• Posted by linds on July 22, 2021 at 12:15 pm

    Does everyone who has stayed believe 100% that their spouse was IN love with them when they had the affair? My husband swears he has always been in love with me and that it was just sex but he has also said that he knew it would hurt me and my feelings didn’t matter because he wanted to sleep with her and that he thought he would get away with it so it wasn’t a big deal. I’m trying to explain to him the difference of loving someone and being IN love with someone. He thinks I should get over it because he can’t imagine his life without me now and is in love with me. But I’m having a really hard time being okay staying with him knowing (or at least believing) that he wasn’t in love with me for a part of our marriage. I don’t want to be anyones second choice and I really feel like I was. I feel like if he had to pick at that time that he would have picked her.

    replied 5 years, 3 months ago 9 Members · 25 Replies
  • 25 Replies
  • kypam

    Member
    July 22, 2021 at 12:34 pm

    I feel the exact same way. In fact, I try to explain to my husband that there were many times during the affair that he DID choose her over me. He denies it and thinks he always put me first and never wanted to hurt me. We he didn’t and he did. I still feel like I’m his second choice even though he says he ended it and never wants to see or think about her again.

  • linds

    Member
    July 22, 2021 at 12:40 pm

    He swears he never would have picked her but he did. I actually thought something was going on and asked him not to go on the business trip where they had sex. I begged him not to go and he did anyway without even a thought to me or my feelings.

  • legolady

    Member
    July 22, 2021 at 12:41 pm

    Linds

    I too am having a hard time with this. My husband has said so many times that he always loved me the whole time. But he has never said that he was always in love with me. He says his affair was never about feelings for her just about sex. He also says he knew it would hurt me but didn’t let that bother him because he didn’t think I would ever find out. He tells me that he had never had someone love him like I do and as in love with him as I was and he didn’t know what to do with it. I have a hard time with thinking that I was his second choice, I don’t feel like his second choice to her but his second choice to himself. I always put his feelings before my own and he never did that for me. He always chose himself and that hurts, a lot. He has been telling me since I found out about this that from the beginning if her and I were ever in a situation where her could only help 1 of us he would always choose me. I don’t know about that because when it came to choosing to hurt her feelings or mine he always chose to hurt my feelings. He always chose to defend her in any argument we had where she was the topic. I know this wasn’t very helpful and not much of an answer to your question I just wanted you to know you are not alone in feeling this way.

  • eliza4one

    Member
    July 22, 2021 at 1:14 pm

    I’ve given this a lot of thought, too…I also feel like I am the 2nd choice…if it had worked out with her, he would have left me for her (if she lived nearby, of course). Of that, I have no doubt. He figured out (finally) that she was too much like him, only worse…crazy, *itchy, self-centered…

    Whether they would have lasted if they got together, who knows. Given how much alike they are, I don’t think they would have lasted, but I digress.

    He freely admits that he was infatuated with her. He “thought” he loved her (that’s what he now tells me). He liked her “a lot”. He was under her spell. I know he loved her…

    When all energy, attention, and love is put towards the OW, there isn’t really any left for the spouse. Love is a choice. When you marry, you choose to love the one you married. Once the choice is made to turn away from that love, it goes elsewhere. That is what I believe happened. He met her. He still loved me. He turned his attention and focus and energy towards her. He felt the attraction. He slowly fell in love with her, and while doing so, turned away from me. No love was directed towards me (even though we still got along great, did things together, he was still kind towards me, etc.)

    He says he never stopped loving me, but I think he did. He had to have (see above paragraph). He explains his distancing himself from me as, “I didn’t want to lead you on”. In other words, he loved her, and therefore couldn’t show me love.

    I’m “ok” with the fact that he fell in love with her. I don’t believe there is only one person on this earth whom one can “fall in love with”. However, I go back to my 4th paragraph above…love is a choice. You have to remain committed to that choice even when/if another person comes along. A weak person is unable to do so. A strong person is.

    I am NOT OKAY with the fact that he slept with her multiple times while on the trip. It sickens and disgusts me. Ugh. I don’t think I’ll ever get over it. I HATE IT! 🙁

    I do believe he still loves me. I am working on reconciling the two. His love for her and his love for me.

    Linds~I think it would be very hard to come to terms with the fact that you asked him not to go, knowing something was up, and that he went anyway, knowing something was up…

    It’s similar to my husband and his Australia trip. I think I explained that I already had a trip planned during that time to see our grandchildren. He knew this. Yet he still went to Australia, even though I asked him not to. Sigh.

  • hearbroken

    Member
    July 22, 2021 at 1:15 pm

    Linds,

    My husband also claims that he always loved me and never loved her. It was also just sex and he didn’t think I’d get hurt because he didn’t intend for me to find out. He claims that everything he does is for me and he’d die for me. I’m having trouble figuring out how cheating on me was for me. In his twisted reasoning he got me more free time by keeping her happily working.

    So he pimped himself out so I wouldn’t have to work much?

    I don’t think I’m his 2nd choice, because he definitely chose to stay with me when I’ve made it abundantly clear that he can go be with her if he has feelings for her. When we were fighting the other night, I told him to go to her. He says that even if I left him, he wouldn’t want to be with her.

    I will never understand how he could do something so hurtful to someone he loves and risk losing me and destroying the family for “just sex and she’s good for the restaurant “. I believe that at the time this started he didn’t feel love towards me, regardless of what he says.

  • linds

    Member
    July 22, 2021 at 2:25 pm

    Ahg I feel all of what each of you has said. I don’t believe he was in love with me when he did it. I believe he had love for me as a partner, a friend maybe and the mother of his kids but I don’t believe for a second that he was in love with me. And how do I be okay with that?? And that he choose himself and the whore over me. I know I’m supposed to be looking to the future, trying to start fresh and build a new marriage but I don’t want to be a second choice. He says it was never about her. He didn’t care about her just about the thrill of the sex. But he honestly picked the one person who he knew I was insecure about their relationship and knew that I didn’t like her. He pick the one person who he knew would hurt me the most. I just feel like if he couldn’t love me or take my feelings into account then why should I believe that he is or will now. It’s totally unfair that these assholes fuck some whore and ruin our lives and we’re supposed to put it aside and forgive them.

  • eliza4one

    Member
    July 22, 2021 at 5:09 pm

    You said: I believe he had love for me as a partner, a friend maybe and the mother of his kids but I don’t believe for a second that he was in love with me.

    Yes. That. There are varying degrees and types of love and they essentially had a flip switch in their brains in order to do what they did. They HAD to block out the love they had for their spouse in order to carry through.

    Linds~Do you think your husband loved his AP? Or was it truly just sex? Just curious. I’m not sure which is worse…

    I told my husband today that love is a choice. You CHOOSE to continue to love the one you married because that is what marriage is all about. The vows you take and all…through ups and downs, through boredom and mundane. There were many a day when I didn’t fully love my husband, but never once did I start communicating with other man, nor even consider adultery.

    I told him he CHOSE to stop loving me/block out his love for him and instead turned that love towards her. We didn’t stand a chance once that happened. No spouse does.

    And like with your husband, mine is now “over it” and thinks that if I just love him, everything will be all right. Before he decided to screw another woman multiple times, my love for him was enough. Now, I’m not so sure.

  • linds

    Member
    July 22, 2021 at 6:40 pm

    He was not in love with her. I do know that. The entire relationship was sexual. She was a coworker and then a friend and he was attracted to her and she started flirting with him. I saw this and that’s why I didn’t like her. She flirts with all men. When I say she’s a whore it’s because she truly is. She has no female friends because she acts the way she does. But for me it’s not really a about him loving her it’s about him not loving me.

  • eliza4one

    Member
    July 22, 2021 at 8:03 pm

    Thanks for explaining. It is amazing how different we all are in what bothers us, what doesn’t. What we get hung up on, what we let go easily.

    I have accepted that he loved her and during that time frame, he didn’t love me like he should have/once did. That he turned the love he had for me towards her, which meant he had none left to give me. I’m okay with that because that is how it has to be..and I can actually see that happening when one gets too close to one of the opposite sex (it’s why you maintain boundaries when you are married, duh!!!).

    For me, it is that it turned sexual because he took the trip to Australia when he didn’t have to. Again, he chose to.

    My one hope is that we can all get past it. I don’t think one truly ever does. Even the book I am reading says you shouldn’t forget it happened. So, I have this to look forward to for the rest of my life. The question is, does everything else top that?!? I don’t know, yet.

  • tomisa

    Member
    July 22, 2021 at 8:17 pm

    My understanding of love or in love or committed to or true companion is fundamentally based on loyalty and a manifest desire to cause no harm with malice aforethought. I recognize that some people may speak in anger or behave for a short while in a way that causes hurt. I recognize it but know that I am not that person because I work at it. After he shattered my heart it started to amuse me to listen to him try to convince me that he wanted to reconcile. His most impassioned plea was “No one will ever love me unconditionally like you do”. That may be the only true statement he had made in several months but it was astonishing that he thought it capable of persuading me of his feelings for me. He basically said “I love the way you love me” and implicit in that is the worst truth I had to endure. He never loved me at all. His “love” was a shallow thing. Weak and self centered, demanding his own satisfaction with no conscience or consciousness. I do not believe that you can love and betray or love and do deliberate harm or love and belittle your life partner to a meaningless person.

  • linds

    Member
    July 23, 2021 at 9:04 am

    Yesterday afternoon I was ready to ask him to move out for a while and try a separation. I just didn’t think I could do it this anymore. Then I drove around for a while and went home and saw him and I softened and never said anything. Clearly I still love him even though I hate him. I think I’m overthinking a lot and putting a lot of pressure on myself to forgive him. I don’t think I’ll ever forgive him for not loving me during that period of time. I just have to figure out if him loving me now is enough.

  • tara81

    Member
    July 23, 2021 at 9:35 am

    I’m pretty sure my husband was not “in love” with me when he had the affair. I think he loved me like you said as his partner, mother of his child and as his family. I think that if we all think hard about our relationships we can see that at some point in our marriages we were not “in love” with our spouses. I think we go through phases and we don’t realize it because we are so busy with life. Our partners cheated because they were selfish and wanted some type of excitement and found a willing participant. In every relationship there is always one partner that is more responsible and I guess the responsible one is the one getting the short end of the stick. It sucks but it’s a reality. We are struggling because we are doing something we never thought we do( stay with a cheater). Before calling it quits we think about kids, debt, housing, future grandkids, retirement, even about them and their needs, we obsess over our choices because we want to make sure that we are not going to regret anything. We spend time agonizing about the reasons that they cheated, but it all comes down to that they wanted to do it. No one made them, no circumstances made them do it. They were selfish assholes. I think we need to work on forgiving ourselves for staying. I’m hurt and super angry almost a year later at how that woman really thought she was just going to sweep in and take my family. I know he was a willing participant and she couldn’t take what he wasn’t giving her. The pictures she sent me are fresh in my mind and boy can I see how she loved him. And if I admit things to myself he looked like he liked being with her. So the question that I keep asking myself is can I move past those images? Can I believe him when he says that he will never stray again? I know that if I leave him I’ll be miserable, I know that for sure. But can I stop beating myself up about this. He is ok and seems happy in our relationship. He is already making plans to take another trip. I think my struggles are not about him, they are about me and my expectations. They are about me doing something I didn’t think I would do. It’s about me letting go. Sorry I got off topic.

  • eliza4one

    Member
    July 23, 2021 at 9:48 am

    You said: I think my struggles are not about him, they are about me and my expectations. They are about me doing something I didn’t think I would do. It’s about me letting go.

    I wonder/think if this is what Tomisa meant when you replied on the “storm” thread and she ended it with, “I am the storm”.

    Tomisa~If you read this, I’d love to hear further thoughts about that very wise statement, “I am the storm”. 🙂

  • linds

    Member
    July 23, 2021 at 10:32 am

    Although I don’t think my husband was in love with me, I am certain he didn’t love her either. Honestly I’m not sure he even liked her that much. He said he liked that she talked “dirty”. She was the only girl in a group chat with a bunch of guys (both my brother-in-laws, my husband, a couple friends, etc.). She posted dirty jokes and memes. Then she started texting my husband outside the group chat. He liked the attention and the way she talked because it was exciting and flirty. I would never talk that way because I am a woman and not a skanky whore. She doesn’t have a good personality. All woman hate her. And the guys only like her because she has big tits and talks dirty.

    They never took photos together, they never hung out, never met up, never did anything alone. It was all texts until the one work trip where they stayed up drinking after the other went to bed and slept together.

  • cait

    Member
    July 23, 2021 at 12:36 pm

    After reading all of your posts, I am amazed at how it feels like each of you took the thoughts out of my head! I could have written what Legolady typed, verbatim.

    My husband, like all of yours, claims he was still in love with me during the affair. I think this must be comforting to them in some way. Do they really think we buy it? I don’t know…but it seems like my husband has convinced himself of it. There is no evidence to support this claim, though. During that time, it was like he was purposefully effing with me.

    His affection completely halted. Wouldn’t even give me eye contact most days. I had to initiate all hugs and he hugged me as if I were an untouchable person, eager to get away from me as soon as it ended. No hand-holding. No kissing, except a peck in front of other people. (He still cared what other people perceived of him…just not me.) He stopped saying “I love you” back to me. He told me one day, out of the blue, he didn’t want kids. (This was before we had our 2 kids.) That was like a blow to the chest. Another day, after I asked him if he still loved me, he admitted he didn’t know. If you don’t know if you love someone you married….you probably don’t. That night it felt like I was having a heart attack. He didn’t pay attention when I spoke. He didn’t care about my worries, work, my parents’ divorce, my special needs brother. The only topics he would deign to talk with me about were his workouts, his beard, fixing his teeth, and his affair partner! And, of course, he was guarding his phone and texting all night and day.

    Now, he admits that he was trying to get ME to “break up” with HIM through his actions. He says it is because he felt guilty and thought I deserved better so he was pushing me away….Oh, please. He didn’t give one damn about me during that time. He just didn’t want to lose face by admitting he had become what he hated the most, a damn cheater. He would rather lose me and my love over his pride.

    I don’t think he loved his ho-worker. I think he was using her as an ego boost and a source of porn. But he certainly prioritized his damn id over me. He loves himself/chooses himself over loving/prioritizing me. He chooses porn over me to this day.

    His love is inconstant and it haunts me. How callously he treated me haunts me. I still see echoes of it to this day. Like you, Linds, I don’t know if I can accept someone as a spouse who has fallen out of love with me during the course of our marriage. How can that really be love? It wasn’t just a *lacking spark* time period. It was 6+ months of unrelenting rejection. How can I be with someone who is capable of doing that to me????

    This is what is hardest for me to live with and forgive. How can someone who loves you hurt you like this, knowingly and purposefully? How can I trust this will not happen again?

Page 1 of 2

Log in to reply.