Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Members Stories › I feel she is still lying

  • I feel she is still lying

    Posted by zeke on January 4, 2021 at 2:01 am

    I feel stupid for typing this. I know about my wife’s affair, she has been extremely open about giving me details about how where what and why.

    She only met this guy twice outside of work (I literally know this because of timeline on google maps, call me a stalker but i would have never learned of thia affair had it not been for me checking there.) Once at a walking park where they very clearly walked around and according to her that is where they really first got to talk outside of work and “connect”

    The 2nd time was at a parking lot. She said they just sat in the car and talked. But she later after much reluctance revealed they kissed, but he tried going for more and she stopped it. I WANT to beleive this story.

    But sometimes I dont…

    Going back to that week…in the middle of that week her period ended. She is usually SUPER horny right after it ends. We were both talking about how excited we were for the weekend and alone time.

    When she came home from that park trip she wasnt wearing her jacket (unusual for her in this cold weather), she drenched herself in body spray (admittedly to hide any smell) and when I went to remove groceries from the car it had a foreign odor to it. His smell? The smell of sex? The passenger seat was also layed back in a partially lounged position. AND most importantly, she wasn’t ravenously horny that night like she normally would be. Almost like she already got taken care of. Admittedly, she may just not have been on the mood because the guilt of that night was weighing on her mind. But you can see how my mind might generate certain assumptions.

    Again, my wife is very open about talking of the affair. Our conversations, when it comes up, are very casual and comfortable mostly. Any time I’ve mentioned the notion of sex her demeanor changes. At first I was asking her directly and she was very defensive. She eventually admitted to kissing him but that took ALOT of effort. Now I talk to her about it in a way where I’m like “I know you only kissed him, but listen to this other similar story that went further.” Her face changes. Her mood alters. I feel like she is still hiding something from me. She is also normally open about me sharing others stories and engages me but when it comes to stories about one off sexual encounters her demeanor changes. I could understand her getting defensive and acting odd if I kept directly asking her if she had sex with him after repeatedly saying she didn’t, but I don’t understand the mood change when I’m just talking about similar situations unless something more is going on. I KNOW her. The mood change thing is how I knew she was lying about the affair in the first place when I first confronted her. And obviously…she has already lied about this situation, so why not lie a little more? Especially if its about the worst part of the affair (even though the worst part to me is that, she proceeded with the affair because she thought we were on such shaky ground that our marriage was going to end…so she effectively did this cuz she gave up on our marriage for a short bit… which destroys me)

    I feel like im sort of crazy for all of this. Like…even if she did have sex with him one time, it honestly doesn’t matter in the long run. We are still getting STD tets because of the kiss (Im aware this is overboard but Im taking no chances). I’m going to work to stay with her whether she kissed him or had sex with him. But I just don’t entirely trust her story.

    I understand if she did and shes not telling me its partially to protect me from the mental images (which quite frankly, I’ve already had) or out of fear that despite me saying I’m going to work on our marriage regardless, she might think revealaing they had intercourse would push me over the edge. There is also a possibility she did in fact just kiss him and thats the gods honest truth and I’m just fabricating a worse scenario in my mind with the evidence I have. I’m not sure if I should press further or just let sleeping dogs lie…

    I feel like im crazy..

    There is even a small part of me that wants to contact HIM pressing him for more info somehow. I know this is an extremely bad idea, but I’d be lying if I said the thought hasent occured to me.

    I have contacted him once via text to let him know I know about the affair because she confessed to me and telling him to move on and keep things professional between she and him going forward (my mesaage was actually very calm, direct, but calm, despite me not feeling he deserves that from me). As far as I know he has been completely avoiding her at work and using other people as a means to relay work related info to her when necessary. Fine by me.

    But to try to get more info, I almost feel like texting him saying “So do you have any remorse for what you’ve done or are you just pissed off because you got shut down before getting a piece of ass?” just to see how he reacts.

    I know anything he replies with would be questionable. He might not reply at all. He might reply but say nothing useful. He might lie to me to get a rise out of me.

    Mind you, his only text to me was “Make this your last text” He is also married and is probably still hiding his side from his wife. Probably doesn’t want a revealing text to pop up at an inopportune time (this is how I first gained any hint and started growing suspicious of my wifes affair with him, a random text from him while we were going over our Amazon shopping list on her phone).

    For all we know my wife isn’t even the first woman hes done this with. Looking back on it my wife does say that she feels like she was naive and that she would have just been another notch on his belt. Would have. Not is.

    I don’t know… I’m making myself nuts with this. And any of you that are dealing with definitive sexual affairs probably think I’m stupid for making a big deal out of the POSSIBILITY of ONE encounter. But it’s still eating at me…

    Should I just be up front with her and say I want to believe the story exactly as she told it but there is just always going to be a part of me that beleives more happened and there is no way for her to convince me otherwise? If she can’t convince me otherwise whats the point of bringing this up? I almost feel like I’d be happier if she lied to me and told me they did have sex just to confirm my notions and make me drop the subject. And that in itself is messed up. But the whole situation is messed up…

    replied 5 years, 9 months ago 5 Members · 14 Replies
  • 14 Replies
  • zeke

    Member
    January 4, 2021 at 5:31 am

    I messaged him again. I couldn’t help it.

    “I really had no intention of messaging you again even before you told me not to but I cannot help it. Curious, do you feel any remorse for what you’ve done or are you just pissed off because you got so close to getting a piece of ass and got cut off before achieving your goal? I’m just trying to figure out if you were a friend who is trying to help a friend and it went too far or if you are just an opportunist who saw an opening and was trying to fuck my wife. I’m not even really expecting you to reply to this, you might not even see it, I figure you probably blocked my number at this point for fear that a stray text at the wrong time might be seen by your wife and then you’ll be in the same situation my wife is in. Or maybe you actually had the balls to confess it to her and work through whatever problems you have on your end. Who knows.

    This will in fact be my last time contacting you unless you give me a reason to. I don’t want to have to talk to you again. Have a nice life.”

  • cait

    Member
    January 5, 2021 at 2:35 pm

    Zeke, I really relate to you because my husband did the same thing to me…deny, deny, deny. He swore on his mother’s life that he did not have an affair 4 years ago. I could see that he was never going to come clean, so I let it go. But I wish I hadn’t. I wish I had the courage to face up to it then. But I was so heartbroken and just wanted the pain to stop. I just wanted him to love me again.

    4 years, 2 kids, 1 mortgage later and I am still as miserable about it as I ever was. Ignoring the pain doesn’t help, believe me. It just prolongs the healing process.

    Back then I found a screenshot of a woman’s face from Skype with a bunch of flirting texts back and forth. He gave me some bullshit story about it being some online woman he never met named Jessica from Idaho who is married and is really into geocaching. I knew it was a lie. My spidey senses went off, just like yours are.

    Flash forward 4 years later, he asks me why I am so depressed and unhappy. He was taken aback because I accused him of cheating on me and brought up that screenshot again. I demanded to know who that woman was and he knew he was caught because he couldn’t remember the story he gave me 4 years earlier. So he finally confessed it was his coworker. But he swears nothing sexual ever happened. It smelled like another lie.

    I then demand her name and find her on Facebook. I write a letter to her, left unsent, telling her how badly it hurts to be the broken-hearted wife and asking if there was anything else to their relationship.

    The next day he *remembers* that there were sexual pictures.

    Then he *remembers* he sent her sexual stories. But no videos.

    But then he *remembers* that they did sexual things while Skyping…

    And the hits just kept on coming.

    Why am I telling you this?

    Because “trickle truth” is very real, very common, and very hurtful. I would bet my bottom dollar something besides kissing happened in that car.

    Cheaters naturally try to get away with as much as they can. They are trying to save face and protect themselves and maybe even you, too. But it doesn’t protect you. It just prolongs the painful discovery process and slows down recovery. In the initial stages of an affair honesty is the substitute for trust.

    I would tell her that so she knows that you NEED the truth, even if it is awful. If she still won’t come clean, you have another weapon to your hand.

    You can contact the affair partner or you can contact his wife.

    If I were her, I would want to know. Who knows what dread diseases he is bringing back home to her.

    I hope you find out the truth!

  • zeke

    Member
    January 5, 2021 at 5:11 pm

    Thank you so much for your perspective Cait. I hope things are going better for you now…or as good as they can be based on the situation…

    I have debated about contacting his wife. Part of me wants to because I feel she deserves to know, part of me doesn’t want to because I’d rather he suffered for how ever long he might worry about her finding out.

    He never replied to my text. I don’t even know if he saw it but it made me feel a bit better.

    After talking to my wife more I believe the just a kiss story more…

    I know her and she isn’t the type to give it up easy especially when she is uncomfortable. She is also the type who likes to wash up immediately after and she didn’t go running into the bathroom when she got home. I don’t even know if I could get her to have sex in a car with me and I’m her husband of many years. Though desperation leads to desperate actions. Her story checks out mostly…its just the unknown what if that sometimes nags.

  • cait

    Member
    January 5, 2021 at 5:22 pm

    It might not have been full-on sex, if that is not in keeping with your wife’s predilections. But there are other cheats besides sex that she might not have had to do that much cleaning up afterwards.

    Just follow your gut. It won’t steer you wrong.

  • zeke

    Member
    January 6, 2021 at 1:52 am

    I talked to my wife about your story last night and once I got to the part about trickle truth and repeatedly lying and hiding as much info as possible she started getting uneasy. I pointed out how peculiar that was and she claimed it was because she was upset thinking about how much she lied to me thru all this prior to telling the full truth. She says its because thinking of the affair itself just upsets her because she knows she made such an awful mistake and wishes more than anything she could just turn back time and do things differently to ensure it never happened. She seems genuinely remorseful.

    As I said originally…I want to believe her but I can’t fully. I don’t know if I ever will. I don’t know if its possible for her to satisfy this notion either. If there isn’t more then she has no more to tell but no way to prove it. If there is more and she told me now it would just further reinforce my feeling that she is hiding more.

    All the times she has been more truthful with me about the situation its because I had her backed in a corner and she couldn’t lie about it. I have no more information available to back her into a corner any further than I have.

    I feel like this is a no win situation and I just need to learn to accept what she has told me as the truth and move on if I want our lives to proceed forward but I don’t know if that’s possible…

    I WANT it to be possible. We’ve been together so long and have so many good memories and the prospect of a long loving life together if I can just get over this one thing. It seems so big now but in the long run its just a bump in the road.

    My own mother betrayed me when I was younger. I’m really not comfortable getting into the details of that but I can tell you that pain initially hurt worse than this affair. That happened a bit over a decade ago. I thought I would never forgive my mom and never talk to her the rest of my life. I eventually started talking to her and allowing her to be part of my life again within 5 years. Now 10+ years in she is a crucial part of my life and I wouldn’t want to be without her. I assume the same can happen with this affair?

    Maybe I’m just a forgiving person. Maybe I’m too naive or dependant. I have no idea…

  • zeke

    Member
    January 6, 2021 at 2:01 am

    The way I scared her into admitting she kissed him is by bringing up the possibility of STDs and the potential long term health ramifications of that.

    I intentionally went overboard explaining it to scare information out of her.

    I literally said “STDs aren’t just transferred through intercourse. If he had a cut on his finger and stuck it inside you, if you gave him a BJ and were accidentally and unknowingly a little too rough with it, if he even kissed you and had a cut in his mouth you didn’t know about it could have transferred something. We need to know if we are safe or not.”

    She kept saying no after each scenario I explained until I got to kiss. At that moment she drew back was very reluctant and defensive but did admit they kissed and that was it.

    Yes she could have given him a handy. I couldn’t find a way to squeeze that into this scare tactic. But with our health and potentially our childrens health at risk after that I don’t know if she could have lied still.

    We ARE still getting STD test cuz even if it was just truly a kiss, there is a small risk.

  • zeke

    Member
    January 6, 2021 at 3:20 am

    I’m being super paranoid but I cannot help that. They are coworkers so they have many texts back and forth related to work but she had texted him about other things and told me she deleted those texts.

    While she was in the shower this morning I decided to dig through her text history with him to see if she missed anything.

    According to her, this relationship had only been going on a few weeks. I did find a kissing emoji with no context she sent in earlier November which to me qualifies beyond the “a few weeks”

    I also found questionable things. Or rather it’s what I didn’t find. Partial conversations that lack context. Something like a text that was clearly part of some larger conversation but part of the conversation has been removed. Like maybe she said something to him and he replied with something that she didn’t want me to see so she deleted his reply or vice versa. Sometimes on non-work days or after work hours. Texts about her talking to him about stuff that she didn’t even talk to me about. She’s been on an antidepressant for two or three months and anytime I’ve talked to her about it she told me she feels great and she feels better than she’s ever felt in her life but there’s a text between She and him where she says that she doesn’t think it’s helping.

    I don’t know if any of this means anything or I’m just jumping at shadows but I can’t freaking help it…

    How could any of us not after going through this? The person you loved and trusted most in the world has betrayed you in a way that is inconceivable. Now I’m supposed to believe that this person who was hiding this secret from me is suddenly being truthful with me. Me believing that she is being suddenly honest is more inconceivable than her having the affair.

    I’m going to confront her about this tonight. Its going to be like the initial sitdown where I gave her a chance to confess and she didn’t. I want to see if she finally truly opens up to me or if I have to force her to again by showing her the evidence.

    I hope she owns up… or that I’m just paranoid…I don’t even know if it will change anything or if this will just continue the cycle…god I hate this…

    A month ago I didn’t have to think about stuff like this at all and now it’s just my constant reality…

  • zeke

    Member
    January 6, 2021 at 5:09 am

    I’m actually going to wait until this weekend to confront her about it and try to let us have a good week so she can’t use the excuse that she’s overwhelmed by my talking about this too much

  • faithfulmatt

    Member
    January 6, 2021 at 10:57 am

    My story is much different than yours, but what made me feel better is realizing that I can divorce. It would be a heck of a financial hit for me (I’ve got kids) but I can. I did a worksheet on our assets and loans, and did some online calculators to estimate payments to her for child support and maintenance, and it will hurt, but I’ll be OK.

    I’ve been married 21 years, and if my wife cheated before kids I would have divorced, no doubt about it.

    My unfaithful wife sat in silence when I told her that I had committed to forgiving her too soon, that I’m walking back that commitment, and divorce is still an option for me. I felt a little more power balance being restored, I don’t have to do this, I’m going to be OK.

    I don’t know your situation, but for me it helped to have divorce being an option on the table. Maybe that will clear up her memory?

  • akasma

    Member
    January 6, 2021 at 11:30 am

    Hello. My story is kinda similar but my husband is hiding so good (a good liar) that i don’t have a proof. Sometimes he’s telling me things such as that he is in a hotel room with another woman that traveled from Russia to be with him. She knows he’s married but…yeah…what can we do? Right now he’s not living with me. He left from home 1 week ago. The woman is still in the city. I keep asking him to call me from his room but he’s ignoring me. And even so he’s saying she’s not with him. He took a hotel room far away from his work area but close to hers. He told me where she is working. If it would be for himself…he would book a 5 stars hotel, but for now he booked a 3 stars one. I saw the access card in his car and one old email that he forwarded to her with another hotel booking…3 stars one. I want to believe that i’m making up stories in my head but in the same time i have this feeling that he us lying…because he can do it. I’m seriously thinking if i should give up on this idea or just hold on it. My brain is in pain. 😅

  • zeke

    Member
    January 6, 2021 at 11:46 am

    It’s easy to make ourselves crazy over this, understandably.

    I talked to a close friend about this and they thought that I was acting a little crazy with my emotional roller coaster and I said to him “I’m acting crazy? I think I would be crazy if my emotions weren’t erratic right now”

  • cait

    Member
    January 6, 2021 at 12:05 pm

    You’re not crazy. You sound totally sane and are just dealing with a crazy situation. Ignore those friends; they just don’t get it.

  • zeke

    Member
    January 6, 2021 at 12:20 pm

    Oh believe me that’s what I told him. He’s just a younger friend that I’ve known for years online but what I said to him was “I’ve been with this woman longer than every relationship you’ve ever been in your life combined, I’m married to her, we have kids, we own a house together, and we were planning on spending the rest of our lives together…you cannot possibly begin to comprehend how I feel right now”

  • wtf2020

    Member
    February 16, 2021 at 6:15 pm

    Zeke,

    Some what similar situation with my wife. She slow dripped it on me.

    I suggest bluffing. Fake a STD and ask her. Tell her you have pulled some additional information from iCloud and you would like her to tell you the full story before you have to go to an attorney.

    In my experience, men that are cheated on probably never set clear boundaries in the relationship, any relationship. Such a simple overlooked thing.

    Your not going crazy. Fact of the matter is a piece of yourself is telling you what you already know but can’t accept yet until she’s honest. You can ask yourself all day what the difference between insecurity and intuition is.

Log in to reply.