I am so very sorry for the situation you have been placed in, and will offer my humble opinion and advice.
Not getting married because he wants to continue to go out with his friends is one of the lamest excuses for fear of commitment I have ever heard…… There are plenty of married couples that have “girl’s night” and/or “boy’s night out”; marriage DOES NOT require you to give up time with your friends, plain and simple…………
Your boyfriend has a fear of commitment, and coupled with the fact that he has also refused to grow up – I mean, staying out all hours of the night, with a family at home alone??? REALLY????
To be honest……and you may not want to hear this, I suspect he has been cheating for quite a while, and not getting caught has made him bolder, hence more nights out, staying out later, etc.
This man has no respect for you, the mother of his children, and obviously doesn’t mind doing things to hurt you and the kids. Remember, he is not just cheating on you, he’s cheating on the kids, too…
He appears to want SO MUCH time AWAY from you and the children, that I believe he is not suitable to be a relationship, let alone a marriage, he has issues, that much is clear…
You are correct, not being able to trust him will drive you crazy, trust me, I know……
Now, you DO have a choice, you ARE NOT stuck…You need to get out of that state of mind. You all have what any state would consider a common-law marriage, and that means you can get spousal support, (alimony) as well as child support, get with an attorney for the details.
Insight30, you deserve a loving partner that will stay true to you as much as the next person, please remember that. You deserve a partner that “wants” to be with you.
I do realize that it is very easy for me to write all this, and that it is you that must take the steps to make it happen, but happiness is worth it, again, trust me on this……..Will it be hard? Yes. Will it be difficult on the kids? Yes. Will they survive, and will you all get to a better place? YES………
Please don’t bear this burden alone, seek council with trusted family, friends, clergy, or all three.
I highly recommend you get tested for STDs ASAP, you may have already been exposed to something.
And one other thing: “She” doesn’t win, even if they end up together, she winds up with a man that CAN’T BE TRUSTED………
I wish you all the best, and will say a prayer for you all.