Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Members Stories › To keep talking or not? That is the question!
-
To keep talking or not? That is the question!
Posted by linds on July 25, 2021 at 4:56 pmWhat is everyone’s take on continued conversations about the affair? I’m 9 months out next week and we typically talk about it a few times a month when I freak out or blow up. And I ask questions trough the day by text when things come to mind. My husband really wants to start putting it behind us and try to limit the discussions. I’m not sure if I’m ready for that but I also see that talking about it is causing both of us a lot of pain. I know the details, I’ve asked all the questions, I still don’t like the answers. Do you guys think that it’s time to stop discussing it so frequently? I really want to stop talking about it because I feel like it’s starting to do more harm then good but at the same time sometimes I just need to talk about it. Is there a way to discuss it without asking questions? Do you all focus more on how your New relationship is going vs how it was during the affair time frame? I seem to really focus on the past and have trouble focusing on now. I bring up not only the affair and the whore but the way we were in the past too. How do I change the conversation to trying to rebuild vs rehashing?? Do you just push it down? Do you write all your questions in a journal to get it out but be okay without getting answers? I’m really finding this part of it hard. Like if I stop asking questions that means I’m ok and moving on when Im not ok yet. If I stop asking questions I’m telling him what he did was okay and I’ve forgiven him when it’s not and I haven’t.
replied 5 years, 3 months ago 6 Members · 14 Replies -
14 Replies
-
I didn’t stay so I’m probably not the best person to contribute on this but I would like you to consider whether his responses are not satisfying your questions or whether you just cannot accept the validity or correctness of his responses though they may be accurate and truthful. If it’s the first scenario then therapy may yet assist you both in framing questions and answers and creating a safe space for increased disclosure and transparency. If it’s the second scenario then you may have to consider whether you can ever resolve the dissonance. I say you in the second instance because he cannot help you beyond the information. If the answer to that is no then the cycle of question and answer becomes harmful to both of you and the relationship becomes defined and then ultimately corrupted by it.
-
We continue to talk about it. I don’t get angry with him anymore. So, we can now talk calmly and rationally.
We don’t talk about the details of the affair, we talk about the psychology behind it. Where he was at mentally when he was involved with her and where she “might” have been mentally, as well (for example: to “sleep with a stranger” (my husband’s words) the first day they met). That is so far out of my realm that I don’t even understand how a woman can do that…
To me, it’s all a part of understanding my husband’s psyche. He didn’t have an affair because he wanted sex or wanted something different or…he (coincidentally) met someone almost identical to him as far as childhood trauma/upbringing and he was enamored with that. He thought that, together, they would/could heal each other, and fulfill all that they had been longing for their entire lives (value, worth, validation, love…).
In order to move forward, I have to understand his psyche as much as I can possibly understand it. (We come from totally different backgrounds/childhoods).
I’m pretty much done with the details. I would say I’m almost done with the psychology behind the affair, as well.
Just now, a question popped into my head. Last night while talking, he brought up the fact that after his Australia trip, he got the sense she regretted what she/they had done, but she never specifically stated that. And he was deathly afraid to ask her because if she said yes, it would shatter the illusion of them that he had created in his mind.
So, just now I texted him, “Would you be sad if she regretted the affair/Do you want her to not regret the affair?” I know he’ll be honest with me and by talking about it, it helps him look within himself to better understand his psyche.
I do think each couple is different, as is each individual. But I also believe that the betrayed spouse gets to “call the shots” when it comes to when he/she is done asking the questions.
-
This is a hard question to answer. It depends on the personality of the parties involved. I think that asking the same questions over and over is not productive to building the relationship. I feel like bringing up the affair is keeping it alive in a place where it shouldn’t. I think that after a certain amount of time has passed it might be doing more harm than good. However, I still have questions, so every couple of weeks I bring it up. I can be ok after our talk and keep it going, but he just closes off again and needs time to come out of a place of shame. So it’s like we take 2 steps back. He told me that he feels like I would never be able to forgive him and get past the length of the affair. I’m scare that he might be right. I really want it to work out and God knows I love that man, but this has been such a humbling experience. And I still feel dumb for staying especially since I can support myself and he will leave me the house and whatever I want. I don’t want to talk about it, I want to enjoy this new phase in our relationship. We are communicating more, traveling more, more affectionate but once in a while that dark cloud comes by. I think I need to let go for me not for him. I need to either enjoy this marriage or walk away. Thinking and bringing up the affair won’t help me accomplish that. I write him emails that I don’t send when I want to ask the same questions again. That helped me. Linds, just because we choose to move on and stop torturing ourselves does not mean we accept what they did. Working on ourselves and our marriage does not mean that we accept what they did. It just means that we are done living in the past and it’s up to them to prove to us that they are worth a second chance.
-
Tara I think you’re right. For my sanity I have to stop bringing it up and asking the same questions over and over. I think I keep hoping the answer will be different but it never is. Moving on is the best thing for both of us so that we can see if we can make this marriage work. It’s just very difficult to do when I literally think about the affair all the time. I don’t know when it won’t be what I think about constantly. Maybe after the first year things will get a little better and a little easier. I’m pretty sure I still love him just not the same anymore. I’ll never believe in true love again. I’ll never believe in pour happiness again. Fairytales are just stories.
-
I think I understand as much as I’m going to. Asking more questions isn’t getting me anymore clarity and is causing my husband to shut down. I think the reason I want to bring it up and continue asking questions is because I want him to make different choices. Unfortunately he can’t do that, and it is bringing him deep shame which makes him want to shut down.
I believe that he has no feelings for this woman. He’s made it clear that if I were to leave him, he would not be with her. Her only use to him was for the restaurant, and he’s working so hard at the restaurant for me. Without me, he has no desire to go to work each day and he would close the restaurant.
He is doing everything in his power to make me feel loved and cherished. I am trying to make an effort to stop bringing up the affair and live in the moment working on building a new better relationship.
I’m reading books on relationships and communication. Easier said than done, but I need to stop bringing up the affair. It puts us both in a bad mood and she needs to see us happy and together. Last Thursday he ended up leaving the restaurant and we had to shut down for dinner. I don’t want that Bitch to know that she still has any influence on our happiness. She needs to feel like she doesn’t matter, because to him she doesn’t. It’s only me that is giving her value.
So happy and in love. It puts her in a foul mood and hopefully she’ll move on out of our lives.
-
Exactly the same here. We both shut down as well when I bring it up. And I agree I think I keep asking the questions to get a different answer. To get an answer that makes me feel like I mattered. Like I was important. Something to make me feel good about staying. I really never could have imagined how hard it would be to be cheated on. I always said I’d kick him out and make him pay and move on with my life. The emotional pain is like nothing I’ve ever experienced before. I just read Blindsided by is Betrayal. It was really good. Was on point with so many things that I’m feeling. I wish there was a step by step guide to recovery for this but I don’t think that exists. Everyone will have a different journey with healing from something like this.
-
linds~Can you tell me if or how the book Blindsided By Betrayal was or was not helpful to you? I don’t want to read a book that drags me back down into the dumps…
Thanks!
-
I think it just reinforced that what I’m feeling is normal and I’m not crazy.
-
Thanks. Not sure if I should read it or not. Ugh. I hate the triggers and they happen so frequently.
-
I know what you mean. Sometimes I feel like I have to read something because still trying to figure out how to navigate this. I’m still really struggling with how to move forward with this man that I don’t feel like I know anymore or can trust. I guess I keep thinking if I keep reading maybe something with trigger in a good way and give me that clarity I’m looking for.
-
This is a really good question! I still am talking about the affair one every 1-2 weeks (per my “volcano” cycle, I guess) but even that requires a great deal of restraint on my part. I choose NOT to talk about it (for his sake and my sanity) more than I choose TO talk about it. These efforts are, unfortunately, hidden and therefore unacknowledged. I am thinking about it every day and it is hard to keep silent on something that is still actively hurting you. And my husband is a constant reminder of the pain.
I think I am also trying to accept and desensitize myself to what happened. I still feel surprised that this has become us. I wake up each day and think, “Did that really happen?”
I am not sure how to do this without talking about it, although I don’t see it as necessarily healing our marriage, either. I think it has to do more with me coming to grips with the fact that someone who loved me just…stopped. I still can’t wrap my head around that.
Maybe I need to hash this all out in therapy alone, although my past attempts haven’t gone well. I felt like I was being “blamed” for having a problematic father who hurt me and for having unrealistic expectations of love. I just think it is wrong to make it out to be a girl/woman’s fault for being hurt by the men in her life. And I think I still would have been devastated by this even if my dad had been great. And my expectations were not that high…just don’t fall out of love with me and stonewall me. Be faithful. Is that really too high a bar?
I will say that if you are having a good day, give yourself permission to feel good. You aren’t letting him get away with it. You are letting yourself be happy for a change. Don’t expose yourself to anything negative on those days; protect them and enjoy them.
-
cait~
You said: I just think it is wrong to make it out to be a girl/woman’s fault for being hurt by the men in her life. And I think I still would have been devastated by this even if my dad had been great.
Any therapist or person who says or implies this is wrong! It pisses me off just knowing this takes place (and I know it does). My dad was a wonderful father, husband, and human being. Obviously, that didn’t help with my current devastation. I’m still devastated. What I am thankful for is the strength he gave me and that I know he is looking down upon me, with the belief that I will be all right. More than all right. But, no. that is just plain wrong! I would never go back to said therapist and I would love nothing more than to tell them how wrong they are.
You said: And my expectations were not that high…just don’t fall out of love with me and stonewall me. Be faithful. Is that really too high a bar?
I’ve read enough of your posts to know that your expectations are NOT too high. In fact, you are expecting far less from your husband than I am, and than many women are/do! You are doing SO much for that man. More than you are doing for yourself, imo. So, don’t let anyone tell you your expectations are too high. Spouses meet each other in the middle. Period. Doesn’t matter the expectations.
I do admire you so much and don’t know how you do it. Somehow, you are! You are strength personified!
-
Thank you, Eliza! I don’t know how I missed this post but am glad I found it tonight. You will laugh at this but sometimes I think, what would Eliza or one of the others do in this situation? It really helps me!
-
You said: You will laugh at this but sometimes I think, what would Eliza or one of the others do in this situation? It really helps me!
Oh, me too!!! Because truly, I have no one else who has gone through this. Sure, some friends/my sisters know, but they haven’t gone through it. The women on here have and I SO relate to you all. Like you said in another post, we can be “real” here with no judgement! No facade! I love that about this site. I love our honesty, as well. Makes me not feel so alone and/or so horrible about myself with regards to how I’m doing (like on the bad days).
Log in to reply.