Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Rant-Rave-Questions › once a cheater always a cheater?

  • once a cheater always a cheater?

    Posted by broken512 on June 24, 2018 at 11:19 am

    I know there is no way of knowing and everyone is different but what are some opinions on this? Cheating once can be a mistake and doesn’t mean that the person will cheat again, but does an affair actually count as just once? Having sex one time with someone is once in my opinion. What about a wife who has an ongoing affair and sleeps with the other person multiple times and goes to great lengths to lie and create stories and reasons to continue seeing this person? I feel like my wife has a very different opinion about this than I do. To me I think that if you are in a relationship and you have sex with someone outside of the relationship ten times then you’ve cheated ten different times and you’ve told lots of lies to make it all happen and continue happening. She seems to see it as a one time thing or just one mistake. Like since it was only “one” time or one person then I should still trust her. She hasn’t said these words but she sort of insinuates this. She accuses me of always bringing up the past just to make her feel bad.

    replied 7 years, 11 months ago 7 Members · 8 Replies
  • 8 Replies
  • joem

    Member
    July 7, 2018 at 4:07 pm

    Whether is one time, or ten, the lies deceit, the trying to continue to see him, etc. is the biggest factor.

    Her even arguing the one vs ten thing, and the fact that she tries to deflect, and blames you for making her “feel bad” is a HUGE red flag.

    It’s been my personal experience, and from being on this site for a long time, that once a cheater, always a cheater is the norm, but that’s not to say it is an absolute.

    There is just something about a cheater, they have a disconnect somewhere in their mind, where promises and commitments just don’t matter as much, that’s why they can break them. And, once they have done it, it gets easier.

    I hope I have given you some decent info to ponder, but please don’t go it alone, reach out to God in prayer, he is listening, and can help. Also, seek council with trusted family, friends, clergy, or all three.

    I wish you the very best, and will say a prayer for you all, may God Bless You.

  • larob

    Member
    July 24, 2018 at 5:57 pm

    I grew up believing that same thing. And then I got into recovery for my own issues and saw people who could change. In fact I had changed. And it gave me a new release on the idea that if people want to they will. But I do agree if it’s your fault and it’s one person but 10 times that’s still cheating. If you want to give her a chance to do so. because of the way she’s talking it’s all yours. Responsibility And if that’s the case you might as well keep on turning by yourself. Good luck to you.

  • admin

    Administrator
    October 14, 2018 at 12:36 pm

    Hi broken. I have to chime in here. There is no justification so don’t allow her to confuse you. If she is still acting this way, denying, downplaying, etc. She is not truly sorry. Staying with her is a high risk.

  • mafadi

    Member
    October 30, 2018 at 6:27 am

    I think it is so dangerous to try to create absolute truths when people and feelings are involved. “once a cheater, always a cheater”. Does that apply to everyone, to all situations? I don’t think so.
    Every individual is different. Every story is unique. When we start putting everybody on the same box, that can be very dangerous. Yes, there are red flags you have to consider, yes, cheating is selfish. yes, it ia a mistake because you were promised fidelity and you were counting on it BUT only you can find out if you can trust her again. She is the one though who has to find a way to make you trust again. She is the one who has to work hard to keep you in your life now. If she is not doing it, is she worth it?

  • broken512

    Member
    October 30, 2018 at 6:49 am

    Yeah, I guess I’m generalizing. Maybe I’m trying to figure out the odds of serial cheaters. How likely is it that if its happened once before or multiple times it will happen again?

  • sunnyr

    Member
    October 30, 2018 at 9:41 am

    Good advice from all.

  • admin

    Administrator
    October 30, 2018 at 11:21 am

    I don’t know if you have already tried this. In my experience, it would be helpful to probe into how she would feel about you cheating on her. Sometimes you can learn a lot from that. She could just be geared towards open relationships. The trick is asking the right questions so that you will get truthful answers. If she wouldn’t care much if you cheated, she will never think it is a big deal for her to. You have to be careful not to trigger a defensive attitude though, or she will hide her true nature.

  • notcrazy

    Member
    December 23, 2018 at 6:56 am

    I think it depends on the person. i know people that have cheated, didn’t feel any remorse and continued their whole life. others that saw the pain it caused and never did it again. if they think they got by with it, though, would be much harder not to do it again, because they didn’t see any pain it caused or any harm, in their mind. i understand relationships can be at a bad point when one decides to cheat. if you tell your spouse about a problem in your marriage and they don’t see it as a problem or don’t respond to try to fix it, then you get to a point where you think there is no hope, kinda like someone committing suicide. i think that’s when most cheat, they just give up. no matter how bad things are though, no one can MAKE you cheat. it’s a decision that you and you alone make. that’s what i told my husband, that won’t confess to doing anything anyway. i didn’t make you cheat, you did that on your own. i told him i forgive him but he didn’t get by with it, cause i know in my heart he did it. i have decided though if he ever does it again, i’m outta here. once is a mistake, twice is intentional . your supposed to learn from your mistakes, not make the same ones again.

Log in to reply.