Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Members Stories › Two wrongs don’t make a right?

  • Two wrongs don’t make a right?

    Posted by daal on January 15, 2025 at 10:52 pm

    Hi everyone,

    This is hard to write and a long story.

    Over 18 months ago August 2023 I had a brief physical affair with a work colleague. It was stupid and I regret everything about it. My wife found out and was broken. It has taken a long time to heal for us both and she has been amazing through it all. I do believe I am the luckiest man alive. I know it should probably not be said, but I honestly have no craving or need or thoughts of ever doing that again.

    The issue is I have recently found out that after my infidelity. My wife has had three one night stands. 1 in June 2024 and 2 in September 2024 All through a popular affair website. She never intended to tell me and she says it was for healing purposes. Which I believe whole heartedly.

    Now I feel like I’m in a very awkward position. I want to be with my wife I love her unconditionally and the is 100% still a physical attraction there. My concern is that I found out because her behaviour had changed recently and I had a gut feeling so I questioned her and after denying it a few times she admitted to 1. A bit of questioning later and she admitted to the other 2. I’ve come to believe that her behaviour had changed again because she was back on the website after leaving it. So even though she did the previous ones for clarity and to understand my actions. I’m worried that now she has some kind of taste for it, otherwise why would she sign back up and look for other guys?

    The next twist, as much as I can’t get it out of my head and I realise that I don’t exactly have the morale high ground here. Instill want to know everything! She is giving me as much as she can but struggles with some details. The bigger twist, is the thought of her with the other guys and when she is telling me, is turning me on! I seem to be getting a kick out of knowing, and it’s curious that I have not even been mad at her for any of it. I was in a worse mood before she told me because of my paranoia now I feel relieved and curious.

    Our marriage and our sex life has been amazing for the past 9 months as well. Our sex life after discovery of mine was incredible. But I realise she was trauma bonding with me, so im not sure if i am doing that with her now or if it truly does give me a kick.

    My mind is everywhere and I’m struggling to process. I am fully aware that there will be those out there that will say. “Well you did it first, this is a taste of your own medicine, such it up and move on” and it’s not that I disagree with you. But the curiosity is still there.

    replied 1 year, 9 months ago 3 Members · 7 Replies
  • 7 Replies
  • cait

    Member
    January 23, 2025 at 11:16 am

    This is a tough one. You cheated and your wife capitalized upon it by using it as a pretext for an unlimited hallpass, which was undeniably wrong. You are both cheaters, not just you.

    The reclaiming period happened for us as well. Sex was great but it only lasts for a short time, maybe a few months if you are lucky. No more than six.

    If it continues in your case, then I think you have your answer as to whether you are trauma bonding with your wife or whether you have a hotwife fetish.

    If the later is the case, and you are both okay with that lifestyle, then I genuinely think you can have a happy open relationship.

  • daal

    Member
    January 27, 2025 at 9:52 am

    Thank you for your words. I’m not sure what to believe in regards to her being back on the site after it all. Maybe she was just after the kick of it.

    I have come to that conclusion as well. See this period through and if things settle back down to how it used to be then I know I was just trauma connecting with her. My worry obviously is trusting her. As is the case with her and me I guess.

    If we are still able to get a kick then yes it would seem I have that fetish. However with that comes the dilemma of it not being an atypical open relationship. As I don’t intend or indeed want to go out and sleep with other women.

  • cait

    Member
    January 28, 2025 at 10:40 am

    Why is that a dilemma? If you both are okay with it and honest, then I don’t see the problem?

  • devastatedwife

    Member
    January 28, 2025 at 1:09 pm

    I do. I have been a hotwife. As soon as I was struggling with grief due to a death in my family and didn’t have as much interest, he was out fucking around with a coworker even though he swore he didn’t have interest. Clearly not true. I was very clear that I do not share whether he wanted me to share or not. I did it completely for him. I have zero interest even now in being with anyone else. Well not even him at this point. I’m turned. In this case, she has already proven she’s untrustworthy. He has too I guess. But open relationships whether hotwife or whatever require solid foundations with complete honesty and transparency. That is certainly not the case here. As for me, never again….

  • cait

    Member
    January 29, 2025 at 9:34 am

    I am sorry that is your experience. It certainly wouldn’t be my idea of a good time either! But I think the difference here is that you weren’t okay with it. You are comparing apples and …maybe not oranges but definitely pears. You said you did it 100% for your husband. OP’s wife is clearly doing it 100% for herself. He is into it. This is a different circumstance than yours was.

    If both parties are okay with it, then I think it can be fine. However, your point about a lack of trust and transparency is definitely valid. That might be the real dilemma here. Since neither one of them has been trustworthy, maybe it cancels each other out? Maybe it exacerbates everything? Not sure.

  • daal

    Member
    January 30, 2025 at 11:47 pm

    There is now definitely a lack of trust from both parties, I’m not saying its not growing again, but I personally have to stop myself from asking questions to where she has been. I don’t even believe she has been anywhere to do anything untoward but I still feel the need to ask. Maybe that will go away in time. I can’t 100% speak for her but I know she doesn’t question me all of the time but whether she has thoughts about it I don’t know.

    She has no worries about me now she is adamant and has 100% access to my phone and has checked it in the past to put her mind at ease, she hasn’t done for a while though. Something major is that I do not have access to hers. She says if I ask she will let me on it but I do not know her pin. Granted I have secretly been on it in the past and deleted parts of her phone and that’s why she changed the pin. But is the circumstances not changed now?

    As for the trauma bonding, things seem to be settling down slightly i don’t feel the need to mention it to her as much, which in turn is not bringing through the kink for me. We still have sex, and i really enjoy it. So I need to start asking myself the question do I need that in my life, because she is willing. And then is it all for me or am I setting myself up to let her go out and do other bits on the side and not share, because let’s face it there’s history for that there now. Which would mean that she is satisfying her own additional needs regarding having her cake and eating it and being secretive.

  • cait

    Member
    February 2, 2025 at 11:12 am

    Both of you should have 100% access to each other’s phones. If she wants to keep a private, paper journal (or if you do) then I would respect the privacy for that. But you can’t cheat through a journal. You can definitely cheat through a phone.

    Sounds like the bloom is coming off the rose for you. You realize that your wife is having her cake and eating it too and that it really has nothing to do with you at all. If you are into it, kink-wise-, then I am sure that is sprinkles on her cake. But it isn’t why she is doing it. To me, it doesn’t sound like your feelings matter to her at all. She is going to do what she’s going to do, no matter what you think about it. And I think that would be disheartening for anyone to realize.

Log in to reply.