I think that life experience is a better indicator than the tests. Tests depend on the wording and the meaning they convey to you, which might be different from what they convey to me. I recently looked over the test in the back of “The Five Love Languages of Children”, because I am trying to get a better idea of what my two youngest kids’ LLs are, and I noticed that the test only compared neighboring LLs in a set order (A to B, B to C, C to D, D to E, E to A). I think a better test would be to compare all to each other.
I’ve taken the test in “The Five Love Languages” at least three times, and came out with my primary LL as Quality Time, but within the last year I realized that loving Physical Touch sensations are like an electric jolt to my brain causing good warm or euphoric feelings.
My family of origin was not particularly into touching very much. I can remember two specific instances that are keystone memories for me.
First: my younger brother was adopted. By the time he was about 2 or 3 years old, my mom had learned that many adopted kids need their adoptive parents to be sure to give them physical affection every day (hugs and cuddles, gentle pats on the head or back, etc.; this advice was probably from a 1980s parent guide, or one of her psychology classes around that time). And so, she instituted what I call (in my head) “the hug-a-day policy”, and all three of us kids got a guaranteed hug every day from Mom. I can remember her picking up and holding my baby brother a lot when he was an infant, but the first hug-a-day stands out strongly in my mind. I think this went for at least two years, until Mom started working. (When I was about 19 or 20, I finally learned why this was a big deal with my mom: she is highly touch-reactive, just ask my dad’s ribs when they were newlyweds, and again when they rekindled their romance …if she doesn’t expect a touch, she flinches unconsciously, even throwing elbows in her sleep at my dad’s ribs, when he thought she was awake and he’d try to cuddle. She had shared a queen bed with her 3 sisters as a kid, and she thinks that developed this reaction because the youngest tussled a lot.)
My dad was keen on little touches, like pats on the shoulder and tousling my hair, when I was little (and he’d pick up and hold my baby brother until he was about six or so). For the most part, he stopped touching me regularly when I got to Jr High. So, I one time stand apart, I was about 14 and riding in the front passenger seat while he was driving. Stopped at a stop sign waiting to turn, he patted me on the knee (not unusual for him) and then gave it a squeeze (the only time I can remember this). A jolt shot through me and delivered a sense of euphoria! I didn’t know then how to describe trust experience.
Other recent evidence, kids hugging me around my knees or around my neck fill me with warmth. My wife touching my chest as if I’ve got manly pecks (which I don’t) gives me the euphoric jolt I described above (she hasn’t done this very many times, and not at all since she started cheating on me; she withholds touch a lot now). A lot of guys mistakenly think that their LL is Physical Touch because they like sex, but the true test is feeling your “love tank” fill up from other kinds of touch. I get hugs from my youngest kids every day on the way out the door to work, when I get home from work, and when I tuck them in at night guaranteed. My wife encouraged them to do this before they could even stand (her holding a little baby towards me saying, “Give Daddy a hug! Give daddy a kiss!”)
I really like quality time, too. It’s like a cozy blanket. I just don’t have memories like those of quality time moments.