Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Rant-Rave-Questions › Just the truth
-
Just the truth
Posted by jellyroll on September 3, 2021 at 3:13 pmHow many feel like their cheating spouse has been open and honest with the disclosure? Do you feel you are being stonewalled because the cheating spouse is afraid to disclose all the information? What are some methods youāve tried to get the whole story? This is the biggest obstacle right now for me. I feel she is withholding because she is afraid of making the situation worse. And by doing that m(stonewalling and denial), thatās what is making the situation worse. I canāt live with the constant denial and withholding. Itās driving me crazy. Iāve tried providing a safe environment for her to speak and even offered her a full pardon upon the confession but still standing steadfast in only telling me what she thinks I will believe. If I donāt get past this Iām afraid it will lead to just needing a divorce to set myself free. Any advice?
replied 5 years, 2 months ago 5 Members · 12 Replies -
12 Replies
-
Iām probably not going to be much help as my husband gaslighted me for 7 months. I begged, pleaded, and cried for him to just to tell me the truth. Weāve been going to therapy since the beginning and he still lied all through that(He went as far as to give me ultimatums if I didnāt stop looking into things). I honestly had to find out everything on my own. I went through deleted photos, downloaded Snapchat data, contacted the AP, and it was just awful what I had to do to find the truth.
Maybe with some time – she will come around to be open and honest. My husband says he was not truthful because he didnāt want to cause anymore hurt or damage. But in the end, it makes everything worse. Does she read? Maybe send her some articles to read about being open and honest to recover from the aftermath of an affair. I really think they believe they are saving us pain from not telling us. Which just isnāt the case.
Good luck to you!
-
Iām currently going through the same. My husband agreed to see a therapist. His infidelity was caused mostly by his low self esteem. It really has nothing to do with our marriage, so we are both seeing therapists separately. I went to my husbandās first therapist appointment with him, and the therapist actually asked me what I needed from my husband right now. I said I need the truth, thatās all Iāve been asking for. He then set that as one of the goals for my husband, for him to be honest, ābrutally honestā if need be. That was a couple of days ago, and I notice him being a bit more forthcoming with info. It is painful to hear, but it is even more painful when they withhold info š
-
When they withhold our minds go scattering. You start thinking of all the worst possibilities. Then you start convincing yourself of them. Itās pure torture. Iāve offered her every opportunity and even explained how the stonewalling/gas lighting is worse for us and our recovery but show is too prideful to just let it all out. She has disclosed the original affair but I know there is more. Iām a believer of when in doubt- trust your gut. I know for me as well as probably most of you, our gut instincts is what got us here in the first place with the discovery. With all the lies and deceit that took place and with her just giving me trickle truth, how is one to believe you are ever getting the whole truth. Can you imagine a life sentence of wondering and imagining and never knowing the truth? She will take this information to her grave because she is self serving and doesnāt want to paint herself in a negative light. Done ranting. Thanks
-
Exactly! My gut is the reason I found out about the affair. My husband has been on dating websites for the majority of our relationship. Iāll never forget the sinking gut feeling every time Iād catch him. He would always say it was just fantasy and to boost his self esteem, but he would never actually meet anyone in person. However, recently he reached out to an old friend, and they started talking, then meeting up, then they eventually slept together. I feel like a complete fool. He says itās all him and his self esteem issues. Although, he also said he had the feeling that I was unhappy with him, so he stepped outside the marriage. Unreal. Iām the most understanding person; he couldāve come to me, he knows that. Him disclosing more about what happened with the affair helps the racing thoughts, but it also gives me more to think about. My gut has been telling me to leave, but Iām dragging my feet. 17 years and 2 kids, itās a huge decision. Rant all you need, it helps all of us going through similar situations to know weāre not the only ones going through it. The lies, the deceit, the betrayal. It is torture!
-
Jellyroll, I deeply empathize. My husband lied to me for 4 years about his affair. I tried letting it go, understanding that he would go to the grave maintaining his image as the perfect husband and father. He cares more about looking good than doing right by me. But it just festered! It caused me grave depression over these years.
I honestly just got lucky one night. I was being eaten alive by the period of time where he fell out of love with me (his affair) and his insistence that he never cheated despite all his behavior saying otherwise. During the affair, I found a screenshot of the OW that he took while they were on Skype. I confronted him with it back then. He made up some lie about how it was some married woman in Idaho named Jessica and they were just friends from some geocaching website.
That night I finally got the truth, I looked him in the eye and asked him to tell me the name of the woman in the screenshot. He was busted because he couldn’t remember that lie he gave me years ago. And he knew I remembered EXACTLY what he said. He could have lied again and said he didn’t remember what I was talking about but I think I caught him totally off-guard and he wasn’t prepared. So he told me it was the name of his female co-worker that he couldn’t stop raving about back then. And slowly, over the next few months, the truth trickled out.
I don’t think I have the full extent of what went on. I don’t even think he remembers it all himself. He has a very foggy memory to say the least. But I have the broad strokes and I have confirmation that he cheated on me. This was essential for me to know so I could put a label to the distress I felt every day. I couldn’t begin to heal from something when I didn’t *know* what it was in the first place.
In your case, Jellyroll, I remember that it was 16 years ago when she had the affair. It is possible that she genuinely doesn’t remember. My husband doesn’t remember a lot of what went on 4 years ago. You also already have confirmation that she cheated; you can put a name to your pain. You can begin to heal.
That doesn’t mean you forgive her or want to be with her, though. If you don’t know the extent of what you are forgiving, how can you forgive it? When I say this, I just mean the broad strokes. I don’t think know every little detail is necessary or helpful. It wouldn’t even be possible for her to remember every detail from 16 years ago.
Do you think you have the broad strokes, in your gut? If you do, then I think it is time to move on from the disclosure stage if you can. If not, then I would maybe move out and force a separation to show her that this is your absolute dealbreaker. Something’s gotta give.
-
Cait, appreciate the feedback. Is it possible that she was cheating again and thatās what triggered me after 16 years? I donāt know. My gut tells me something is off and it could be as simple as her not divulging the details of the previous affair. I donāt want sexual details. She says she strayed because of lack of attention and it was presented by another man. Ok, I get that. Not up until my emotional setback in may, she hadnāt really tried to fix our marriage . We just went through the motions. So what did she do in the meantime? I have this image of her being with multiple men and she is only willing to confess to the one affair? If you have an itch you scratch it right? This is where Iām stuck in my recovery. Iāve told her many times, that I can deal with multiple affair but I canāt deal with the unknown. It eats me alive every f*cking day. Just deep down in my gut and instincts I know there is more. She will never confess because she is afraid of the fallout. How can I convince her to just come clean? This is absolutely killing me. Just want to know where i stood and where I stand today. The feeling of 2nd choice and getting all the leftovers really just unsettles me. Iām now afraid if I donāt get the closure I need it will spell the end of us. Any suggestions? Anybody? Does anyone feel the same? Her conscience doesnāt guide her like it would us. She can go through life and put guilt on the absolute backburner. HELP before I lose it all!!!!!!!!!!
-
jellyroll~ Wow! I can see you are really struggling right now. I’m sorry. š
What if you gave your wife an ultimatum? (You’d have to be willing to follow through, however).
What if you told her you were moving out/leaving her because you don’t believe her and you can’t live with her with that disbelief hanging over your head? Do you think she would come clean? Would she be willing to risk losing you?
Honestly, I don’t see another answer to your problem.
1) You either stay and accept that she will never come clean and be okay with it.
2) You leave/tell her you are leaving, with the above ultimatum.
3) You just leave. Cut your losses and move on.
I’m sure I’m being short-sighted, so am hoping others have more solutions for you.
You can’t force someone to be honest with you. That’s the problem here.
-
Agreed. As much as I want to work things out ; this is a big problem. Iāve tried explaining this to her. Not sure how to move past this. How do you accept your past and know this is your current reality and probably your future? Is this the new normal to expect going forward?
-
Ya, it’s a tough situation to be in. Honesty is vital and how do you prove/disprove whether you’ve been told the absolute truth?!?! You don’t.
Lie detector test anyone? (Ha-J/K. Sort of…). I guess that’s another option. Ask if she would be willing to take one…(no idea how much they cost…).
IF you don’t think you can get over this, then you have to ask how much more of your life you are willing to “give” to her/this situation. How much is your life worth…
I don’t know…just throwing out ideas…
-
I think you should trust your gut. Are you willing to leave, at least temporarily? I had a separation from my husband for a week and it was the best I had felt in a while. I am tired of thinking about him so much. It was a great break from the agonizing.
-
Thatās the thing that hinders everything. Iāve always been honest with her and canāt see myself leaving so the ultimatum wonāt work in my case I donāt believe. Because Iām not yet willing to walk away from the only woman Iāve ever loved. I was honestly hoping her guilt and shame would win out over her but itās not. She has too much pride not wanting to see herself in any more negative light than she already has. She wants to keep this image for the outside world to see.
But letās say I stay and am in it for the long haul, how do you āacceptā things now? How do you try and forget about it everyday?
We went fishing yesterday and had a great time. I enjoyed the moment for the most part. I just kept thinking, āthis is greatā, ā I CAN be happy. And then I began thinking back to when the affair took place and we had great times and memories back then. Family vacations & birthdays. How could she have been that unhappy. I work 2 jobs to support and provide for her and the kids. Not saying she is unappreciative, but saying I do my best to make her happy but now to know it wasnāt enough.
Lastly, her not admitting to āotherā betrayals, what is the end game for her?
Saving her image?
Trying to avoid further damage?
Wanting me to not think she was a whore?
Is she a narcissist?
All feedback welcome. Thanks guys
-
Does your wife have childhood trauma? Does she live life wearing “masks”, putting up a facade? Is the person she portrays to the outside world different from the person she feels like she is on the inside? Does she (deep down) feel unworthy? Does she bury her feelings and emotions? Those are exploratory questions…she might be suffering from CEN (childhood emotional neglect). Or any other number of psychological issues stemming from her upbringing/past.
How do you live with it (the affair(s))? Prayer? Retraining your brain…Look up HEAL: https://www.habitsforwellbeing.com/heal-the-four-steps-to-taking-in-the-good/
Distancing yourself from her emotionally (so as to protect yourself), but continuing to live with her in marriage?
I think each person has to find what works for them.
Log in to reply.