Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Members Stories › I cheated in high school

  • I cheated in high school

    Posted by jalapenosunrise on December 2, 2020 at 10:44 pm

    Hello, first post on here.

    When I was 18 (I’m 24 now) I cheated on my first ever girlfriend. We had been dating for about two years at the time. I think I had fallen out of love with her, and I was really attracted to someone else. I met up with this person and made out with them multiple times before finally breaking up with my girlfriend. But when I did break up with her, I didn’t even admit that I had been cheating. I just said I wanted to break up. (She found out later though). Then I started dating the other person, although that relationship ended pretty quickly. I know that I should have just told my girlfriend the truth about how I was feeling, but I was too cowardly and immature. I’m so ashamed of everything I did, but especially that I never even owned up to it. I fully understand that what I did was wrong, there’s no excuse for it, and that it caused my girlfriend a lot of pain. It’s the worst thing I’ve ever done.

    Well, that was 6 years ago and now I’m engaged to someone else. We’ve been together for over a year, and I just told them tonight that I cheated on my past girlfriend. I feel bad for not telling my fiancé sooner, because I really think they deserved to know before getting engaged to me. (To be clear, I’ve never cheated on anyone since.) My fiancé was concerned and sad but overall very understanding. We’re going to talk about it more tomorrow.

    When I look back on what I did, I almost can’t believe it. It was such an awful thing to do. I had no respect for my girlfriend or our relationship. I was purely acting selfishly and not thinking about the consequences of my actions. I feel like I was in a daze, just acting and not thinking, and not caring about anyone else. I really look down on myself because of it. I can imagine how it must have felt for my girlfriend and how it must have affected her mental health and her ability to trust. It was so unfair to her.


    Since I cheated then, I have been cheated on in another relationship, and I remember how intensely painful it felt. I truly feel that I would never do that to someone else again. I fully understand why it was wrong and the severity of the pain that cheating causes. I reassured my fiancé of this and they said they trust me not to cheat on them. But should they?


    I’ve been reading in this forum a little bit and it pains me to read things like “cheaters never change” because I feel like I HAVE changed since I was 18. But am I actually just a terrible person who’s destined to do it again? Should I just force myself to be single forever because I can’t be trusted? If there’s no redemption for cheaters, then what do I do? What I did was completely awful- it was the worst kind of cheating because it was emotional and physical, it happened more than once, and I didn’t own up to it. But I still feel like I’m not a completely terrible person and I won’t do it again.


    So I guess my question is, what do I do to atone for what I’ve done? How can I ensure that I won’t do it again? How can I reassure my fiancé that they can trust me? I’m just so scared that even though I feel like I’m a much better person now than I was then, and even though I feel so strongly about never cheating again, that since I’m “a cheater” it means that deep down I’m a bad person and I don’t deserve love.


    replied 5 years, 10 months ago 2 Members · 2 Replies
  • 2 Replies
  • lilly0792

    Member
    December 3, 2020 at 9:48 am

    In nutshell – you’re talking about a girlfriend when you were in High School- it’s not the same thing as cheating on a spouse – there is a reason marriage is important. You don’t take vows when you’re dating. Almost every teen I’ve ever known has cheated on their girlfriends or boyfriends. They’re kids. That’s what they do.

    I stole a candy bar in 8th grade – that doesn’t make me a shoplifter.

  • cait

    Member
    January 5, 2021 at 1:24 pm

    You’ll be fine. Did you know your prefrontal cortex in your brain (the part that tells you long-term impacts of your decisions) is not even fully developed before you are 24?

    Cut yourself a little slack, here. It seems that you have learned your lesson and are aware of the pain that cheating causes. You will be more on the alert for it in the future.

    Good luck! I wish you every happiness!

Log in to reply.