Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Members Stories › I asked him for a separation

  • I asked him for a separation

    Posted by cait on November 16, 2021 at 8:27 pm

    And he deleted it!

    I texted it to him while I was particularly down. My youngest got Lyme from our backyard and I got it last year. This place must be infested, and I am so paranoid about spraying and checking.

    So we both agree we shouldn’t stay here. But he told me he wanted to move closer to his family, which is far away from mine.

    I just decided… okay, let him go. I am tired of feeling this sad and dreading my own husband. I typed it all out to him while my youngest was having a car nap and he was shopping with my oldest. In hindsight, that was a weird way to do it, but I am terrible at emotional conversations because I just cry. But I did pour my heart out.

    I told him to read it when he got back and he pushed to know what was wrong because I was crying. I gave him a heads up (spelling it out in front of the kids—God help us when they can spell!). He said he wanted to stay together and said he would be okay with living the same distance from his mom— which is not what he said before.

    And I waited for him to read the texts with all the angst and heartbreak. When I checked his phone, they were deleted! And he also deleted them on my phone just in case my mom would see them.

    He said no, he doesn’t want a separation and deleted the evidence. I guess he relaxed his standing in where we can move but I don’t trust him to keep his word. He has changed his mind on big things before. I also wanted the separation for other reasons too; this move was just the catalyst. I don’t know if I have it in me to be with someone who really hurt me like this. I don’t trust him to still love me when I am this sad.

    I feel like I finally made a bold move and then it was like it never even happened! Just….deleted! I don’t know what to do now. Pretend it never happened? Should I be feeling more positive than I am? I don’t know.

    replied 4 years, 12 months ago 5 Members · 9 Replies
  • 9 Replies
  • hearbroken

    Member
    November 17, 2021 at 1:14 pm

    Cait, it sounds like he is freaked out at the idea of you leaving.

    You have to do what you need to to heal and figure things out. If you are unsure if you can get past this and love him again, a separation would give you the space to figure it out. That’s probably what he’s afraid of. That you may discover that you’re happier and more at peace without him. On the other hand, you could discover that you miss him and really want him in your life.

    A separation wasn’t an option for me. We own and run a business together and the AP is still in our lives. I was not going to separate and have him continue his affair while I figure things out. Or worry that he was continuing the affair. I have enough anxiety over the fact that she’s still around and we are together.

    Separation could have 2 results. It could grant freedom to do whatever they want, or it could ignite the fear of losing us and cause them to put more effort in.

    You need to do what is best for you to heal and move on with your life.

    Sending hugs.

  • eliza4one

    Member
    November 17, 2021 at 9:30 pm

    Curious as to what you ended up doing..,

    I don’t think it’s something you can ignore. Nor do I think you really would want to. There is a reason you’re feeling the way you are…it needs to be addressed. Maybe now it will be.

    I do think it’s good that you made that bold move. You are thinking of yourself, first, which is what you need to do.

    He was probably taken by surprise!! Perhaps he never expected it(?)

    I am curious how he would delete it from your phone. Did he have access to your phone? I’m not tech savvy…

    Maybe this will help open up communication with him! He needs to know that your pain is so bad that you are considering separation.

    Sorry I don’t have better advice!!

  • tara81

    Member
    November 18, 2021 at 12:45 pm

    I’m sorry Cait.

  • freshstart

    Member
    November 18, 2021 at 2:38 pm

    So sorry, I would be upset and feel like I am not being listened to. There is nothing wrong with wanting some time apart. It is a hard decision no matter what you decide to do.

  • cait

    Member
    November 19, 2021 at 10:42 am

    Yes, he has access to my phone, as I do to his. I don’t guard my phone in any way, never have, and I need him to be open with his phone as well. (That was a hallmark of his affair, phone guarding at all times.)

    I start another conversation about it and his response was something like, “Of course I deleted it. Am I supposed to keep texts from you saying you want to leave me as a treasured memory?” I told him I am really struggling and he said he can do better, but didn’t qualify exactly what that means.

    I am also in the process of discovering that my abusive father, with whom I have no contact, has Narcissistic Personality Disorder, which is really damaging for their children. I told my husband that it was hard for me to trust and open up to someone as I did with him. Choosing to trust was really a brave move for me. When he betrayed me, the fallout was horrible and it is still affecting me.

    He then said that we should have a date night every month and that he would help me get the kids ready more in the mornings to alleviate some stress. (I am not a morning person, sadly.) I guess that made me feel like we were more of a team, but I am not sure if it is enough.

  • tara81

    Member
    November 19, 2021 at 3:02 pm

    @cait it might not be enough in the moment but it’s a start. Have you been to therapy to deal with your childhood? If you haven’t, you might want to try to start there. When we discover the deep betrayal of our spouses, it brings everything to the surface. We are fighting to keep the family intact and to get to a place of forgiveness. We read, talk, listen, we devour everything that has to do with affair recovery, but sometimes we fail to take care of ourselves and the wounds that the affair reopened. It brings to the surface self esteem issues from the past, abandonment issues, fear and lots of fear of the unknown. I have been talking to a therapist and she asked me what I need from my husband to move on. To be honest I don’t think it’s about him anymore. It’s more about how he made me feel and that it’s something that he can’t change. From what I have read from your post it seems like you are still hurt that he fell out of love with you while like all of us you were in love with him. You may be feeling like he played with your emotions and how can you trust that he won’t play with them again. How can you trust that he loves you how you deserve to be loved. How can you love him again, if you can’t trust that he won’t fall out of love again? In my opinion I think you need to spell out the things that make you feel love. And meet in the middle with him on how you can still feel love by his actions without feeling like you are forcing him. Some man can be clueless. Spell it out to him. He probably thinks that it’s about the betrayal and the OW. I think it’s more about your feelings and like your mention the trust. The conversations that I now have with my husband are not about the affair but how I felt during the time he was having an affair and about the state of the relationship. I refuse to bring her up in my home. I might be telling you things that you already know or that have been posted before. If you want to work on your marriage I hope you are able to do it with an open mind and give him the opportunity to make things right. Tell him the ball is in his court and you will allow him to make things right. Hopefully he will get it.

  • eliza4one

    Member
    November 19, 2021 at 9:50 pm

    Yes, he has access to my phone, as I do to his. I don’t guard my phone in any way, never have, and I need him to be open with his phone as well. (That was a hallmark of his affair, phone guarding at all times.)

    I agree that’s how it should be. I’ve never had anything to hide either, and I don’t have a passcode on my phone. Despite everything…I still don’t have access to my husband’s phone. Could I ask to see it? I could, but then I’d feel guilty for asking and he would (stupidly) wonder “why” I even asked to see it…his thinking is so warped. I know I’m way off of your topic, but sometimes I just have to get things that are bothering me out of my system. It’s like all these things that the betrayers are SUPPOSED to do…my husband doesn’t/isn’t. He won’t even finish reading the damn book I asked him to download/buy!

    Back to YOUR post…

    I’m glad you opened up to him about your trust issues and how it was brave of you to trust him…that’s vulnerability, which is needed! Kudos to you!

    He then said that we should have a date night every month and that he would help me get the kids ready more in the mornings to alleviate some stress. (I am not a morning person, sadly.)

    This warms my heart. It might not be enough…but it’s a start.

    As you know, my husband isn’t doing nearly enough…but I am TRYING to take his baby steps and appreciate them. It’s so damn hard, though. I want so much more than he’s giving. (Again, I digress…I think I’m just really triggered tonight).

    Take your husband up on his offer(s)!!!

  • cait

    Member
    November 21, 2021 at 5:49 pm

    I can relate to the book thing. I bought my husband a book back in February or March. It is 81 (e-reader) pages long. He has not finished it. You can lead a horse to water…

    Your husband should definitely tell you his passcode for the phone. That is very basic. Ugh, I am so sorry that he keeps making his “cluelessness” (read: self-centeredness) YOUR problem. Maybe it didn’t come to the forefront because you moved into the condo? Still, that should be addressed, in my opinion.

    Thanks for your perspective about him trying. I will try to take up his offers about getting the kids ready, but he has made similar promises before and then conveniently forgotten about them. I asked him to either get the kids dressed or brush their teeth. We both despise brushing their teeth, so he chose the dressing option. We’ll see if it sticks.

    He has also said similar things about scheduling a date night in the past but then said he didn’t have time or we didn’t have the budget in the past. Should I be the one to organize the date nights or is that his purview?

  • cait

    Member
    November 21, 2021 at 5:58 pm

    Tara, you completely nailed it on the head about my unease/ distrust in loving him again after him falling out of love with me. That has hurt me profoundly. I am sure that the childhood issues didn’t help in overcoming that pain. My feelings of being unloved have always been harder to cope with than the cheating aspect. To be fair, it was over 6 months of relentless rejection….and then rejection *lite* when my babies were born. That would be a lot for most women to heal from, I think, even those without daddy issues. But those certainly don’t help.

    I appreciate your advice about spelling it out to him. I have been almost stupidly explicit with him in the past about what love feels like to me. Our therapist said to write 3 things down (he wrote like 23+ housekeeping things down….still PO’ed about that) that we would like the other to do.

    I wrote: 1) Say one nice thing to me a day 2) Be nice to me, even if I am running late 3) Cherish me.

    I will grant you that #3 could be ambiguous but the other two are pretty clear. He basically said….no. No, he couldn’t give me a compliment every day, even if it was as simple as saying dinner tastes good. It wasn’t him. And no, running late is a trigger for him. He can’t be nice about it.

    So… that left me feeling more unloved than before. He has really screwed the pooch on the recovery on several occasions. Who can’t say ONE nice thing a day? It’s pathetic.

Log in to reply.