough times after his affair. I am not the adoring wife that I once was. Whenever we talk about the affair and my pain over it, he says he feels less in love. The same goes when I need time away from him or when I am angry or sad at him….he doesn’t feel “in love.” Soooo…he only will feel “in love” when I am making him feel adored and like a king? How is that love?

    This man really broke my heart. I can’t go back to how I was before. I am not that person anymore…and besides he cheated on that adoring wife so what the hell? Also, it is unfair for him to blame his emotions on mine. He is the one who cheated, so he should be the one to flip the leaf. I try to be the one who starts the love feeling up again, but I am only human and it drains me. I can’t maintain it.

    You asked if it is hopeless. I don’t think it is hopeless, but it won’t be easy. I think love ebbs and flows and this is a low ebb. It comes with a great personal cost for me. It is hard to be in love with someone who just doesn’t love you as much. I understand and I am so sorry you are going through this. It didn’t have to be this way.

    I am trying to tough out these low ebbs for the sake of keeping our family together. We have young kids and we got a house. We worked hard to finally make it here. It took a decade of paying off our student loans to finally afford a house! We need each other to keep the same quality of life. He might be the breadwinner but I am the primary child-caregiver. If he were to replace me with daycare, he would be broke! (“It’s cheaper to keep her!” and all that…) We function as partners pretty well and we share a lot of critical values for our kids. The sacrifice of splitting up isn’t worth it to me at this juncture. And maybe the love will flow again or maybe I will be less needy for his love.

Log in to reply.