Affair Recovery Community › Forums › Members Stories › Very confused at what have done

  • Very confused at what have done

    Posted by mags on April 29, 2021 at 9:24 pm

    Have no doubt I will upset many with my post….but do value feedback as am at a crossroads where must make a decision as afraid may crack if do not.

    I am the guilty party….. am the loving mother, daughter, sister, friend and, until a few years ago, the loving wife….

    4 years ago my husband had a mid-life crisis… Had suspected something was wrong; asked him to go to counseling. He agreed, but at therapy sessions stated he had no issues, was only there to be supportive to me….. Fast forward 5 months, Dday came for me. Out of the blue, my husband told me he didn’t know if he believed in marriage any longer. When asked if he still loved me – he responded “I would save you from a burning building”… I was devastated, went into depression. Asked if there was some one else one evening. He responded he had had several opportunities on business trips (and told me of them) but said nothing ever happened. We had two young daughters under the age of 10. Was a horrible time for me. I am the breadwinner making significantly more than my husband. Was commuting to the City over an hour each way every day to a job that paid very well and provided for my family, but working for someone who was difficult and made my job unfulfilling to say the least.

    I became somewhat resentful that here I was having recently moved to the suburbs, not having many friends, gone 12 hours a day from my girls and now dealing with a husband who hurt me horribly. I spent many nights up crying – he showed no remorse but said he had become desensitized to my feelings. For the next year and a half to two years, he was distant, would refer to me as needy. When would get home from work at one point said, “will talk when you have something interesting to say” (to be fair, I did complain a lot about working so much and not being able to meet friends in town or see my girls enough as gone so much).

    My husband’s solution was to join a fancy golf club… he had been a golf pro in his younger days before we married and believed would be a good way for me to make friends and he would be able to play golf. I nixed it pretty quickly as the price tag was crazy and knew meant I would have to work even harder to pay for it. Said I didn’t need a club to make friends but would be happier cutting back at work and meeting moms through my daughters at school. He was not very supportive. We went to counseling for a year. I was so hurt and angry and he was upset expecting I should have been empathetic towards him after telling me he wasn’t sure he believed in marraige. That he was confused and expected I would have been supportive as he worked to figure himself out.

    After being depressed for a while, I asked him to listen to the tape the 5 Love Languages so we could understand each other’s way of relating better. Kept saying he would, but never did. After 6 mos of asking, told him after vacation was going on with friends, I would not be coming back. Only then did he listen to the tape….

    I tried to make things better – bought sexy lingerie, tried to initiate being intimate. I was rejected many times – told that he was not in the mood. But never hearing “am sorry – it’s not you”…. There were two times I asked to see his phone. Once was headed to the gym and my phone was broken. asked if I could borrow his to listen to his phone play list. At first said No – not giving you my phone. When I pressed why, he finally said OK but right in front of me, deleted a few texts first. When asked what he was deleting, he said inappropriate photos his guy friends would send that he didn’t want me to be offended by. He swears he did not cheat. Do not think he was in love with someone else, but I still question to this day whether he had had an affair while on overnight sales trips.

    I got tired of feeling so down. I decided was time to focus on me. After working 12 hours a day, I made a huge effort to make friends in town, organizing working mom’s groups. Made a few friends and spent time enjoying myself with them – grabbing dinner or drinks once every week or two. Spending weekends with my daughters. My husband threw himself into sports and joined paddle leagues. I also decided to apply for an executive leadership program at a top university. It was a 10 month program that required on campus sessions for 5 weeks over the course of 10 months (2 weeks in December, 2 weeks in April and 1 week in October). I applied on a whim and to my surprise was accepted. For the first time in months, had a glimmer of happiness. Something to get my confidence back. The night we went out with the kids to celebrate, I told my family about the program, to which he responded “Are you going to make tonight all about you?”. I was crushed…..

    6 mos later I left for my first two week session at school. A bit more personal info – have lost certain family members to suicide. My class at school consisted of 45 executives from all over the world between ages 40-55, only 6 of who were females. We were required to work on certain projects with partners. My partner was a great guy. Though not married, was desperately still in love with his ex girlfriend whom he had lived with for three years and who cheated on him. They remained close – even vacationing together with their kids – however he made it known to her he still loved her and wanted her back. She did not have a job, treated him horribly but kept him holding on promising that ultimately she wanted to wind up with him. He is a wealthy individual. When I heard she would agree to move in with him if he guaranteed her certain $$ if didn’t work out, I knew she may love him as a great guy, but was not in love with him.

    During our many hours of working together at school, he confessed he had rettired two years prior, started a new business with his best friend since a young boy and that his best friend had committed suicide 5 months prior. He applied to school to refocus his life and hoped to start a new company after school. What are the chances that I am partnered with someone why has lost a super close loved one to suicide? I shared my family tragedies. There was a bond that was created. We were very similar in so many other ways – both loved to learn, both introspective, both from great families where our parents our best friends, both two daughters around the same age (each one of us with a daughter that had some mental health issues). He was kind, open minded, so intelligent and comfortable expressing himself; I learned from him; there was a depth to him that drew me in. It was mutual. Over the course of 10 months, it was an amazing emotional affair. Felt had met my soul mate. There was a physical aspect but not sex. He is religious, I was and am married, which very much bothered him (he has integrity, which made me attracted to him even more). Said he would prefer to simply talk and lay next to me than anything else. My feelings were definitely stronger than his – at least I openly expressed how much I felt.

    We communicated by text over the months and saw each other back at school two more sessions. I know he felt the strong connection too. He is an introvert without lots of close friends given he had spent so much time traveling running his prior business. School ended and I missed him terribly. The core of it all was a deep friendship, but knew was falling in love. He responded that while he knew he could be a loving partner to me and that we would be great together, the timing was wrong. He was not ready to give up on his ex and disappointed that he had allowed himself to get as close as he did with a married woman. Several months later he told me he had lost the “spark” but that I was his best friend and wanted us to remain close. I was crushed. Generally what causes something to fizzle is the lack of connection – that clearly was not the case with us. I believe it was fact I am married (though he knew unhappily) and we lived different parts of the country.

    I was punished, perhaps rightfully, for my wrongdoing…. While flying home from a. vacation with my daughter she saw me reading texts, a few that were from my friend from school. She got upset stating those texts are from a man that is not Dad…. I told her it was from a classmate from school – a friend. Of course, she was still upset and said she was telling my husband as soon as we landed. I asked if she would give me the courtesy to let me tell her dad.

    That night I told my husband that my daughter had seen certain texts on my phone. They were platonic texts as the core of what we were was deep friends. I admitted to my husband however that I had strong feeling for the man and had been wrestling with it, though had not had a sexual affair. That I never intended this to happen or went looking for this, but put together with someone 12 hours a day for several weeks and we simply clicked on many levels. my husband knew our marriage had not been in good shape for years and I admitted I was likely in a. vulnerable position when this happened. He guessed right away who it was. Overall he was very calm and asked if I was still in touch with him. I said on occasion, mostly when related to school calls. I said I would cut it off. My husband is not one to deal with emotions or express himself well. Our communication has never been good. He is an avoidant personality that prefers to simply bury things and move on – how his family grew up. I on the other hand grew up with my dad who was amazing – open, loving, intelligent…..

    About a month or so later, after spending a day playing 36 holes of golf and likely a few drinks, my husband showed up at my daughter’s school where I was with my 8 year old – at an outdoor movie. He asked me to walk to the side of the school to speak to me and lost it. Screamed every nasty name in the book to me, called me a whore, a cunt, that he would tell my kids what kind of mother I was and that when he was done with me wouldn’t have a friend in town – he would destroy me. He continued to scream obsenities even when my daughters walked over. He pinned my older daughter down on a bench and screamed at her to tell him what she saw in the texts on my phone. My girls were in shock crying – my older one running away from him saying she wanted to go hurt herself.

    I made it back home with my older daughter. My sister had been staying with us and he had threw all her stuff in the street and screamed every name in the book to her before coming to the school to find me. He arrived back home with my younger dauighter that night. I was sure he would have calmed down with the girls in the house – but he did not. continued screaming at me, my sister – calling her a psycho and suicidal just like other people in my family who had killed themselves (which my daughters knew nothing about before that night nor had I wanted them too). I called the family therapist asking her what to do – she could hear my girls screaming in the background at their dad to stop yelling. Scared at their screams and not knowing how bad his state might get, she called the cops who showed up at our house and asked him to leave for the night.

    It was a nightmare. Yes, I did something horrible and understand his hurt however his temper scared the hell out of me. Doesn’t happen very often, but when he dos lose it, it can be ugly. This by far was the worst.

    The next day he apologized, asked that we forget everything and start over. For the sake of my kids and our family, I wanted to try as hard as it was. We have had further arguments since, one where he recently threatened to call cops on me while we were on the phone with our marriage counselor saying he was scared of me.(I was yelling). I am a 5’4 petite woman who has barely ever lost her temper. He was not scared of me, he threatened to call cops to get back at me for cops coming that horrible night months before. When angry, he has said I don’t have the balls to leave him. I suspect he is still very hurt about my feelings for my friend from school – I completely understand, however he refuses to discuss it. as a result, I think his anger is manifesting in other ways.

    I have become very resentful of my husband. He is a good dad and overall a good guy. However I work like crazy while he has a pretty cushy life – time each night to play sports or watch movies with the girls. I am usually working. We could never live on my huband’s salary and thefore feel the stress of doing a good job for a job don’t love but which provides my family with a very nice life. My husband finally had some $ he could have contributed to fund kids college, etc, He received an inheritance from his grandmother. But he said he would like to use the $100K to either buy a fancy sports car or join a fancy golf club. At 50 years old, Felt he deserved something nice and agreed. Stupid me. Later found out he also built up large amounts of credit card debt (mostly on family purchases – however never told me). I am financially conservative and never would have allowed our debt to accumulate like that. I often wonder if we have simply grown apart or perhaps I have outgrown him. I do believe he still loves me and will do what it takes to stay together. He said I make him a better person. However said to him “I want someone who is going to make me a better person too”. Am not sure he will. Not sure I see us growing together. a former golfer, he is obsessed with golf, plays most weekends. Working full time and having two daughters, I do not play. To be honest do not have a strong interest. Don’t know we have lots in common anymore. But overall a good guy. Is funny, helps with housework and a good dad.

    I have not however been able to forget my friend from school. I miss him horribly. I feel like he was my soulmate. However he has said he can only offer my friendship. He is an honorable man and I don’t know if he is holding back true feelings for me as he refuses to break up someone’s family ( he left his first wife and said it destroyed his kids)), or perhaps he really does feel nothing but friendship. Our connection as he has admitted is very strong and deep. Looks are not most important by any means, but I consider myself a fairly attractive woman and when at school, he had told me I was the only other woman he had met he could see himself with long term – that I showed him it was possible to fall for someone again after many many years.

    If I knew he would see me, I would likely leave my husband. I know that probably means although I care for my husband a lot and do love him, I am likely no longer in love. This makes me sad… It kills me to to hurt my girls and break up our family. I can understand why people might stay married even though not happy. It feels selfish to hurt my girls that way. Am I afraid to wind up alone?? – of course, however know not a reason to stay – not fair to my husband. I am afraid if I leave I might later regret it. Maybe deserve that.

    So I am the “cheater” as much as it pains me to say (my husband may have ben at one time too, but will never know). As bad as it al sounds, we are both decent people. Lots of good friends, live in an affluent suburb, involved in many charities, great parents. We are the couple that looks picture perfect as though we have it all from the outside; never believe everything you see.

    I welcome your thoughts. I am torn to pieces – don’t sleep. I took a month away to work remotely, having my family visit for a bit, but taking time to figure out my life. Think my husband wanted me to go as I have been difficult to live with – he feels my resentment that I am the one who works all the time….

    I don’t expect sympathy as an emotional affair can often be worse than a physical one. I find it difficult to believe that my school friend could not feel more when our connection strong. I spoke to him two months ago when he asked I submit his friend’s resume at my company. We spoke for 4 hours – we can talk about anything…. At the end of the conversation, I asked if he missed me. He became a bit upset reiterating that we can only be simply friends. How can he expect someone he said so much to (he could see himself with me long term) to simply be a friend? I have recently blocked him on social media and let him know I need to put him behind me. I have not been able to and wonder, if I were to leave my husband would he tell me he does feel more but doesn’t want to be responsible for hurting my family and having my kids hate him.

    Thank you in advance for any thoughts you might have – particularly those who may have been in my shoes – the one who cheated. Did you stay married and, if so, are you happy or do you wish you would have left? If you left, are you happy – do your kids forgive you for leaving?

    replied 5 years, 6 months ago 4 Members · 9 Replies
  • 9 Replies
  • eliza4one

    Member
    April 29, 2021 at 9:47 pm

    Warning: Brutal honesty here.

    Not sure how he is a good dad when he did what he did at your daughters’ school. He also doesn’t sound like a very good husband. Your marriage sounds a bit dysfunctional. Given what you’ve written, I don’t think I could handle being in such a volatile, toxic relationship.

    I can’t even focus on the situation with the other man…your marriage sounds very unhealthy, which isn’t good for your girls. The other man is the least of your problems right now. Get your girls in counseling. Are you in counseling? Is your husband? That might be a place to start.

  • mags

    Member
    April 29, 2021 at 10:57 pm

    Thank you so much for your reply!

    I am generally a very forgiving person however part of my issue is I am having a very difficult time getting past some of the horrible incidents that have transpired with my husband. We have been married for 19 years and, for the first 14, I felt like the luckiest woman. I am the type who looks for the good in people, am compassionate and try to see others point of view. His outburst that night at the school was uncalled for however I sometimes question, what is a normal reaction to hearing your spouse falling for someone else? Would most people lose it and act differently that under normal circumstances? If were me, would probably cry, scream and say I hated him. Think for men often shows up as anger. I tried to look at that night as an isolated incident as horrible as it was.

    Was horrible what my daughters witnessed. My 15 year old has been in counseling for years as she suffers from anxiety. Her therapist says she does not want to talk about that night at the school. My daughter is not very open but tends to bottle things up. I know she is disappointed in me after seeing me converse with another man. Though we do still have a good relationship. She does not respect my husband very much as they have very different views on everything from politics to religion, etc. My husband also doesn’t do a great job of hiding the fact he favors my younger daughter. Would not be surprised she also lost some respect for him that evening at the school. In some ways, think I should have left after that night. Have thought what is it showing my daughter when I allowed her dad to speak to me the way he did? But then my guilt kicks in and think I love another man – what would my daughter think of me for that? And also know she has said her life would be miserable if her parents were divorced.

    Fact is I don’t feel an emotional connection with my husband; do not have a sense of emotional security with him. 95% of the time a a good guy, but when he is nasty, he throws blows below the belt.

    Am trying to decide now whether he and I try counseling one more time. Have been to three different counselors in the past – none of which were helpful. Frankly I don’t know if I am 100% committed to make it work. Don’t know if what I have experienced is verbal abuse. Have not been able to be intimate with my husband since that horrible night at the school – more than a year ago. He seems to have no issue with the fact we live totally separate lives, which baffling to me. Actually think it must bother him, however he will never be the one to bring up issues for discussion. As mentioned, he would rather avoid conflict and hope issue goes away – simply turn a new page. I feel as though I have lost respect for him – am sure it comes across. Could never hate him and would never bad mouth him to his children but dont see myself ever admiring him or truly loving him again – despite his many positive qualities.

    I admit am very scared – scared to be alone, scared will lose many of our friends as he will say he didn’t want this – that it’s all my fault that things didn’t work out – that I met someone else.

    Unfortunately lots of other tough stuff going on right now. My father – my best friend who raised my siblings and I alone, in a nursing home with advanced dementia. And my sister, my best friend, has inherited the horrible gene of mental illness and need to get her into in patient treatment facility very soon. On top of all this, I have a super demanding job as a managing director at a top financial services firm. I cannot afford to not be focused on my job. My family depends on me for financial support.

    Feel if knew had. a strong support system would be more likely to leave. But with so much else on my plate, not sure I can handle all of it at once. I know could rach out to my friend from school for support – but not the wise thing to do. If he has only feelings of friendship for me, I need to keep my distance as being rejected by him will only add to my difficulties.

    Sounds as though you don’t think am crazy for being upset by my husband’s behavior. He really does have many positives too.

    Thanks much for your advice!

  • mags

    Member
    April 29, 2021 at 11:01 pm

    and although my husband has said he would go for individual counseling (including for anger management), the only counseling he has done is regarding how to deal better with my daughter (which is important). My 15 year old got sick of counseling and refuses to go anymore. She is a bright girl. Am sure she can tell that although my husband and I no longer fight, we live totally separate lives – there is no affection between us. The fact I am living on my own for a month likely tells her something.

  • eliza4one

    Member
    April 30, 2021 at 8:19 pm

    I’ve been thinking about you/your situation. Does your husband work? Curious, because it sounds like he loves spending money, but earning it (?).

    Anyway, kids are resilient. If you decide to separate from your spouse, they will be fine. Living in that type of environment can sometimes be even more detrimental than divorce!

    You will be fine on your own. You are obviously successful, independent, etc. All traits you will need.

    I was married 33 years (now married 34) when I found out my husband had an affair. I had never lived alone. Love(d) being married. I moved out within 2 months of discovering his affair. I couldn’t be in the same house as him.

    It hasn’t always been easy, but it’s not been that difficult, either. I’ve cried when I need to cry and just stayed busy. Luckily teaching is a very demanding job, so that has helped.

    I don’t have a support system, either, per se. I’m an introvert. (Which I think has helped me with living alone). I have a daughter I can confide in. No other family in the state in which I live. I have friends at work who I can confide in. But, what I have found is that, ultimately, you have to “walk alone”. You have to get through it on your own. Sure, people can listen…and be there for you. But, the work has to come from within ones self.

    All that to say…you can do it and I think you should. Do you really want to be where you are now 5 years down the road? 10 years? H*** no! Wasted years! I think you’ll really regret not making a move towards freedom!

  • mags

    Member
    April 30, 2021 at 11:43 pm

    Thank you much!! Fortunately inherited many of my father’s genes/traits – ambitious, a fighter, compassionate. However, lost my mother to suicide at 10 years old. To some extent have abandonment issues, and essentially have recently lost my father (dementia) and my sister (suffers from debilitating depression). A lot of loss to handle at once. Want to believe I have the strength to be on my own, without my husband, but don’t know. While not in love, he is someone can lean on at times and tries. We are simply very different. After being awakened to what feels like when connect with someone on so many levels (as I did with friend from school), do think would be settling to stay in my marriage. I know my husband is sorry for pain he has caused and at times think, I should be able to simply move forward. But am a very loving, giving person however don’t feel that way when comes to him.

    My gut tells me what should do, but my biggest fear is to wind up alone like my single sister – who slipped into horrible depression and basically fell apart from so much loss and loneliness.

    While not sure Hod hears me any longer, perhaps need to pray for more strength.

    I do believe could remain good friends with my husband (though know he will be very angry at me and friends won’t fly for him).

    Believe it or not, he never really spent $$ lavishly on himself other than wanting the golf club and fancy car. His mom much more successful than his dad ever was. His mom bought the dad fancy cars, vacations, etc. Pethaps my husband just assumed our situation would be the same…

    Again – thank you so much for your thoughts!

    Will have to look for your post and do same for you 😊

  • tara81

    Member
    May 1, 2021 at 6:18 am

    You are going through a lot. Like Eliza said it’s time for some brutal honesty. Your husband needs to get his act together. You are focusing on your mistake of falling for someone else, but the biggest problem is that before you fell for someone else, he told you he wasn’t in love with you. He is selfish and thinks only of himself. Not being able to talk about the issues in the marriage it’s a huge red flag. Are you willing to keep living in limbo? Seems to me that you are financially secured on your own. Your kids deserve a better example. Plus it sounds like neither one of you wants to be married to the other but it’s afraid to pull the plug. He doesn’t want to give up his lavish lifestyle and you are afraid of being lonely. But I think you are already lonely because you don’t have that intimacy and companionship from your husband. Weight in your options and think long and hard. Maybe a trial separation might help.

  • lilly0792

    Member
    May 3, 2021 at 2:42 pm

    Mags- you need to see a divorce attorney immediately. You need all assets frozen- so he can’t spend anymore of your money.

    This is not about your cheating. If that even what that was ?? This is about you wasting your life with a man who is below you in every way. I’m sorry/ but your husband is a user. He’s using you. Period. Bad dad. HORRIBLE DAD-

    PLEASE- see an attorney. This will cost you and it will be difficult – but you need to do this NOW. Right now. Get out.

  • mags

    Member
    May 5, 2021 at 3:47 pm

    Hello – thank you.

    I do believe my husband loves me and my kids very much. He is not great at handling emotions but has worked on it.

    He sold the fancy sports car so other than his golf club, does not spend much on himself. I do believe was materialistic years ago but has wised up.

    I am now the one who is distant. We talk, no fighting, but an awkwardness there – no connection. He will never be the one to bring it up – perhaps out of fear of what I might tell him. We have not been intimate since that horrible night at school. But my husband never brings up issues, more an avoider – not great at communicating.

    I try to discount that horrible night at school to some extent as I don’t know what normal behavior is when hear your wife falling for another man.

    I also neglected to previously share that last March I was traveling for work – the town where my school affair partner lived. He had made clear we could only be friends as think the guilt of how close we became ate away at him.

    Anyway, did not want to lie to my husband and told him that I wanted to see my school partner for dinner while down there. He responded “what if I ask you not to go?” To which I replied “I need to do this for me, to try and put my feelings behind me”. Despite me going – nothing happened other than a dinner – my husband has stayed with me even though my decision basically indicated was choosing my friend from school over him.

    What does bother me is how he threatened to call cops on me few months ago saying he was scared of me and saying I don’t have the balls to leave.

    Can you tell me what specifically makes you think he is horrible? I don’t deny he likes our lifestyle but frankly he could never earn the kind of $$ I do even if he worked harder.

    Thx!

  • lilly0792

    Member
    May 6, 2021 at 6:45 am

    Mags-

    You wrote that he told you he didn’t have feelings for you, didn’t want to have sex with you. Refused to give you his phone and deleted texts before he gave it to you. You tried, desperately to help your marriage and he didn’t want to do anything to help your marriage. He treats you badly. His outburst was not because he learned that you were interested in another man. That was pure evil. That rage in front of your children is absolutely inexcusable. We’ve all been cheated on here – none of us have done that. Where is this “love” you feel from your husband ?

Log in to reply.