Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Members Stories › Still a newlywed

  • Still a newlywed

    Posted by cousinsmiley on June 8, 2021 at 6:26 pm

    Hello all!

    I got married last October. It hasn’t been a whole year yet and I want to enjoy the honeymoon phase of my marriage but I cannot because I have suspicions that my spouse has been cheating. The arguments come out of nowhere and of course I’m to blame. The last few arguments were about us not being around each other 24/7 and that we needed our own lives. I totally get that but we’ve been in a pandemic and we are our bubble. So why do I have suspicions? I’ve received random text messages and phone calls from women about him being a liar and a cheater. I’ve seen text messages on his phone from someone asking if he’s coming over tonight. And then there is my intuition and my gut. I know something isn’t right. I’ve seen addresses in the cars navigation, I’ve seen him texting until he realizes I’m around. But here is the kicker – I entered this relationship as a polyamorous person. I don’t mind the relationships with other people. I know we cannot be everything to one another. But what I do mind is lying. When the lies start flowing it becomes cheating in my book. I made this super clear to him from the onset of our relationship. I don’t understand why he has to lie about it. I just want the truth. As I type this he is “hanging out” and I know that’s code for seeing some woman. He’ll call to check on me but I know that’s only so that I won’t call and interrupt him. His hanging out will bring him home as the sun comes up. And I know the story will be that he stopped at his cousins house and fell asleep after having a few too many drinks. I’m no dummy and I’m highly intelligent but right now I’m beating myself up that I fell and keep falling for his stories. I don’t want my marriage to end. I just want him to be honest about what he wants and what’s going on.

    I can’t talk to anyone about this at all. We had a beautiful wedding and everyone thinks we are great together (we are for the most part) and I of course don’t want to be judged. I’m just fed up with the consistent lies.

    I asked him about seeing a therapist and he says we can work our own issues out.

    I think that was a vent session lol. I appreciate you taking the time to read it!!

    replied 5 years, 5 months ago 5 Members · 14 Replies
  • 14 Replies
  • tomisa

    Member
    June 8, 2021 at 6:37 pm

    This is the first post I have read from someone who is polyamorous. Was that the relationship dynamic that was agreed between you both or is that your expressed preference only? My own understanding of polyamory is limited but I thought that it involved an agreed relationship between more than two people. Understandably, you didn’t consent to lying and cheating. Just seeking clarification before I express any opinion or proffer any advice.

  • cousinsmiley

    Member
    June 8, 2021 at 7:07 pm

    Yes polyamory involves an agreement. We agreed that we would focus on one another. Since I’m the one with experience in polyamorous situations I expressed that if I became interested in someone else I would be truthful and let him know. His response was that he doesn’t believe in polyamory and he’s not a cheater. I then told him that I’d like to be informed if a situation with someone else presented itself. He laughed it off and said ok.

  • tomisa

    Member
    June 8, 2021 at 8:13 pm

    Thanks. It seems there is a divide between you on polyamory. Again I don’t want to judge or marginalize but I feel that his response to you when you expressed your honest position was dismissive. He may actually have subconsciously received your position as a license to become involved with someone else whilst consciously rejecting your suggestion. He will likely respond to any allegations with disdain because he may, wrongly, conclude that you acknowledged that you may become interested in someone else in the course of your relationship. My sister in law is fond of saying that relationships work best when both or in the case of polyamory all parties are standing beside each other and looking in 5he same direction. I have always thought this made sense. You have not begun with the same ethos and in truth you have only just begun. I think it is likely from your narrative that he is involved with someone else. You need to honestly confront him on this and your polyamorous beliefs and discuss your respective expectations of fidelity. If he refuses to discuss both of these issues with you then I think you are heading for more conflict and you deserve the honesty you so patently requested. You are clearly not someone who is ruled by conservatism so the fact that other people hold an idealized view of your relationship is irrelevant. Everyone keeps calling me to tell me how great a couple my ex and I were and how much he loves. I only care what I think about this. I know when someone loves me. I feel it. I see it in their eyes. I preferred to believe that he did love me but it was not the message that was conveyed to me when he refused to answer my questions, deflected, attacked me verbally and displayed indifference in the face of my great sorrow. Confrontation did not make him tell me the truth of his conscious infidelity because plausible deniability is his favorite strategy. We are regrettably both lawyers which can make discussions unnecessarily technical. Confrontation did however reveal how much he loved me which was sadly not enough. Consider confronting him and learning the state of his true feelings for you and his respect for your beliefs.

  • tara81

    Member
    June 8, 2021 at 8:14 pm

    It sounds like he is trying it out but doesn’t want to share you with anyone else. I hope that you are able to sit down and talk to him, and hopefully he will be truthful.

  • sharstar

    Member
    June 8, 2021 at 8:36 pm

    That’s really hard. There’s nothing worse than all of the clues but loving and trusting someone so needing to hear it from them. And how do you address an issue the other person refuses to acknowledge. I think I may have made a mistake thinking I could deal with a man who struggles with monogamy but wants me to be monogamist. I think its true that the fundamental belief systems or approach to the relationship need to be aligned for it to work. Its just so hard when you fall in love with the person not their preferences or sexual identity.

  • cousinsmiley

    Member
    June 8, 2021 at 8:52 pm

    Thank you so much for this response! I have confronted him and he denies any infidelity and becomes angry and tells me I need to get a life outside of him along with other nasty things. Today’s argument he called me out of my name which is a huge negative for me. All I could do was cry and just let him walk out of the door. He did apologize for calling me out of my name but I’m of the mindset that what a person really thinks and feels comes out when they are angry or intoxicated.

    Right now I’m not feeling confident about our future. We’re supposed to be relocating to another state at the end of the summer but I’m on the fence about that I want my marriage but I need honesty

  • cousinsmiley

    Member
    June 8, 2021 at 8:54 pm

    You are correct. He’s not comfortable with me being involved with anyone else.

  • cousinsmiley

    Member
    June 8, 2021 at 9:02 pm

    Yes it is very hard!!

  • melyy

    Member
    June 9, 2021 at 12:23 am

    Upon meeting your partner was he polyamorous as well? Just want a little more insight before giving my opinion.

  • cousinsmiley

    Member
    June 9, 2021 at 12:42 am

    No he was not. I told him I was on day 1. I explained in depth what that meant for me. I actually thought he was no longer interested but he called for another date.

  • melyy

    Member
    June 9, 2021 at 8:35 am

    If you’ve made it clear that the lying is considered cheating then he’s clearly cheating. Men lie for the strangest things. I once dated a guy and from the start mentioned to him that if he wanted to date other people(or sleep with) just let me know and I’m perfectly fine with it. It didn’t bother me since I wasn’t looking for anything serious. He told me straight out that he didn’t want to date/sleep with anyone else and that I was the only girl he wanted to be with. 3 months into it his gf messages me on my social media account and tells me to call her. I do, find out they’ve been together for a year, she met his family (as did I) and he met her son. He calls me that same day and I bring it up to him telling him that I no longer wanted to see him. The problem wasn’t the other girl, it was the lie. Why did he lie? I have no idea! He had no reason to lie.

    In regards to your husband I would bring up the conversation as a “matter of fact” type approach. Mention to him that you’ve seen the messages, you know what’s going on and that you just want transparency. In doing so make sure he is aware that you won’t leave him over it, that you just want truth and honesty. Men don’t like feeling like they are being attacked. They also don’t like to be perceived as the bad guy so maybe that’s why he can’t fess up to what he’s doing.

    From another angle, maybe he perceives it as an open relationship and doesn’t understand you’re view as to why it would bother you since you are a polyamorous person. He potentially (like most men say) doesn’t want to be “nagged” for what he is doing so he keeps it to himself. Or maybe talking about it makes him uncomfortable.

    I feel a lot of it is a misunderstanding of communication on his end. Seems like he doesn’t really comprehend what you perceive as cheating so I would make that loud and clear to him. He has no reason to lie. Only reasons he would lie is 1) it makes him uncomfortable to talk about it 2) might be ashamed of it 3) doesn’t understand why you want to talk about it when in his mind you are okay with it or 4) he doesn’t want to hurt your feelings

  • cousinsmiley

    Member
    June 9, 2021 at 10:39 am

    Thank you for your response!! I don’t understand why he must lie. I’ve done the “matter of fact” I saw the text message conversation and he felt VERY attacked. I wasn’t even mad I just told him what I saw. I didn’t ask any questions or anything.

    He constantly reminds me that he’s not a cheater at all. And that he hates cheaters (his first wife cheated on him and had a baby). So I understand where the sentiment stems. I just want honesty that’s all! He definitely thinks the truth will hurt me. He talks about protecting me. Of course discovering the truth hurts even more.

    I don’t want to walk away from this relationship because I know it’s a communication and understanding my perspective issue. And there is something deeper going on with him. But right now today I’m ready to just go. I’m just tired of hurting and tired of crying. I just never expected my husband to make me feel this way.

  • melyy

    Member
    June 9, 2021 at 6:23 pm

    We never expect our loved ones to hurt us. I’m sorry you feel this pain.

    It seems like he is ashamed of what he’s doing if he condones cheating. He doesn’t want to be perceived as a cheater. That’s a tough one. Have you tried mentioning to him that the act of what he doing isn’t cheating in your eyes? That only the lie is?

  • cousinsmiley

    Member
    June 12, 2021 at 9:30 am

    Oh yes! I’ve told him it’s the lying that affects me not the relationship with other women. He just gets defensive and of course turns it on me and says things that he has to apologize for saying. I’m a true believer in hurt people hurt people. I just don’t know what hurt exactly he is feeling. I wish he would agree to professional help.

    Thank you so much for your feedback

Log in to reply.