Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Members Stories › I forgave him so quick. Is it wrong?

  • I forgave him so quick. Is it wrong?

    Posted by anicole1114 on April 26, 2015 at 9:09 pm

    Before I describe my situation you should know that I’m really young. I’m 18 years old and I’ve been desperately in love with the same guy for 4 years. Young love for sure, but absolutely not infatuation. I know I’m “too young” to settle and I have my whole life ahead of me. That isn’t what I want to hear. I want to hear what you would tell me if Iwere older. IF I weren’t just some 18 year old.

    We are finishing our first year of college, but we are separated by a big distance. He’s about 800 miles away. Oddly enough, he didn’t cheat while we’ve been in college and so far away from each other. He’s been faithful since we got to college regardless of the fact that we initially had broken up at the start of our first semester. He and I decided we couldn’t be happy not being together so that ended quickly. He cheated on me in high school. Twice.

    He told me himself which I was thankful for because that was the right thing to do. It was the thing a mature man would do.

    The first time he did it, he had been away living with his dad for the summer. HE was working an internship and girl there had taken interest in him. HE stayed clear until the very last day of the program when he was just in the mood for sex. He didn’t even like the girl, but he felt good about himself because she liked him and he  used it to his advantage. It was a shitty thing for him to do to me and to her. I can’t say I feel bad for her completely because she knew he had a girlfriend and she should have backed off too. That doesn’t make him any less wrong. I told him that I didn’t her and that this would not be good. I always told him that I trust him, but he is human and he is a guy and sex is tempting.

    The second time, his best friend was going to hookup with a girl and needed a ride, but he knew there would be a second girl and again, he was just in the mood so he went with his friend. I told him that same month that I knew his friend would get him into trouble. I warned him. His friend is a known cheater. I always worried that he would be corrupted by him. Obviously my boyfriend can make his own choices so the fault still lies with him, but you need to surround yourself with the right people too. His best friend also happens to be my best friend. I love him but he is trouble.

    Both incidents were only a couple of minutes of instant gratification. He didn’t even know the second ones name. As cliche as it is, they literally meant nothing to him.

    He told me about both incidents just last week after  I drove 12 hours to surprise him.  I thought he was breaking up with me, and he probably almost did from the guilt he was feeling about it. He cried and fought to get the words out. It looked like physical pain. I knew what was coming but I couldn’t feel mad at him. I was upset and hurt, but I couldn’t feel angry. I didn’t see him any differently. I heard all of the details and I felt no anger. I still saw the guy who made me so happy. The guy whose spirit and passion I love so much. And I told him that second that he didn’t deserve me. I told him how shitty he was for doing what he did. But my dad cheated on my mom, and I instantly thought of my dad. I hated my dad for doing what he did until  I realized that what he did didn’t change who he was. He was dumb and made poor decisions. But he loved my mother for who she was anyway. He was still the great guy  I grew up knowing and he took his punishment with no complaints. He accepted full responsibility and lived with the guilt for longer than he should have. So I looked at my boyfriend and I told him, after  I finished telling him that I deserved better and that he had done a shitty thing, that he was not a bad person. HE said he started pushing me away because he felt awful that  I thought he was perfect when he knew he wasn’t.  I told him that I never expected him to be perfect and that I had been warning him all along and that I had always prepared myself for this. I didn’t expect it from him, but I didn’t make him seem like a sinless being. I told him that it doesn’t change who he is.

    There was a noticeable lightness that followed that. The tension was gone and all either of us could feel was love. I still hurt. And I cried a lot after that, but I didn’t want to cry to anyone else but him. I know him and  I know he is better than that. So I am giving him a second chance. To prove that I mean something to him. To prove that he will put everything and more into this relationship because we are so good together.

    I started writing him long letters so that he knew what  I was feeling. One letter set something off in him. A good thing. He told me he wants to start over and be better for me. He is very cocky-confident. For him to say he wanted to be better for me meant everything. He said he didn’t just want to be in a relationship, he wanted to be engaged IN me. He wants to be truly present in this relationship and know and appreciate what he has.

    I know it seems naive to trust him again so easily, but we have been best friends since we were in elementary school. And I know him better than he knows himself.

    A lot of people have told me that I am crazy for staying. They think  I have just signed up for more hurt. But it’s a chance I’m willing to take. I rather be hurt again knowing that I have exhausted every possibility and option. Knowing that I trusted my gut. I rather that than the regretful lingering hurt of having to break up with him now because people think  I should. I never take risks in my life. There is no better place to take risks than in love.

    I know I have plenty of other options. I could find someone who would never cheat. But honestly, the chances of finding that person that also can be my best friend and know all my secrets and have been through all of my hardship and someone who will be 100% honest with me is astronomical. My boyfriend has now told me everything and feels comfortable coming to me for anything and feels comfortable knowing that I don’t see him as some flawless guy. We have a good relationship that most people don’t have. We tell each other when we are being stupid and awful. And  I know that I shouldn’t settle. And I know he doesn’t deserve me. But I deserve happiness and this is making me happy right now. When it stops making me happy then I won’t need him.

    I just want someone to tell me that it is okay to forgive him and try to work it out. I want to know that its okay to forgive him and still feel a little hurt once in a while. I want to know that for a dumb 18 year old kid, I’m making a mature decision that isn’t blinded by anger. Perhaps I’m a little blinded by love, but I can’t live with regrets and even if he does hurt me again,  I can never regret him.  I can only regret not giving this another chance. Right?

     

    replied 7 years, 9 months ago 3 Members · 3 Replies
  • 3 Replies
  • joem

    Member
    April 27, 2015 at 7:39 am

    I am very sorry for the situation you are in, and will offer my opinion and advice. Some of what I am going to say may sound harsh, but I believe you need to hear from a neutral party.

    Now, I can’t address you as if you are an older, more experienced person, because the fact is, you’re not.

    You say he didn’t cheat while 800 miles away, how can you be sure???

    You blame the friend for “corrupting” him, but he had already cheated on you before…so how much “corrupting” did he need?

    I think it is probable that he has cheated on you more than twice, and if he is having sex with girls that he doesn’t even know their name, I HIGHLY recommend you get tested for STDs right away.

    Now, it IS ok to forgive, and it is certainly ok to give a person a second chance, but if you choose this path, it will be a very difficult one, and it will take time, a lot of time, trust me, I have been there.

    I don’t think you have a future with this man, and I know that is not what you want to hear. But consider this – if you had a girlfriend, and this was her story, how would you advise her?

    You are wise beyond your 18 years, and YES, you certainly deserve better………

    Whatever you decide, I wish you all the best, and will say a prayer for you both.

  • notcrazy

    Member
    February 9, 2019 at 8:57 am

    just read your story and wondered how that worked out for you? i have a feeling i already know though.

  • sunnyr

    Member
    February 11, 2019 at 3:09 pm

    I think you want confirmation for your actions here but I don’t think you will get it here unless you draw some boundaries and he sticks with them. Literally, all of us have been through this.

Log in to reply.