Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Rant-Rave-Questions › I’m on the fence!

  • I’m on the fence!

    Posted by ashley979 on November 23, 2021 at 10:53 am

    It has been 6 months since D-Day. Although my husband has made tremendous growth in letting me know his whereabouts and trying to rebuild, I am not sure if I want to remain in the marriage. I’m caught between not wanting his transgressions to be apart of my story line and actually allowing him to show me that he’s truly remorseful. The source of my reluctance to move forward is that there is 350% chance a cheater will cheat again. On the flip side, I want to believe that we can have a blissful marriage if I just try. But that’s the dilemma!! I CAN’T get past my own hurt. I can’t see what COULD happen be in the future. In fact, I CAN’T fathom that this is my life and this is happening to me. Although it’s been six months and oddly enough, I’m still in disbelief. Like is this my life, am I really going through this, and how can I control this. Thus, I constantly tell myself to take things one minute, one hour, and one day at a time to remain sane. I’m constantly spazzing out and I no longer seem to have control over my emotions. AND I DON’T LIKE THAT!! I’ve told my husband that I’m unhappy and I no longer want to move forward but he always persuade me to stay. He will say that I’m not giving myself time to heal, hurt doesn’t last always, and continue trying. But hearing this from him doesn’t actually make it to my ears. It’s like listening to one of the adults on a Charlie Brown movie (all I hear is wonk wonk wonk). I don’t believe he has my best interest at heart so I CAN’T take any of his advice, even if it makes sense. But more importantly, he constantly reminds me that his 4-year sex only off and on affair (sorry, I forgot to add that part in guys) meant nothing. He takes a firm stance on that this woman filled a void only, that he wanted to end it a long time ago, but this woman threatened to tell me on numerous occasions. I spoke with his AP and she confirmed that it was sex only, she wanted more, but he wouldn’t oblige. But as you may suspect, I still believe it was more. I mean, come on, 4-years; I’m not buying it. And yes, I called her a woman because I have no ill will towards her. She only did what my husband allowed her to do. My husband took vows to me, not her. Yes, she plays a role in the affair but my frustration will always be directed towards him and never her. I just want this pain to end. I don’t think I will ever view my husband the same, I don’t think I will ever fully trust him, and I’m sick of caring around this guilt as if I did something wrong. I’m just sick of it all!!

    replied 4 years, 11 months ago 5 Members · 9 Replies
  • 9 Replies
  • brokenheart19

    Member
    November 23, 2021 at 11:35 am

    Hello, everything you’re feeling is exactly what I felt when going through all this and you’re absolutely right! They never change they just stop for a while and then as soon as they see you forgive them they do it again. The relationship will never be the same I stayed with the cheater gave him a chance and he did it again they just get better at hiding things. They never accept that they are the ones with the problem and always want to blame it on something we didn’t do, you did nothing wrong he would of cheat even if he had the perfect relationship. My advice to you if you’re lucky and if your feelings for him have changed and you can walk away from the relationship now do it. A lot of women like me stayed in the relationship because even though we are hurt our feelings for them don’t change. So if you feel like you don’t want to stay in this relationship run out of there a cheater IS always a cheater!

  • ashley979

    Member
    November 23, 2021 at 12:13 pm

    Thank you for your comment! I definitely plan on leaving without warning. I’m tired of riding on this emotional roller coaster. He sacrificed me for her so its only fair I let him have what he wanted.

  • freshstart

    Member
    November 23, 2021 at 12:16 pm

    I think it is tough because once you know they were able to cheat, you know they could potentially be in the “right” place and do it again. Without the WS doing a lot of work that they want to do on themselves this is a likelihood, hence the statistics of repeating.

    I do think there are a percentage of people who cheat who are not like others, who use it as a learning experience, who truly take strides to change, and who do the work to set boundaries and not put themselves in the situations that caused the situation to begin with. It takes real work, especially with the longer affairs.

    My husband had a 5yr on again/off again affair. I believe it was purely sex and alcohol had a play in it. I believe low self esteem contributed and it is absolutely his fault, but knowing that this chick hit on him from the start i have a lot of resentment on her and her actions given that she knew he was married. She also continued this through having a boyfriend AND getting married! People are more likely to cheat if they think they can get away with it, and they get a rush from it because it is wrong. I read an analogy about walking across a secure bride vs a rocky bridge… your relationship could be the stable bridge, but they get on the rocky bridge and it gives them a thrill, like riding a roller coaster or something. This makes it seem better than it really us, and really they aren’t into the person but rather the fantasy in their head.

    I feel pity in the AP just as I feel pity in my husband for what they have done. How sad is it they feel however they feel about THEMSELVES to allow this type of betrayal to those they committed to? I doubt either thinks this is who they are as a person (or now feel even lower of themselves for having done it)… so how sad they have to live the rest of their lives knowing they were capable of such a thing? I’d rather be on my end, honestly.

    I have invested 16 years into this marriage and have 3 children, so it is not easy for me to just walk away. He will always be in my life, and I would rather him be in a healthy state mentally. I am willing to stick around for a bit to see if he works on himself as my immediate reaction when I found out was wanting him to get help bc if he doesn’t and we split he would probably just do the same thing to someone else. I listened to an audio book which touched on how seeking pleasure occurs when we lose meaning in our life. I think when we get into a phase in our existence where we are in autopilot addictions for pleasure occur- food, alcohol, drugs, exercise, and unfortunately sex.

    Let us hope that there are spouses who use the affair as a wake up call in their life rather than feeling like they can get away with it again. Time will tell for each one, and unfortunately there is no crystal ball or easy button. We have to remember that always have the choice to leave. I may be here now, but 5 years from now I could have enough, and that isn’t necessarily from this. We have to be strong individuals with a desire to have a life together, not codependent. I am working on me and he is working on him.

  • ashley979

    Member
    November 23, 2021 at 1:22 pm

    Wow that was a mouthful and I respect you so much for your input. I hope that this act of infidelity is a wake up call for my husband as well. The dilemma again is I don’t know and I’m afraid; actually I’m terrified. So I rather run!!

    But I would like to know more about your story because our stories are a bit similar. My husbands’ AP is also married and she hit on my husband first. She’s actually a very aggressive woman. But my question is did your husband and his AP affair end after D-day? If yes, what did your husband do or say to you along the way to offer reassurance?

  • cait

    Member
    November 23, 2021 at 6:12 pm

    It doesn’t sound like you are on the fence, if you don’t mind my saying so. Maybe that is just your anger speaking, though.

    It won’t necessarily cost you to wait and see how you feel. I told my husband, I am giving him 2 years (1 year down) until I make my choice. If I don’t feel better by then, I hope I will know what to do. Ideally the marriage will be better; I want to survive this. I do think some cheaters can change, but I also expect a better marriage 2.0, a better husband 2.0. I am done with the laziness and the selfishness.

  • ashley979

    Member
    November 23, 2021 at 6:41 pm

    Have you noticed a change thus far (regarding the better marriage)?

  • cait

    Member
    November 23, 2021 at 6:46 pm

    Honestly, no. Not really. But I am better at sticking up for myself and taking a break when I need one. He has picked up the slack with the kids when I spend a night at my mom’s house. Maybe that is am improvement. But I still am missing something. He says he can’t love on me like he did when we were dating. I think that is what I am looking for but it probably won’t come. If he doesn’t change and I can’t learn to live on less love, then I guess I have to leave.

  • tara81

    Member
    November 23, 2021 at 6:55 pm

    Unfortunately, society tells us a cheater is always a cheater. We are told that we should never stay with a cheater. I was one of those people until it happened to me. Things are not always black and white. Like your husband, my husband had a long term affair on and off. It could have been 4-6 yrs long. I still have not been able to get an exact timeframe. But I’m counting up until I found out. He said she meant nothing and he had no feelings for her it was more like curiosity. We have only been with each other. He said that he kept going back because she made herself available and than was blackmailing him. The affair had been over for maybe 1-2 years before I found out: she wanted it to start again and when he refused she told me. By the way she was someone I knew. My husband has shown me remorse. I have full access to his phone, social media. He is very transparent and is doing the work to fix the marriage. I want to think that he has learned his lesson and has grown but unfortunately due to his affair I will never blindly trust him or any men. This site has taught me that cheating is widespread and no matter what you look like or who you are. Your partner might be cheating. You don’t have to make a decision now. You can leave at any time. Get your affairs in order first. If you still love him and you think that he is worth a second chance, give him a chance to make it ok. If you feel like you are done than go. Leaving is hard. Staying is hard. You have to do what’s best for you. Choose your happiness.

  • freshstart

    Member
    November 23, 2021 at 7:28 pm

    I found out about the affair from the AP’s husband (supposedly soon to be ex). He texted me out of the blue the end of September. From what I have gathered the affair was in the “off again” phase, in that my husband had not been with her “for awhile” (meaning earlier this year but I have no definitive answer of when).

    Because of the nature of on again off again, the real question is at what point should I feel it is off for real? I don’t know what this whore would say to get him to go back. And I don’t know what would cross his mind to reach out to her.

    Honestly it sounds like he would go see her at times to prove to himself he could say no, and maybe one time did over coffee, otherwise would go have lunch, or go have drinks and think he would be ok??? I don’t get it really. The more things I hear the more I am like do you hear what you are saying to me??? This chick is nuts— he would block her on FB and she would create alternate accounts to reach him. When I found out about that I updated his settings to block anyone who isn’t his friend from reaching out to him as he was never friends with them. I am probably going to block friend requests too. I have considered deleting his account altogether.

    He also had left her as a contact on his phone bc he didn’t think he could block a number that wasn’t a contact? Huh? He has cried to me about how he is so sorry for this, that he doesn’t know why he did it and he doesn’t know why he couldn’t stop. I get that I probably will always have some questions, but I really need him to come up with the narrative for this hot mess. I am 62 days in and while I have had some good cries earlier on I think I am mostly just dumbfounded by the whole thing. We definitely had communication issues during this time, and honestly I felt like he was too aggressive when he wanted to be affectionate to where I would reject him, but now I wonder if really I was picking up that something wasn’t right. It is really easy to convince yourself that you are over reacting. I am working on trusting my intuition. Right now I think he is trying and every day I evaluate. If something seems off I ask what is going on, and I don’t take crap until I get an answer. We have had a bunch of conversations that have been open and honest and it has helped. I have even told him things about myself that I have never told anyone to show him that I am here and he can tell me anything at this point. I’d rather he be real that put up a facade. I don’t want sugar coating.

Log in to reply.