Notta, trust is hard to get back for sure!
My husband lied to me for 3 years before I FINALLY grilled him and found out the truth. Before that, he swore on my eyes, my life, and HIS mother’s life that he wasn’t cheating and that he was too moral to ever do such a thing.
When I told my family about his cold treatment of me and my suspicions of him cheating, he threatened to never see them again because–oh how could anybody think HE could do something like that? Then I found myself apologizing to HIM and trying to smooth things over for HIM with my family. Talk about gaslighting!
In the 3 years before I found out the truth, I struggled mightily with depression and the knowledge that something was off in our marriage; his love was just not there. He tried to blame it all on post-partum hysteria because I had two kids. I will admit, that did not help matters, but it was all set off by his affair.
I totally understand your wish to get a lie detector but those are notoriously unreliable. If he is nervous in any way or about anything, he could set it off. Conversely, if he has little empathy or emotion, he could lie and get away with it. Narcissists and sociopaths are aces at lie detectors.
My husband tried to get a police job a long time ago–before we even got married. He got far in the process but failed the lie detector twice. He even told me that he popped on questions that had to do with sexual crimes.
I am not saying my husband is a saint, but I know for a FACT that he has never done anything like that. I think he just got nervous because he was in the military and it is like a giant fraternity with really horrendous porn/ stories getting passed around, trying to out shock each other. I am sure he has seen some messed-up stuff, but I am equally sure he didn’t commit it. He didn’t have to tell me that he failed the polygraph OR what kind of questions he popped on, either. He could have easily told me that his bad back disqualified him from the physical exam. I think he genuinely was amazed by the result.
Do I trust my husband, now? Yes and no. I would NOT be okay with him going out without me or attending work events with female coworkers. (His AP was a co-worker.) But I don’t think he is actively cheating on me at the moment.
He gives me his phone with ease…before he was guarding it all the time. He asks me to attend work functions with him or respects that he can’t go at all. He isn’t fostering any “friendships” with women; that is a hard boundary. He has left his work IM up before and I have perused it briefly and I didn’t see any inappropriate messages….before he admitted to sexting her on the company IM (Idiot!) He also works from home so he is a homebody and with me and the kids all the time. He doesn’t seem AS hardcore emotionally removed as he was when he was conducting his affair. Before he was like a pod person.
All in all….I trust my gut. I *knew* before when he was cheating but I chose not to find out for sure and look the other way because of his aggressive gaslighting. (The best of defense is a good offense.) And I trust my gut that he isn’t doing it now.
As for why they lie like this…all I can tell you is that almost ALL cheaters do this. Even ones that are usually honest. Even ones that want out of the marriage….so even bother to lie? Even ones that want a fresh start….why not get it all on the table and out of the way so healing can begin?
I think it has to do with confronting themselves as much as anything. They don’t want to look too hard at what they have done. They want to think of themselves as good, moral people, still. They tell themselves it was just a “one-off” or “a one-time mistake.” They think they can just not do it again and think why does anyone really need to know their misdeeds. They don’t want to be held accountable. They are selfish and want to protect THEIR sense of identity and reputation over YOUR sanity. They are cowards.
The lying was the second most hurtful thing about my husband’s affair. The most hurtful thing was the disdain with which he treated me while it was still going on….but lying feels like a disdainful act, too. I have to remind myself, that it is not because of ME. If that were true, then my husband would be the only cheater lying. They are lying because they are accustomed to it and don’t know how to stop.
Only once they finally get off the hamster wheel and the full truth is out can healing and trust SLOWLY rebuild. It takes years.