Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Members Stories › New member. Sorry in advance for the long read.

  • New member. Sorry in advance for the long read.

    Posted by vito on July 28, 2021 at 10:09 am

    I came across this place out of necessity. I’ve got a great support group of people who love me but none of them have actually dealt with anything like this before, so their advice is well intentioned but probably not great. I apologize in advance for the long story but I feel the need to get all of the info out there. I also thank you In advance for taking time to read and for your responses.

    My name is Vito, I’m 31 years old and my wife has emotionally cheated on me for an unknown amount of time and I just so happened to catch it right before it got physical.

    Before I met my wife, she used to go to a lot of concerts with her friend C and my friend J and another fella I went to high-school with named M. I met my wife at J’s house New Years Eve 2010/2011 and hit it off immediately. When we first started talking, she had let me know that she had hooked up with J once while he had a girlfriend. She wasn’t proud of it and chalked it up to being young and stupid. I took that for what it was. I have been very very good friends with J since 2004. We met in sophomore year of high school and remained good friends since. M was always a friend of friends but we always got along very well and could hang out any time and it was a good time.

    Throughout my relationship with my wife, she always had a friendship with J that I felt uncomfortable about. We had spoken and argued about it a few times. She went through periods of not speaking to him. I went through period of not speaking to him as well.

    We got married in the Summer of 2016. We had the biggest wedding that Secrets in Jamaica had ever seen. J was not in attendance and neither was his girlfriend. Five or six years ago, my wife introduced J to her really good friend A and they hit it off fast as well. They were dating shortly after and she moved in with him shortly after. A recognized J’s friendship with my wife and confronted him about it. They argued and fought about it multiple times as well.

    Over the last three years or so, everything was fine. I was getting along with J, he was not talking with my wife anymore, and we would all often hang out. Go to concerts, parties, and all the things a group of friends would do. Tragically, their friend M (mentioned above) was going throigh a bad divorce where a kid was involved. He was an officer for the NYPD and used his service weapon to kill himself in his patrol car. My entire community was shaken by this. The wake was tremendous. Anybody we went to school with was there. It seemed like the entire roster of the NYPD was there. Truly sad. My wife resumed communication with J as a way of comforting eachother because he really was close with both of them. I wasn’t about to get in the way of helping her grieve and cope with her loss.

    Unfortunately these conversations never stopped. They began talking more frequently and for longer periods of time (unbeknownst to me). My wife and I did not have a perfect marriage, but whos is? We were working on whatever was happening with us but we were happy. We have a house and two beautiful dogs. And a half-annoying cat. We both work and don’t want for anything thankfully. I was feeling positive and hopeful but I guess I was the only one.

    We left for Aruba on 7/7 for a trip to celebrate out 5 year wedding anniversary and returned on the 13th. It was an amazing trip and we had a beautiful time. Things seemed great. We returned for our fathers birthdays (which are two days apart) and I returned to work after the weekend on 7/19. She is currently not working as she is an educator.

    On 7/19 I went home for lunch with my wife and she mentioned she was going to her parents for a swim and would be home later. She came back at 2am citing that her parents were fighting and she was trying to keep the peace. On 7/23 I came home again for lunch with my wife and she mentioned she was going back to her parents for a swim. At around 3:30 that day I decided to turn on the camera in our living room to check on the dogs. When neither of us is home I like to check on them every once in a while to make sure they’re OK.

    Unfortunately my wife was home and I saw her video chatting with J. I saw his face in her phone. And I saw her take her shirt off on the camera. I blacked out, left work, sped home and confronted her. It was not pretty and I ultimately kicked her out. She had since admitted to going to J’s on 7/19 after her parents where they talked, hugged, and held hands. I am told things never got more physical than that and that I was witnessing the first time anything was getting more than too friendly.

    My world absolutely fell apart. I am so conflicted about so many things on so many different levels. I am doing my best to be amicable with her and to take the high road but it’s not easy. I’m just totally lost now.

    replied 5 years, 3 months ago 4 Members · 8 Replies
  • 8 Replies
  • katie2020

    Member
    July 28, 2021 at 11:19 am

    Sadly, because I was cheated on, I don’t believe your wife. I don’t believe it was the “first time things got physical”… especially after she went to his his and had “hand holding and hugs.”

    I hate that this happened to you. I hope you can work things out. Sans children, it would be much easier to leave the marriage. I hate saying that, but it will be extremely difficult for you to trust again. Especially since they had a physical relationship before you two got together.

    Sorry, friend. Stay positive and find your own happiness.

  • riley

    Member
    July 28, 2021 at 5:38 pm

    I don’t know if I would trust her either. I also got cheated on, his also started as an emotional affair that I put a stop to and months later they rekindled and then it started to turn physical. I found out last week.

    He told me they never had sex and also tried telling me there was no phone sex, when I called bs he admitted to the phone sex.

    I don’t think I will ever believe that they never actually slept together. As since your wife already has the sexual history with him it’s not hard to imagine that happening again.

    Even if my husband goes to his grave promising sex never happened. If I decide to forgive him in mind it would have to be for sex too, because I am sure it happened but also because of all the times he has imagined screwing her while getting of himself.

    I am really sorry you are going through this. I am sorry that anyone has to go through this. It’s not fair to any of us, no matter how good or bad the marriage was. The pain is real because the betrayal is real.

  • melyy

    Member
    July 29, 2021 at 3:41 am

    That’s a lot to take in, let me start by saying that your wife is more than likely lying to you. Cheaters have a tendency to admit some truth but not all. I highly doubt it was her first time removing her shirt for him. Sounds more like playful chat that they’ve engaged in before. Just stop and think, do you really believe two adults who are attracted to each other and are alone in a house wouldn’t engage in something more than just hugging and holding hands? They aren’t in Jr high. I personally wouldn’t believe that nonsense.

    I’m a firm believer that you must teach people how to treat you and if at one point you “allowed” her to talk to him for consolidation it just gives the perception that it’s okay for her to talk to him anytime. Not sure if you ever set boundaries but considering that you’ve brought up how uncomfortable you are with their relationship but also okay with them talking it sends mix signals. Either way, it’s no excuse for her to cross any moral boundaries. Seems that by you two always having “issues” with this friend and allowing him back into your life from time to time has created a toxic environment. He nor she clearly can’t be trusted with one another since you are not the only one sensing vibes between them. There’s a possibility that she may have underlying feelings for him or she simply enjoys the “rush” she gets from sneaking around with him.

    I’d request to see her messages and if she deleted them or doesn’t want to show you then you have your answer on how far things have gone. If she has nothing to hide then there shouldn’t be a problem.

    Have you spoken to J? Fyi he’s not a friend and you should drop him from your life immediately. He clearly has no respect for you or your marriage.

    Since you’ve kick her out what has she done for you to show that she cares? To show that she’s willing to commit to fixing the marriage?

  • vito

    Member
    July 29, 2021 at 6:04 am

    Thank you for your reply. I know it would ultimately be easier to part ways than to try and work through things; I just can’t fathom trying to leave it all behind me. I have trouble sitting at my desk at work even. I’m sure that’s normal but it’s just so raw and new. I know she’s beating herself up in a big way. She always has, even for little things. Nobody is harder on her than she is. I don’t know if i believe her necessarily either. How could I, right?

  • vito

    Member
    July 29, 2021 at 6:11 am

    I’m sorry you’re going through this is well. I’m not sure that I can trust what she’s saying. I want to believe she was displaying attention-seeking behavior and reacting to the attention she got. Don’t know if that’s a thing or not. Individual therapies and group therapy are both going to happen at some point, hopefully soon. Reconciling wasn’t on my agenda until I spoke with my potential lawyer and he surprisingly was very sensitive and had some very unexpected things to say. I didn’t expect it and it got me thinking a little. I need to understand it all 100% before I make a decision. I won’t sleep if I’m still asking “what if” 10 years down the road. I had a pretty bad anxiety attack which lasted like 12 hours yesterday and stupidly called her when I was driving back from my parents. I weirdly calmed down immediately and have been fine since. We spoke about the Olympics, the dogs, and what we’ve been learning pre-therapy. She seems genuinely happy that I found some sort of support group with people who are experiencing the same trauma.

  • vito

    Member
    July 29, 2021 at 6:17 am

    I spoke with J and said some things I might end up feeling badly about one day, but it felt good at the time and still does. Everyone in our friend group has abandoned him. His family all moved out of state. He has nobody and it helps me sleep like a baby knowing that. My wife also had everyone abandon her (rightfully so) but I have different feelings there. I’m so conflicted there because she did what she did and deserves whatever she gets but at the same time that’s the person I care about in the world more than anything and I’m supposed to protect her and take care of her when she’s so down and it’s all just a total mind fuck. I know how badly she’s beating herself up. I know how remorseful she is. It makes things harder for me knowing these things. She’s back at her parents which is a very toxic place for her and she’s not doing well. We’re both going to do individual therapy and group therapy together to see how to proceed. I need all the answers to everything and she’s going to have have prove a lot to me over time. I don’t know that she ever will but I don’t think I can cut any of my options off just yet.

  • vito

    Member
    July 29, 2021 at 6:19 am

    One of the things I read about was extracting those answers from her. That cheaters need a safe mental space to give the answers. Forcing them and reacting badly to them will cause her to stop being truthful in fear of my reactions. It’s all so fucked.

  • melyy

    Member
    July 29, 2021 at 1:59 pm

    I would just start with the truth. Get the truth from her and then go from there. The worst she can do to you has already happened. What she needs to do now is respect you by giving you the whole truth and giving you the choice on whether you want to stay or leave.

Log in to reply.