Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Rant-Rave-Questions › Keeping proof of the affair…

  • Keeping proof of the affair…

    Posted by phitkueen76 on June 29, 2021 at 12:24 pm

    So I am 15 months post “D-day”. I found out March 31, 2020…literally the day before April Fools day and I still feel like a fool most days for staying.

    Not sure who all at least got the courtesy of their partner feeling guilty for cheating and coming clean, but I wasn’t that lucky and only found out by finding disgusting videos of the OW masturbating for him as well as 2+ years of sexting, receipts of purchases for Air BnB stays, train tickets and even bought the pathetic, bitch groceries. And get this…he disguised her under some stupid fictional name that I guess he thought would fool me.

    Long story short we have been through it for the last year and by all accounts he “seems” to be remorseful and all and declares “I am the only woman for him” but and I quote “We had no serious marital issues he did it because she made herself available and he could”. WTF am I supposed to do with that! 🤬

    So all that said, I have saved all of the evidence under a folder called INSURANCE because I don’t know how much I can trust a person that would sacrifice what we had for what he did and if I’m honest I don’t know “if” I can get over it enough to stay married to him.

    Has anyone else held on to evidence just in case they needed it or from your experience am I hindering my own progress by holding on to it?

    Also I would love to hear from a cheater how is it, you can say there is NOTHING your partner needs to change and you love the life you share, but you cheated anyway? What is the logic in that and what is the betrayed supposed to do with that?

    replied 5 years, 4 months ago 7 Members · 10 Replies
  • 10 Replies
  • eliza4one

    Member
    June 29, 2021 at 12:47 pm

    I don’t personally think it hinders one’s recovery, but that is just me.

    I’ve kept what I could…but it isn’t much. The 5 page love letter he sent to her, the receipt for him mailing her something in the mail, a book of love poems (WTF?!?! Fake much? Poetry has never been his thing…he always thought it was lame…trying to impress her, no doubt!) he bought so he could read them to her over the phone, a hat he bought in Australia, the birthday card she gave him when he arrived in Australia. I think that’s about all I have…

    I found out about his affair by opening my Notes app on my phone. He had saved hundreds of text messages (whatsapp) to Notes, along with about 20 pictures (nothing sexual in nature, thank god). Sadly, he “blackmailed” me at a very vulnerable time in my life. He told me it wouldn’t do me any good to read them, it would only make things worse for me (ultimately for him…), and that if I read them and didn’t delete them, “We were done. There was no way he’d stay with me”. This was on day 2 of discovering the affair. Well, I (now) consider that blackmail, even though I did have free will. I wasn’t thinking straight, was in panic mode, etc., so I gave him my phone and allowed him to delete the data. To this day, I KICK MYSELF for allowing it. How stupid was I?!?!? It would have answered a lot of my questions…things he probably has never told me. And I am the type to have zillions of questions!! But, what’s done is done.

    All that to say, I’m with you on keeping them. It is an honest reflection of who our spouse’s are, period. That may sound harsh, but…

    And yes…I love your bolded paragraph. My husband just tells me, “I was lost and confused”. Ugh. Like that helps…

    Edited to add: I don’t think I’ll “need” any data in the future, per se. Except to e-mail/mail to the OW’s husband, but even then, not sure if I need it. In my state adultery does not play into divorce settlements.

    One of the stupidest/most cruel things my husband said to me the day after I found out was, “It’s not like adultery is illegal.” I think I had called him immoral or something like that. I looked it up and in 6 states, it is “illegal” and plays a role in divorce settlements. Just not in my state. You can damn well bet that I told him if I lived in South Dakota, I’d be suing HER ass and his ass alike. (She’s married to a multi-millionaire).

    Ya, still a bit bitter, lol. Working on it…

  • linds

    Member
    June 29, 2021 at 12:59 pm

    My husband says he loved our life. He says the only thing was he felt sexually frustrated. We were having sex just not enough for him I guess. Same as yours the whore made herself available and made him feel important and wanted and he said he did it because he never thought he’d get caught! lol Isn’t that great. He actually said he thought he could lie well enough to have me at home and her on the side and no one would find out. Problem was I suspected and asked him repeatedly. I guess the guilt did get to him and it ended but he only came clean when she confessed to her husband and he threatened to tell him. My husband doesn’t have mental health issues. He was just a lying cheater looser whose now doing his best to try and win back my love.

  • phitkueen76

    Member
    June 29, 2021 at 1:23 pm

    I have also looked into going after the OW legally as well, and though it’s not necessarily illegal perse; I have found that I could seek AND actually win for mental distress being I have proof she was well aware of me before she even proposed sex with no strings attached (again what a vile pos human)

    I also fantasize about sending everything to any and all future love interests of hers if she were to ever actually have anyone (not my proudest moment, but yes I do periodically look her up on social media to check 😑).

  • phitkueen76

    Member
    June 29, 2021 at 1:32 pm

    Mine is trying too, but I don’t take a lot of comfort in that. My thoughts are “you should have seen my value before and not have blown up my life”. Now it’s just annoying. Crazy thing is I love him so much I feel sorry for him, yet stupid for staying all at the same time.

    I’m a 20 yr veteran and was a single mom for 18 yrs of that time because I wasn’t willing to settle for just any guy. I waited until I was almost retired and was perfectly fine in my singleness but I thought he was different.

    Family and even bff who didn’t like ANY other man I dated loved him…so this has cut me to the core. Just so hard to make sense of it.

  • eliza4one

    Member
    June 29, 2021 at 1:42 pm

    linds~I guess I didn’t know this part of your story…that he actually thought he could have his cake and eat it, too, and no one (you) would be the wiser. That helps me understand why you are struggling with forgiving him.

    I guess my husband thought (and did) the same for 18 months before I found out…so really, what’s the difference?!? He did say the guilt was tremendous…but not enough to end the relationship I guess.

    I don’t believe people who cheat love their spouses as much as they love themselves. Or is it that they DON’T love themselves, and therefore seek out others who love them? Not sure…it’s all so complicated.

  • hearbroken

    Member
    June 29, 2021 at 3:35 pm

    I had Christmas card she wrote a little love note on that I found in the trunk of his car. It didn’t have any names on it. She called him babe. It was her handwriting (she has very nice penmanship – we had her write the specials board.) She signed it with her stupid smiley face that she puts everywhere. I carried it in my purse for maybe a week, but it made me sick so I shredded it. I donated anything that I knew was a gift from her. We are a no fault state, so it wouldn’t matter in a divorce. I need to get rid of the vegan cookbook she got me for Christmas. I’ll do that tomorrow.

  • defeatedmarine

    Member
    June 29, 2021 at 4:41 pm

    Phitkueen76,

    First off, I am sorry for the pain you carry. Personally I am keeping all records because my wife has a tendency to change what happened as time goes by and we may still divorce and there are aspects of what happened that are good evidence towards custody. That being said, I don’t think its healthy to constantly view the evidence while trying to heal. If it mainly sits there there is no issue, but if you find yourself opening it just because often I’d suggest either a few copies on password protected thumbdrives or saved to the cloud in Google Drive so it’s always there but not so easily accessable.

    I wish you luck on I your recovery.

  • cait

    Member
    July 1, 2021 at 8:26 pm

    That is fascinating! All states should allow lawsuits against the affair partners, in my opinion. It is shit for society.

    I looked this up immediately, btw. The state where my husband and I resided while he cheated does have adultery for at-fault divorces. The state we live in now does not. The OW lives in a state where you can sue the OW for” alienation of affection.” Not sure who gets jurisdiction in our case or even that I would bring such a suit against her. But I will have fun daydreaming about it.

    For those interested: https://www.brides.com/sue-for-alienation-of-affections-1102874

    States Recognizing Alienation of Affection

    If you live in Hawaii, Illinois, Mississippi, New Mexico, North Carolina, South Dakota, or Utah, you have legal recourse should someone intrude into your marriage by having an affair with your spouse.1

    FACEBOOKPINTERESTEMAILSHARERELATIONSHIPS MARRIED LIFE<b style=”font-family: inherit; font-size: inherit;”>Yes, You Can Sue Someone for Breaking up a Marriage<b style=”font-family: inherit; font-size: inherit;”>It’s called alienation of affection.

    by

    Cathy Meyer

    Updated 03/21/21

    IN THIS ARTICLE

    States Recognizing Alienation of AffectionProving Alienation of Affection

    Considerations Before Starting a Lawsuit

    No one wins in an adulterous relationship—least of all is the jilted spouse—but luckily, there is legal recourse for some situations: You can sue someone for breaking up a marriage. After all, the third-party is attempting to come between two people who have a legal contract: a marriage license. This is all you need for grounds for a lawsuit.

    In a few states, this would be an appropriate case for an alienation of affections suit. You may file a suit charging the other man or the other woman with intentionally interfering in your marital relationship. The adultery itself is not the crime; it is the actions of the other man or woman that determines whether a law has been broken.

    What is Alienation of Affection?

    Alienation of affection is the interference with the relationship between a husband and wife by a third party without an excuse. This is a civil tort claim, usually filed against third-party lovers, brought by a spouse who’s been alienated due to the actions of a third party.1

    States Recognizing Alienation of Affection

    If you live in Hawaii, Illinois, Mississippi, New Mexico, North Carolina, South Dakota, or Utah, you have legal recourse should someone intrude into your marriage by having an affair with your spouse.1

    

    The rest of the country has struck down its laws related to adultery. Today, laws give people more freedom in order to keep up with the times, especially with the advent of open and polyamorous relationships. It also avoids the most vindictive types of lawsuits, which can be difficult to prosecute and costs taxpayers a considerable amount of money.

    What You Need to Prove

    In order to open an alienation of affection lawsuit, you need to prove the following:2

    Your marriage was happy and that love existed between you and your spouse.The third party destroyed the love.The third party’s intentions were to destroy the marriage and the love between you and your spouse.

    This describes what I experienced to a tee!

  • cait

    Member
    July 1, 2021 at 8:36 pm

    Keep it all, honey.

    I found a screenshot of the OW during a Skype session in his downloads folder by accident. He told me it was some random girl he met in a chatroom who was married, yadda yadda, a pack of lies.

    I struggled for 4 years because he was acting completely shady and cold towards me during that time. Then, I demanded the truth one night and he confessed it was his ho-worker because he couldn’t remember the ridiculous story he told me back then. I sent that picture to my email but he must have hacked it and deleted it (he denies it). It is the only proof I had and it burns me up that it is gone. I have emails that are older than that one, so there is no reason why it should have disappeared.

    I can’t even say why I want it. It was a particularly unattractive picture of her. It was the only thing that I had that was a glimpse into their relationship/ conversations. I guess I just want the proof that it happened and I am not crazy because he swore for YEARS that nothing was going on. Even now that it is “out,” I feel the need for proof because he lied for so long. I feel lucky that he didn’t deny the screenshot altogether or say he couldn’t remember. His foggy memory is legendary when it comes to the affair.

  • tomisa

    Member
    July 8, 2021 at 10:07 pm

    You are absolutely correct to keep an insurance file. I have one too and you should also ensure that you secure the data in more than one place. There are a myriad of issues that may arise including defense of your reputation, potential property disputes, mental and physical health issues and the list goes on. Your insurance is more than evidence. It also leverage and bargaining power. Some people will concede a great deal to avoid being unmasked but you need your insurance to persuade them to a state of amicable resolution. In my experience cheaters don’t usually limit themselves to relationship infidelity. If he or she cheats sexually and/or emotionally then take a hard look at his or her life and you may well find that you are being cheated financially by your partner.

Log in to reply.