Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Members Stories › Mad Hatter, husband and sister though?

  • Mad Hatter, husband and sister though?

    Posted by xyzhereweare on December 3, 2020 at 12:59 pm

    Looking for thoughts and advice as my mind is blown. Some back story is that I had an A 11 years ago, physical, emotional, the whole bit for months. I ended up ending the A and telling my husband about it. (To this day I regret that decision 100%) We stayed married although I never really gave him the appropriate remorse. He was abusive to me in the aftermath, which was out of character for him, and he says now he suffered a “nervous breakdown” at the time which is the reason he acted that way. He also went and told every single person we knew. It was all very brutal, for him, for me, for those that were enmeshed in the situation. Well, we have slowly gotten back to a state of normalcy.

    Then last month my younger sister began having an affair outside of her marriage. I tried to warn her off of doing this, reminded her of the consequences of what I did, how it hurt so many people. She then said she was triggered by that memory and had to tell me something. She revealed to me, through tears and a heaving chest, an incident that happened 20 years ago. She had been staying at our house as she often did, and I was in bed. Apparently my husband came downstairs with no pants on and they had a very erotically charged and inappropriate conversation where according to my sister he expressed feeling sexually frustrated and she said “well she (meaning me) just had a baby so why dont you take care of yourself”. Then my husband proceeded to lay on the floor and masturbate in front of her. He was 31 at the time and she was in high school. They apparently, unbeknownst to me, had some type of “emotional affair” and “Crush” as he now puts it. He says it wasn’t about being physically attracted to her, but it was more about how she made him feel. According to him she laughed at all his jokes, knew all the words to all of his music that he wrote, and genuinely seemed to like spending time with him. We were newly married and I had just had our son. I had NO idea he was unhappy at that time, and I look back at that time of our life as a relatively happy one. He told me he was very immature at the time, and felt more like an 18 y.o. My parents say he was very immature as well. I dont think that’s an excuse but apparently it is for some!

    Then my sister said there was a second incident where my husband came downstairs where she was sitting in the family room(we were all staying at my parents house while our home was being rehabbed), and he had no pants on. Just a sweatshirt. She swears nothing happened and they just had normal conversation and he was covered the whole time.

    To make matters even more insane…when my A came out, and my husband was being abusive to me and our life was hell, my sister told my mother and our other sister about what my husband had done years before because she knew she had something that could really ruin him if it came out. She thought he was a hyppocrite for treating me that way when she knew what HE did with her years earlier. NO ONE FUCKING TOLD ME!!!! Their excuses now for not telling me run from “I thought you knew” to “we didnt want to make a bad situation worse and cause the kids to be affected” to “I cant remember it was 20 years ago”.

    I am sick over this. Sick that he did that in front of my sister. Sick that no one told me. And sick that he could treat me that way after my A when he had already done something that in my mind was not just immoral but also criminal. She was in high school for godssakes!

    Fast forward to now, and he took the opportunity to move out for 3 mos to another state for work. Totally out of character for him. Normally he is up my behind and doesnt ever want to be away from me. He for years after the A monitored my every move and even up until recently I would send him pics when I went out so he wouldnt think I was with the AP.

    He SWEARS he never did anything else outside of our marriage and one day just realized what he had to lose so he stopped the situation with my sister when I was pregnant with our second child.

    I am struggling to believe him. This behavior of his was a total shock to me and to the few people I have shared it with who know him. He is usually shy and has never flirted with any of my friends. No one has ever told me anything inappropriate about him. But something just doesnt sit right.

    Also, I had bought him a dashcam for christmas last year because both my kids have them and they have proven invaluable to have proof of reckless driving etc in case of an accident. SO being that my husband is an on the road salesman, I thought it was a great idea. He never installed it. Both times I asked him, before I knew any of this, why he didnt and he blamed it on not knowing how. But I call bullshit because he does LOTs of wiring of electrical, music equipment, etc. WOuld you be paranoid about that?

    There’s so much more to process, but this is the gist. We are both in IC and I’m trying to take it day by day.

    My sister and I and my whole family, we are all very close. We do meals several times a month, vacations every year, every birthday and holiday. I feel like a fool for this having gone on and I had no clue for all these years.

    I understand so much of why he may have done it, but I just wish he could have had an affair with a grown woman I didnt know. LIke that I could wrap my head around.

    replied 5 years, 11 months ago 2 Members · 3 Replies
  • 3 Replies
  • stepforward1

    Member
    December 3, 2020 at 2:26 pm

    Tough situation. Can’t tell at what part of the time line he did this with your sister; before or after he found out about your cheating? Just for perspective. If I missed that, I apologize.

    As someone who has been cheated on, and by someone who showed no remorse, the first part of your story jumps out at me. Where you casually tripped over that you did not show remorse, and that he stated he had a nervous breakdown. The way you said it sort of comes out as probably what it was at the time to him. That you did not really feel all that badly about what you did and that you did not take his feelings seriously. At least that’s how it seems to me. The thing about being cheated on, and maybe you’re feeling some of it now, is that it truly feels awful and that when you cheat on someone, you are not fully aware of how the other person will feel or will respond. Not knowing the timeline it sounds to me like this is all payback. Your sister is a victim of it. Kids in highschool are not mature enough to handle the crap he threw her way. And what he did was wrong, and possibly legally wrong depending on her age at the time.

    When you hurt someone, you have no idea how far the ripples will move out from the stone you threw in the pond. At this point, it’s between you guys and your therapist. But again, is sounds to me like you cheated on him and then just sort of shrugged it off/and now you are in a world of mess. That’s what happens.

  • xyzhereweare

    Member
    December 3, 2020 at 2:50 pm

    Thanks for your input. He did this with my sister 20 years ago. My A was 11 years ago. So as it turns out he betrayed me, with my little sister, well before I betrayed him. It’s almost like his reaction to my affair was a bit of projection. Also, I confessed my affair because I couldnt live with the guilt anymore. It’s out of character for me to be so deceitful. He however never told me, and I had to find out from my sister. My whole family betrayed me though also, because they found out after my affair, and yet never told me. Im struggling to deal with the fallout now.

  • stepforward1

    Member
    December 3, 2020 at 3:14 pm

    Got it. Sorry for being presumptuous.

    This is a lot to unravel. Sounds like karma got him at some point.

    This stuff is brutal. No one can tell you what to do; it’s one of those things that has to run its course and while that is happening, keep yourself safe.

Log in to reply.